Callaghan v The Queen [1952] HCA 55

Callaghan v The Queen [1952] HCA 55

A conviction under s. 291A is not warranted by a degree of negligence no greater than would suffice to make the accused civilly liable. Because the jury was directed that ordinary civil negligence could support conviction under s. 291A, the direction was wrong and the conviction had to be set aside. In the circumstances, including the acquittal of manslaughter and service of part of the sentence, no new trial should be ordered.

Jurisdiction
Australia
Procedural Posture
Criminal Appeal by Special Leave / High Court Appeal From Conviction Under S. 291 a After Indictment for Manslaughter
Outcome
Special leave granted; application treated as appeal and heard instanter; appeal allowed; conviction and sentence set aside; conviction quashed without a new trial.
Legal Topics
['manslaughter' 'criminal Negligence' 'dangerous Driving Causing Death' 'statutory Interpretation' 'jury Directions']
['criminal Law'] ['manslaughter' 'criminal Negligence' 'dangerous Driving Causing Death' 'statutory Interpretation' 'jury Directions']

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 1 Authorities cited 2 Party arguments 1 Amounts and remedies 1
Sign in to unlock

Procedural Posture

Criminal Appeal by Special Leave / High Court Appeal From Conviction Under S. 291 a After Indictment for Manslaughter

Legal Issues

  1. 1 ['Whether conviction under s. 291A of The Criminal Code 1913-1945 W.A. is warranted by negligence no greater than would suffice for civil liability.' 'Whether the trial judge wrongly directed the jury that a lack of care falling below gross negligence could support a verdict under s. 291A.' 'Whether a new trial should be ordered after the conviction under s. 291A was set aside.']

Ratio Decidendi

A conviction under s. 291A is not warranted by a degree of negligence no greater than would suffice to make the accused civilly liable. Because the jury was directed that ordinary civil negligence could support conviction under s. 291A, the direction was wrong and the conviction had to be set aside. In the circumstances, including the acquittal of manslaughter and service of part of the sentence, no new trial should be ordered.

Court Disposition

Special leave granted; application treated as appeal and heard instanter; appeal allowed; conviction and sentence set aside; conviction quashed without a new trial.

Orders

  • ['Special leave granted.' 'Application to be treated as the appeal and heard instanter.' 'Appeal allowed.' 'Conviction and sentence set aside.' 'The conviction should be set aside.' 'No new trial ordered; conviction quashed.']