Weston v Aughton Flats Pty Ltd, in the matter of Empire Property and Investment Group Pty Ltd (in liq) [2019] FCA 310

Weston v Aughton Flats Pty Ltd, in the matter of Empire Property and Investment Group Pty Ltd (in liq) [2019] FCA 310

Defendant is entitled to part but not all of the legal costs claimed; recovery of legal costs from plaintiff requires proof of reasonable incurrence and amount, proper authorisation under articles, and compliance with statutory requirements. Only legal fees incurred up to the appointment of the liquidator, and limited reasonable costs for discharge of lien and settlement tasks after appointment, are payable out of the fund. No entitlement to legal costs incurred after liquidator's appointment absent contractual or statutory basis. Each party is to bear its own costs for proceedings after 7 July 2017.

Jurisdiction
Australia
Judgment Date
08 March 2019
Procedural Posture
Corporations Matter / Judgment Following Hearing of Application and Determination of Issues
Outcome
Defendant entitled to part but not all of legal costs; parties to provide draft orders reflecting reasons within 14 days; balance of fund to be released to plaintiffs; each party to bear its own costs from 7 July 2017.
Legal Topics
['company Title Schemes' 'lien Over Shares' 'recovery of Levies, Interest and Legal Costs' 'apportionment of Legal Costs' 'liquidation Procedures']
['corporations' 'corporate Insolvency'] ['company Title Schemes' 'lien Over Shares' 'recovery of Levies, Interest and Legal Costs' 'apportionment of Legal Costs' 'liquidation Procedures']

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 1 Authorities cited 2 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 1
Sign in to unlock

Procedural Posture

Corporations Matter / Judgment Following Hearing of Application and Determination of Issues

Legal Issues

  1. 1 ['Is the defendant entitled under its articles of association to levy legal fees against the plaintiff in respect of its shares absent specific procedures?' "Should the defendant pay the plaintiffs' costs of the originating process and the application?" "Should costs be deducted from the defendant's share of the sale proceeds?" 'Should there be orders for the distribution of the fund accordingly?']

Ratio Decidendi

Defendant is entitled to part but not all of the legal costs claimed; recovery of legal costs from plaintiff requires proof of reasonable incurrence and amount, proper authorisation under articles, and compliance with statutory requirements. Only legal fees incurred up to the appointment of the liquidator, and limited reasonable costs for discharge of lien and settlement tasks after appointment, are payable out of the fund. No entitlement to legal costs incurred after liquidator's appointment absent contractual or statutory basis. Each party is to bear its own costs for proceedings after 7 July 2017.

Court Disposition

Defendant entitled to part but not all of legal costs; parties to provide draft orders reflecting reasons within 14 days; balance of fund to be released to plaintiffs; each party to bear its own costs from 7 July 2017.

Orders

  • ['Parties to provide draft orders reflecting reasons within 14 days.' 'If parties unable to agree, each to provide draft orders and submissions (max two pages).' "Plaintiffs entitled to retain $10,000 from fund pending determination of amount of costs payable by defendant in respect of plaintiffs' costs incurred...