Perron (as Trustee for Brennan Trust) v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) [1972] HCA 47

Perron (as Trustee for Brennan Trust) v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) [1972] HCA 47

The Commissioner was not confined to forming an opinion under s. 99A(2) only when favourable to the taxpayer, nor was any taxpayer application required. The matters considered, including the size of the trust income and applicable tax rates, were not irrelevant, arbitrary, fanciful or inconsistent with the legislative purpose, so there was no basis to interfere with the Commissioner's opinion that it would be unreasonable for s. 99A to apply; the assessment under s. 99 therefore stood.

Jurisdiction
Australia
Procedural Posture
Tax Appeal / Appeal Against an Assessment Raised Pursuant to S. 99 of the Income Tax Assessment Act
Outcome
Appeal dismissed.
Legal Topics
['assessment of Trust Income' 'income to Which No Beneficiary Is Presently Entitled' "commissioner's Opinion Under S. 99 A(2)" 'judicial Review of Discretionary Tax Opinion']
['taxation' 'trusts' 'administrative Law'] ['assessment of Trust Income' 'income to Which No Beneficiary Is Presently Entitled' "commissioner's Opinion Under S. 99 A(2)" 'judicial Review of Discretionary Tax Opinion']

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 1 Authorities cited 2 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 1
Sign in to unlock

Procedural Posture

Tax Appeal / Appeal Against an Assessment Raised Pursuant to S. 99 of the Income Tax Assessment Act

Legal Issues

  1. 1 ['Whether income of the trust estate should have been assessed under s. 99 or s. 99A of the Income Tax Assessment Act.' "Whether s. 99A(2) is a dispensing power that the Commissioner cannot exercise against the taxpayer's interests so as to increase tax payable." 'Whether the Commissioner may form an opinion under s. 99A(2) without an application by the taxpayer.' "Whether the Commissioner's consideration of the trust income amount and applicable tax rates invalidated the opinion that it would be unreasonable for s. 99A to apply."]

Ratio Decidendi

The Commissioner was not confined to forming an opinion under s. 99A(2) only when favourable to the taxpayer, nor was any taxpayer application required. The matters considered, including the size of the trust income and applicable tax rates, were not irrelevant, arbitrary, fanciful or inconsistent with the legislative purpose, so there was no basis to interfere with the Commissioner's opinion that it would be unreasonable for s. 99A to apply; the assessment under s. 99 therefore stood.

Court Disposition

Appeal dismissed.

Orders

  • ['Order accordingly.' 'The appeal is dismissed.']