Brooke v Public Trustee [2001] NSWSC 715

Brooke v Public Trustee [2001] NSWSC 715

The Court accepted the Plaintiff's evidence and the corroborating evidence of independent witnesses that the deceased intended the initial payment of about $15,000 to be a gift to the Plaintiff and that the Plaintiff paid the whole balance of the mortgage and the property expenses. Treating the payment as not made by the Plaintiff merely because it was paid directly from the deceased's bank account would elevate form over substance. The deceased therefore held, and the Public Trustee after his death held, the shares and the St. Kilda unit on resulting trust for the Plaintiff absolutely; alternatively, a constructive trust would arise. Because the Plaintiff thereby had secure...

Jurisdiction
Australia
Judgment Date
22 August 2001
Procedural Posture
Amended Summons Seeking a Declaration of Trust and Provision Under the Family Provision Act 1982 / Hearing Before a Master in the Equity Division
Outcome
Plaintiff succeeded on the declaration of trust claim and received additional family provision from the estate.
Legal Topics
['resulting Trust' 'constructive Trust' 'company Title Home Unit' 'adult Child Family Provision Claim' 'need for Accommodation' 'competing Claims of Residuary Beneficiaries']
['trusts' 'succession' 'family Provision' 'wills and Probate'] ['resulting Trust' 'constructive Trust' 'company Title Home Unit' 'adult Child Family Provision Claim' 'need for Accommodation' 'competing Claims of Residuary Beneficiaries']

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 1 Authorities cited 2 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 1
Sign in to unlock

Procedural Posture

Amended Summons Seeking a Declaration of Trust and Provision Under the Family Provision Act 1982 / Hearing Before a Master in the Equity Division

Legal Issues

  1. 1 ['Whether the Public Trustee held 2,400 shares in The Rand Flats Pty Ltd, entitling occupation of Flat 7/29 Marine Parade, St. Kilda, on trust for the Plaintiff absolutely.' 'Whether the circumstances gave rise to a resulting trust in favour of the Plaintiff over the St. Kilda unit.' 'Whether, alternatively, the circumstances gave rise to a constructive trust in favour of the Plaintiff over the St. Kilda unit.' 'Whether the Plaintiff was entitled to provision out of the deceased estate under the Family Provision Act 1982, and if so in what amount, having regard to her circumstances and the competing claims of residuary beneficiaries.']

Ratio Decidendi

The Court accepted the Plaintiff's evidence and the corroborating evidence of independent witnesses that the deceased intended the initial payment of about $15,000 to be a gift to the Plaintiff and that the Plaintiff paid the whole balance of the mortgage and the property expenses. Treating the payment as not made by the Plaintiff merely because it was paid directly from the deceased's bank account would elevate form over substance. The deceased therefore held, and the Public Trustee after his death held, the shares and the St. Kilda unit on resulting trust for the Plaintiff absolutely; alternatively, a constructive trust would arise. Because the Plaintiff thereby had secure...

Court Disposition

Plaintiff succeeded on the declaration of trust claim and received additional family provision from the estate.

Orders

  • ['Declaration as in prayer 1 in the amended summons.' 'The Plaintiff receive out of the estate of the late Sydney Robert White one third of residue, that benefit to be borne by the part of residue to which under the terms of the will of the Deceased his grand-daughter Kate White is conditionally entitled.' 'The...