Jubilee Properties Pty Ltd v Parkview Farm Pty Ltd [2014] NSWSC 563

Jubilee Properties Pty Ltd v Parkview Farm Pty Ltd [2014] NSWSC 563

Parkview failed to establish any misuse of trust funds, breach of trust, improper exercise of trustee powers, entitlement to remove the Trustee, or unilateral standing as a minority unit holder to require the Trust to be wound up. Clause 6 and clause 6.5, properly construed in light of the Trust Deed and the surrounding commercial circumstances, allowed winding up only by the unit holders jointly, not by Parkview alone. The Trustee's impugned acts, including the Perpetual Guarantee, use of ING facilities and amendments to the Trust Deed directed at the caveat, were not shown to have been made otherwise than honestly, in good faith, with genuine consideration of the Trust's interests, and...

Jurisdiction
Australia
Judgment Date
12 May 2014
Procedural Posture
Equity Division Expedition List; Cross Claim Concerning Trusts, Alleged Breach of Trust, Removal of Trustee and Winding Up of Trust / Principal Judgment After Hearing
Outcome
Parkview's claim against the Trustee was dismissed.
Legal Topics
['breach of Trust' 'removal of Trustee' 'winding Up of Unit Trust' 'minority Unit Holder Standing' 'construction of Trust Deed' 'trustee Power to Amend Trust Deed' 'caveatable Interests' 'trustee Borrowing and Guarantees']
['equity' 'trusts' 'property' 'commercial Law'] ['breach of Trust' 'removal of Trustee' 'winding Up of Unit Trust' 'minority Unit Holder Standing' 'construction of Trust Deed' 'trustee Power to Amend Trust Deed' 'caveatable Interests' 'trustee Borrowing and Guarantees']

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 1 Authorities cited 2 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 1
Sign in to unlock

Procedural Posture

Equity Division Expedition List; Cross Claim Concerning Trusts, Alleged Breach of Trust, Removal of Trustee and Winding Up of Trust / Principal Judgment After Hearing

Legal Issues

  1. 1 ['Whether the Trustee acted in breach of trust by misapplying funds drawn under the Second ING Loan.' "Whether the Trustee acted in breach of trust by providing the Perpetual Guarantee for Jubilee Group's obligations." 'Whether the Trustee acted in breach of trust by its use of ING facilities and Jubilee Group funding.' 'Whether matters concerning the Third Spring Loan justified adverse findings or removal of the Trustee.' 'Whether Parkview, as a minority unit holder, had standing under clause 6 or clause 6.5 of the Trust Deed to require the Trust to be wound up.' 'Whether the Trustee had power to make the Fourth and Fifth Variations to the Trust Deed.' 'Whether the Fourth and Fifth Variations were made in breach of trust or for an improper purpose.' 'Whether the Trustee should be removed or the Trust wound up.']

Ratio Decidendi

Parkview failed to establish any misuse of trust funds, breach of trust, improper exercise of trustee powers, entitlement to remove the Trustee, or unilateral standing as a minority unit holder to require the Trust to be wound up. Clause 6 and clause 6.5, properly construed in light of the Trust Deed and the surrounding commercial circumstances, allowed winding up only by the unit holders jointly, not by Parkview alone. The Trustee's impugned acts, including the Perpetual Guarantee, use of ING facilities and amendments to the Trust Deed directed at the caveat, were not shown to have been made otherwise than honestly, in good faith, with genuine consideration of the Trust's interests, and...

Court Disposition

Parkview's claim against the Trustee was dismissed.

Orders

  • ['Claim against trustee dismissed.' 'Counsel invited to bring in short minutes to give effect to the reasons.']