Maurice Gibbons Eagle Knight v Josiah Charles Eagle Knight [1912] HCA 36

Maurice Gibbons Eagle Knight v Josiah Charles Eagle Knight [1912] HCA 36

The majority (Barton and Isaacs JJ.) held that the words 'survive me' should be given their ordinary meaning, restricting the class of beneficiaries to those children of Elizabeth Mary Steinbach and Josiah Charles Eagle Knight who were born during the testator's lifetime and living at his death. There was no context justifying a broader interpretation, and the rule of convenience applies only as needed for distribution of particular funds, not to extend the class beyond its ordinary meaning.

Parties
Appellant: Maurice Gibbons Eagle Knight; Respondent: Josiah Charles Eagle Knight; Beneficiary: Elizabeth Mary Steinbach; Plaintiff (originating Summons): Marie Louise Steinbach; Plaintiff (originating Summons): Charles Horace Steinbach
Jurisdiction
Australia
Judgment Date
31 May 1912
Procedural Posture
Consolidated Appeals / On Appeal From the Supreme Court of Tasmania
Outcome
Appeal dismissed (by majority)
Legal Topics
Construction of Wills, Meaning of 'survive' in Testamentary Gifts, Class Closing for Beneficiaries, Rule of Convenience
Wills and Estates Succession Law Construction of Wills Meaning of 'survive' in Testamentary Gifts Class Closing for Beneficiaries Rule of Convenience

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 3 Authorities cited 25 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 7
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Maurice Gibbons Eagle Knight

Appellant

Josiah Charles Eagle Knight

Respondent

Elizabeth Mary Steinbach

Beneficiary

Marie Louise Steinbach

Plaintiff (originating Summons)

Charles Horace Steinbach

Plaintiff (originating Summons)

Procedural Posture

Consolidated Appeals / On Appeal From the Supreme Court of Tasmania

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether the phrase 'such of the children...as shall survive me' in the will includes only children born during the testator's lifetime and living at his death, or also includes children born after his death;
  2. 2 When the class of beneficiaries entitled under the residuary trust fund becomes closed: at the testator's death, when a beneficiary attains a specified age, or when separate funds become distributable.

Ratio Decidendi

The majority (Barton and Isaacs JJ.) held that the words 'survive me' should be given their ordinary meaning, restricting the class of beneficiaries to those children of Elizabeth Mary Steinbach and Josiah Charles Eagle Knight who were born during the testator's lifetime and living at his death. There was no context justifying a broader interpretation, and the rule of convenience applies only as needed for distribution of particular funds, not to extend the class beyond its ordinary meaning.

Court Disposition

Appeal dismissed (by majority)

Orders

  • The costs of all parties as between solicitor and client to be paid out of the estate.