North Eastern Dairy Co Ltd v Dairy Industry Authority (NSW) [1975] HCA 45

North Eastern Dairy Co Ltd v Dairy Industry Authority (NSW) [1975] HCA 45

The operation of reg. 79(10)(c) and sections 23, 33, and certificate conditions of the Dairy Industry Authority Act 1970 (NSW), as they relate to the sale and supply in New South Wales of milk pasteurised in Victoria by the plaintiffs, constitute direct burdens on interstate trade and commerce, are not necessary for public health, and discriminate against interstate products. Accordingly, these provisions violate s. 92 of the Constitution and are inapplicable or invalid to the extent they restrict such interstate transactions.

Jurisdiction
Australia
Procedural Posture
Stated Case / Final Judgment
Outcome
In favour of the plaintiffs, North Eastern Dairy Co Ltd and Carrolls Food Mart Pty Ltd
Legal Topics
['section 92 of the Constitution' 'validity and Operation of State Regulations Affecting Interstate Trade' 'regulation of Food and Dairy Industries']
['constitutional Law' 'administrative Law' 'trade and Commerce'] ['section 92 of the Constitution' 'validity and Operation of State Regulations Affecting Interstate Trade' 'regulation of Food and Dairy Industries']

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 1 Authorities cited 2 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 1
Sign in to unlock

Procedural Posture

Stated Case / Final Judgment

Legal Issues

  1. 1 ['Whether reg. 79(10)(c) of the Pure Food Regulations (NSW) is void for being contrary to s. 92 of the Constitution or ultra vires s. 54 of the Pure Food Act' 'Whether provisions of reg. 79(10)(c) and s. 23 of the Dairy Industry Authority Act are inapplicable to interstate sales of milk by reason of s. 92' 'Whether conditions imposed on certificates of registration for milk vendors restricting supply to pasteurised milk from specified NSW suppliers breach s. 92' 'Whether the restriction on registration and sale of Victorian pasteurised milk for supply in NSW is permissible regulation or unconstitutional prohibition']

Ratio Decidendi

The operation of reg. 79(10)(c) and sections 23, 33, and certificate conditions of the Dairy Industry Authority Act 1970 (NSW), as they relate to the sale and supply in New South Wales of milk pasteurised in Victoria by the plaintiffs, constitute direct burdens on interstate trade and commerce, are not necessary for public health, and discriminate against interstate products. Accordingly, these provisions violate s. 92 of the Constitution and are inapplicable or invalid to the extent they restrict such interstate transactions.

Court Disposition

In favour of the plaintiffs, North Eastern Dairy Co Ltd and Carrolls Food Mart Pty Ltd

Orders

  • ['Reg. 79(10)(c) of the Pure Food Regulations (NSW) declared void or inapplicable for being contrary to s. 92 of the Constitution.' 'Conditions on certificates of registration restricting sale to milk pasteurised by approved NSW suppliers declared inapplicable or invalid as they relate to interstate trade.'...