Lynch v. The Canada North-West. Land Co. / South Dufferin v. Morden / Gibbins v. Barber

Lynch v. The Canada North-West. Land Co. / South Dufferin v. Morden / Gibbins v. Barber

The majority held that the 10% addition on unpaid municipal taxes is an additional tax or penalty incident to provincial authority over municipal institutions and direct taxation under s.92, not 'interest' within s.91 of the BNA Act; accordingly the provincial provision authorizing the addition is intra vires and the appeals are allowed (Gwynne J. dissenting).

Citation
(1891) 19 SCR 204
Parties
Plaintiff/appellant: Martin Lynch; Defendant/respondent: The Canada North-West Land Company; Defendant/appellant: The Rural Municipality of South Dufferin; Plaintiff/respondent: Wilmot Morden; Defendant/appellant: William Gibbins; Plaintiff/respondent: Barbara Barber
Court
Supreme Court of Canada
Jurisdiction
Canada
Judgment Date
22 June 1891
Procedural Posture
Appeal From Court of Queen's Bench of Manitoba to Supreme Court of Canada / Hearing on Appeal; Final Judgment by Supreme Court of Canada (majority Decision)
Outcome
Appeals allowed with costs; judgment of the Court of Queen's Bench of Manitoba reversed (majority).
Legal Topics
Division of Powers, Municipal Taxation, Interest Versus Penalty, Ultra Vires
Source Language
English
Constitutional Law Municipal Law Taxation Division of Powers Municipal Taxation Interest Versus Penalty Ultra Vires

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Legal principles 3 Authorities cited 11 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 3
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Martin Lynch

Plaintiff/appellant

The Canada North-West Land Company

Defendant/respondent

The Rural Municipality of South Dufferin

Defendant/appellant

Wilmot Morden

Plaintiff/respondent

William Gibbins

Defendant/appellant

Barbara Barber

Plaintiff/respondent

Procedural Posture

Appeal From Court of Queen's Bench of Manitoba to Supreme Court of Canada / Hearing on Appeal; Final Judgment by Supreme Court of Canada (majority Decision)

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether a statutory 10% addition to unpaid municipal taxes is 'interest' within s.91 of the BNA Act and thus under exclusive federal jurisdiction
  2. 2 Whether the provincial legislature may authorize municipalities to impose an additional percentage on unpaid taxes as a penalty or additional tax
  3. 3 Whether the addition operates as compound interest and if that character affects constitutional validity

Ratio Decidendi

The majority held that the 10% addition on unpaid municipal taxes is an additional tax or penalty incident to provincial authority over municipal institutions and direct taxation under s.92, not 'interest' within s.91 of the BNA Act; accordingly the provincial provision authorizing the addition is intra vires and the appeals are allowed (Gwynne J. dissenting).

Court Disposition

Appeals allowed with costs; judgment of the Court of Queen's Bench of Manitoba reversed (majority).

Orders

  • Appeals allowed with costs in this court and in the court below
  • Judgments of the Court of Queen's Bench of Manitoba reversed to the extent they held the 10% addition ultra vires