Toga Pty Limited v Perpetual Nominees Limited and CFS Managed Property Limited [2012] NSWADT 80

Toga Pty Limited v Perpetual Nominees Limited and CFS Managed Property Limited [2012] NSWADT 80

The Tribunal finds that while Item 14 (Special Covenant) is included in the Option Lease, the common intention and bargain between the parties was that a rent/outgoings free period applies only in the initial term, not in the Option Lease. As the Applicant does not consent to rectification, the Tribunal cannot order rectification to exclude Item 14 from the Option Lease, but under s72(1)(f)(iii) declares that the Applicant is obliged to pay Annual Rent and Lessee's Contributions for the first year of the Option Lease (13 November 2010 to 12 November 2011).

Parties
Applicant/cross Respondent: Toga Pty Ltd; Respondent/cross Applicant: Perpetual Nominees Ltd; Respondent/cross Applicant: CFS Managed Property Limited
Jurisdiction
Australia
Judgment Date
30 April 2012
Procedural Posture
Claim for Declaration of Rights and Liabilities and Cross Application for Rectification/payment / Principal Judgment
Outcome
Declaration granted; leave to file amended cross application; rectification not ordered; costs reserved.
Legal Topics
Retail Leases, Contract Construction, Rectification, Fidelity of the Bargain, Implied Terms, Tribunal Statutory Powers
Contract Law Property Law Retail Leases Contract Construction Rectification Fidelity of the Bargain Implied Terms Tribunal Statutory Powers

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 6 Authorities cited 31 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 4
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Toga Pty Ltd

Applicant/cross Respondent

Perpetual Nominees Ltd

Respondent/cross Applicant

CFS Managed Property Limited

Respondent/cross Applicant

Procedural Posture

Claim for Declaration of Rights and Liabilities and Cross Application for Rectification/payment / Principal Judgment

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Does the Special Covenant (Item 14) apply to the Option Lease?
  2. 2 Can the Sublease be rectified to exclude Item 14 in the Option Lease absent consent?
  3. 3 What are the rights and liabilities of the parties under the Option Lease?

Ratio Decidendi

The Tribunal finds that while Item 14 (Special Covenant) is included in the Option Lease, the common intention and bargain between the parties was that a rent/outgoings free period applies only in the initial term, not in the Option Lease. As the Applicant does not consent to rectification, the Tribunal cannot order rectification to exclude Item 14 from the Option Lease, but under s72(1)(f)(iii) declares that the Applicant is obliged to pay Annual Rent and Lessee's Contributions for the first year of the Option Lease (13 November 2010 to 12 November 2011).

Court Disposition

Declaration granted; leave to file amended cross application; rectification not ordered; costs reserved.

Orders

  • Cross Applicants granted leave to file Amended Cross Application.
  • Applicant obliged to pay Respondents the Annual Rent and Lessee's Contributions from 13 November 2010 to 12 November 2011 under the Option Lease.