Construction, Forestry, Mining & Energy Union v Australian Industrial Relations Commission [1999] FCA 847

Construction, Forestry, Mining & Energy Union v Australian Industrial Relations Commission [1999] FCA 847

The Full Bench of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission erred in law by failing to appreciate the distinction between the functions exercised by Commissioner Hingley (quasi-judicial, individual rights under unfair dismissal provisions) and Commissioner Hodder (arbitral, award for future workplace relations), resulting in jurisdictional error. However, s150 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 operates as a privative clause to protect the Full Bench's quashing of the Increase in Hands Award from prerogative relief. The certification of the Mine Management Pty Limited Certified Agreement 1998 was invalid, as there was no 'single business' in operation at the time with employees to...

Jurisdiction
Australia
Judgment Date
25 June 1999
Procedural Posture
Federal Court Judicial Review / Prerogative Relief Application and Associated Declaratory Relief / Consolidated Proceedings / Final Judgment and Orders After Hearing
Outcome
Applicant's claim for prerogative relief dismissed; declaration of invalidity of certified agreement granted; related proceeding dismissed.
Legal Topics
['certified Agreements Under Workplace Relations Act 1996' 'prerogative Relief (prohibition, Mandamus, Certiorari)' 'jurisdictional Error and Privative Clauses' 'successor Employer Obligations (s149 Workplace Relations Act)' 'inconsistency Between Awards and Certified Agreements' 'award Validity and Parties Bound' 'remedies for Unfair Dismissal' 'procedural Requirements Under the Workplace Relations Act']
['industrial Law' 'administrative Law' 'employment Law'] ['certified Agreements Under Workplace Relations Act 1996' 'prerogative Relief (prohibition, Mandamus, Certiorari)' 'jurisdictional Error and Privative Clauses' 'successor Employer Obligations (s149 Workplace Relations Act)' 'inconsistency Between Awards and Certified Agreements' 'award Validity and Parties Bound' 'remedies for Unfair Dismissal' 'procedural Requirements Under the Workplace Relations Act']

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 1 Authorities cited 2 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 1
Sign in to unlock

Procedural Posture

Federal Court Judicial Review / Prerogative Relief Application and Associated Declaratory Relief / Consolidated Proceedings / Final Judgment and Orders After Hearing

Legal Issues

  1. 1 ["Whether the Full Bench of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission erred in law in quashing Commissioner Hodder's Increase in Hands Award" "Whether the Full Bench's error was jurisdictional so as to attract prerogative relief" 'Whether s150 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 immunised the Full Bench order from review' 'Whether, on construction, the successor as mine operator (Mine Management Pty Limited) was bound by the Increase in Hands Award' 'Whether there was an inconsistency between the Increase in Hands Award and a certified agreement under Part VIB of the Act' 'Whether the certification of the Mine Management Pty Limited Certified Agreement 1998 was valid']

Ratio Decidendi

The Full Bench of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission erred in law by failing to appreciate the distinction between the functions exercised by Commissioner Hingley (quasi-judicial, individual rights under unfair dismissal provisions) and Commissioner Hodder (arbitral, award for future workplace relations), resulting in jurisdictional error. However, s150 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 operates as a privative clause to protect the Full Bench's quashing of the Increase in Hands Award from prerogative relief. The certification of the Mine Management Pty Limited Certified Agreement 1998 was invalid, as there was no 'single business' in operation at the time with employees to...

Court Disposition

Applicant's claim for prerogative relief dismissed; declaration of invalidity of certified agreement granted; related proceeding dismissed.

Orders

  • ['It be declared that the order of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission made on 1 February 1999 certifying the agreement known as Mine Management Pty Limited Certified Agreement 1998 is void and of no effect.' 'Otherwise the proceeding be dismissed.' 'The proceeding N166 of 1999 be dismissed.']