Chaina & Ors v The Presbyterian Church (NSW) Property Trust & Ors [2008] NSWSC 290

Chaina & Ors v The Presbyterian Church (NSW) Property Trust & Ors [2008] NSWSC 290

Defendants established a reasonable and necessary need to access the formulae and manufacturing processes of new and reformulated products to properly test the basis of the plaintiffs' damages claim, particularly given the asserted unique qualities of the products and the inadequacy of reverse engineering. Confidentiality concerns can be managed by court orders. Provision of sample products alone is insufficient in the circumstances.

Parties
First Plaintiff: Mathew Chaina; Second Plaintiff: George Chaina; Third Plaintiff: Rita Chaina; Fourth Plaintiff: Proton Technology Pty Limited; Fifth Plaintiff: Deluxe Chemicals Pty Limited; Sixth Plaintiff: Jean-Pierre Chaina; First Defendant: The Presbyterian Church (New South Wales) Property Trust; Second Defendant: Robert Iles; Third Defendant: Christine Alexander; Fourth Defendant: Gordon Black; Fifth Defendant: Ewen Brown; Sixth Defendant: Richard Bull; Seventh Defendant: Bruce Christian; Eighth Defendant: Simon Fraser; Ninth Defendant: Roy Johnston; Eleventh Defendant: William McLaren; Twelfth Defendant: Philip Mitchell; Thirteenth Defendant: Tony Pfeiffer; Fourteenth Defendant: Robert Richards; Fifteenth Defendant: Harry Taylor; Sixteenth Defendant: Peter Wolnizer
Jurisdiction
Australia
Judgment Date
07 April 2008
Procedural Posture
Civil / Interlocutory Application on Discovery of Confidential Information/formulae
Outcome
Orders to be made in accordance with defendants' motion; parties to agree on confidentiality conditions and costs submissions before final orders.
Legal Topics
Discovery, Confidential Information, Expert Evidence, Case Management
Civil Procedure Discovery Confidential Information Expert Evidence Case Management

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 2 Authorities cited 4 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 9
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Mathew Chaina

First Plaintiff

George Chaina

Second Plaintiff

Rita Chaina

Third Plaintiff

Proton Technology Pty Limited

Fourth Plaintiff

Deluxe Chemicals Pty Limited

Fifth Plaintiff

Jean-Pierre Chaina

Sixth Plaintiff

The Presbyterian Church (New South Wales) Property Trust

First Defendant

Robert Iles

Second Defendant

Christine Alexander

Third Defendant

Gordon Black

Fourth Defendant

Ewen Brown

Fifth Defendant

Richard Bull

Sixth Defendant

Bruce Christian

Seventh Defendant

Simon Fraser

Eighth Defendant

Roy Johnston

Ninth Defendant

William McLaren

Eleventh Defendant

Philip Mitchell

Twelfth Defendant

Tony Pfeiffer

Thirteenth Defendant

Robert Richards

Fourteenth Defendant

Harry Taylor

Fifteenth Defendant

Peter Wolnizer

Sixteenth Defendant

Procedural Posture

Civil / Interlocutory Application on Discovery of Confidential Information/formulae

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether defendants should be provided with the formulae and manufacturing process for products claimed by plaintiffs notwithstanding confidentiality
  2. 2 Whether provision of product samples alone is sufficient for defendants to test plaintiffs' claims
  3. 3 Whether reverse engineering is a reasonable or sufficient method in the context of this litigation

Ratio Decidendi

Defendants established a reasonable and necessary need to access the formulae and manufacturing processes of new and reformulated products to properly test the basis of the plaintiffs' damages claim, particularly given the asserted unique qualities of the products and the inadequacy of reverse engineering. Confidentiality concerns can be managed by court orders. Provision of sample products alone is insufficient in the circumstances.

Court Disposition

Orders to be made in accordance with defendants' motion; parties to agree on confidentiality conditions and costs submissions before final orders.