ACN 103 830 333 (formerly S.J. Holdings (Aust) Pty Ltd) v Property Options 1 Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 938

ACN 103 830 333 (formerly S.J. Holdings (Aust) Pty Ltd) v Property Options 1 Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 938

Property Options 1 Pty Ltd and Lora Taha, as borrower and guarantor, are liable to ACN 103 830 333 Pty Ltd for the sum of $173,343.32 as debts under the loan and mortgage documents executed for the Wallerawang Properties; Sam Agostino and Jacqueline Pearce are, in principle, entitled to an order for re-transfer (specific performance) of the Marulan Property by Property Options 1 Pty Ltd, subject to repayment of quantified advances, but final relief is deferred pending further information concerning the mortgage and property value. The claim for a charge over the Parramatta Property is dismissed due to insufficient evidence of an enforceable oral agreement.

Jurisdiction
Australia
Judgment Date
11 August 2023
Procedural Posture
Civil / Principal Judgment – Reasons, Further Orders Pending Party Input
Outcome
Judgment for first plaintiff against Property Options 1 Pty Ltd and Lora Taha for $173,343.32; in principle, specific performance or damages in respect of Marulan Property for Sam Agostino and Jacqueline Pearce against Property Options 1 Pty Ltd, quantum and final relief pending; claim for charge over Parramatta...
Legal Topics
['mortgages and Securities' 'loans and Guarantees' 'oral Agreements Relating to Land' 'liquidated Damages' 'caveats on Title' 'specific Performance' 'trusts']
['equity' 'land Law' 'contract Law'] ['mortgages and Securities' 'loans and Guarantees' 'oral Agreements Relating to Land' 'liquidated Damages' 'caveats on Title' 'specific Performance' 'trusts']

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 1 Authorities cited 2 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 1
Sign in to unlock

Procedural Posture

Civil / Principal Judgment – Reasons, Further Orders Pending Party Input

Legal Issues

  1. 1 ['Whether Property Options 1 Pty Ltd and Lora Taha are liable for debts under loan, mortgage and guarantee documents relating to Wallerawang Properties' 'Whether Property Options 1 Pty Ltd holds Marulan Property on constructive or resulting trust for Sam Agostino and Jacqueline Pearce and whether specific performance or damages are appropriate' 'Whether Lora Taha orally agreed to grant a charge over her Parramatta Property to the plaintiffs']

Ratio Decidendi

Property Options 1 Pty Ltd and Lora Taha, as borrower and guarantor, are liable to ACN 103 830 333 Pty Ltd for the sum of $173,343.32 as debts under the loan and mortgage documents executed for the Wallerawang Properties; Sam Agostino and Jacqueline Pearce are, in principle, entitled to an order for re-transfer (specific performance) of the Marulan Property by Property Options 1 Pty Ltd, subject to repayment of quantified advances, but final relief is deferred pending further information concerning the mortgage and property value. The claim for a charge over the Parramatta Property is dismissed due to insufficient evidence of an enforceable oral agreement.

Court Disposition

Judgment for first plaintiff against Property Options 1 Pty Ltd and Lora Taha for $173,343.32; in principle, specific performance or damages in respect of Marulan Property for Sam Agostino and Jacqueline Pearce against Property Options 1 Pty Ltd, quantum and final relief pending; claim for charge over Parramatta...

Orders

  • ['Judgment for ACN 103 830 333 Pty Ltd against Property Options 1 Pty Ltd and Lora Taha for $173,343.32' 'Specific performance in principle: Property Options 1 Pty Ltd to re-transfer Marulan Property to Sam Agostino and Jacqueline Pearce, subject to repayment of advances (to be quantified)' 'Alternative order in...