Liang by her Tutor Yuen [2012] NSWSC 365

Liang by her Tutor Yuen [2012] NSWSC 365

The Court held that it was appropriate to appoint Vanessa's mother and Chit Ying Ng as trustees and establish the Vanessa Liang Trust because the proposed private trust was in Vanessa's best interests: it was expected to produce a better return than administration by the NSW Trustee and Guardian, the proposed investment in bank term deposits was safe, and both proposed trustees had suitable employment histories, financial experience, and financial standing.

Jurisdiction
Australia
Judgment Date
24 April 2012
Procedural Posture
Application Concerning Investment and Settlement of Damages Recovered by a Minor / Principal Judgment on Application to Establish a Trust Instead of Payment to the NSW Trustee and Guardian
Outcome
Application granted; trust established and trustees appointed for the benefit of Vanessa Liang.
Legal Topics
['damages Recovered by Minor' 'payment Into Court' 'appointment of Trustees' "private Trust for Minor's Settlement Funds" 'nsw Trustee and Guardian Fees' 'parens Patriae Best Interests' 'investment of Settlement Funds']
['civil Procedure' 'damages' 'trusts' 'children'] ['damages Recovered by Minor' 'payment Into Court' 'appointment of Trustees' "private Trust for Minor's Settlement Funds" 'nsw Trustee and Guardian Fees' 'parens Patriae Best Interests' 'investment of Settlement Funds']

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 1 Authorities cited 2 Party arguments 1 Amounts and remedies 1
Sign in to unlock

Procedural Posture

Application Concerning Investment and Settlement of Damages Recovered by a Minor / Principal Judgment on Application to Establish a Trust Instead of Payment to the NSW Trustee and Guardian

Legal Issues

  1. 1 ["Whether damages recovered on behalf of the minor should be paid to the NSW Trustee and Guardian or instead paid into a private trust for the minor's benefit." "Whether the proposed trustees and proposed investment arrangements sufficiently protected and preserved the minor's settlement moneys." "What considerations should guide the Court when asked to appoint private trustees for a minor's damages settlement."]

Ratio Decidendi

The Court held that it was appropriate to appoint Vanessa's mother and Chit Ying Ng as trustees and establish the Vanessa Liang Trust because the proposed private trust was in Vanessa's best interests: it was expected to produce a better return than administration by the NSW Trustee and Guardian, the proposed investment in bank term deposits was safe, and both proposed trustees had suitable employment histories, financial experience, and financial standing.

Court Disposition

Application granted; trust established and trustees appointed for the benefit of Vanessa Liang.

Orders

  • ['Connie Yuen and Chit Ying Ng (known as Sanny Lok) jointly are appointed as trustees of a trust to be established for the benefit of Vanessa Liang born on 30 March 2000.' 'The Trust shall be known as the Vanessa Liang Trust and its sole purpose shall be for the sole benefit, maintenance, advancement and education...