R. v. Herd

R. v. Herd

Judge found the circumstantial matrix — vehicle linked by licence plate and key, victims' phones found on McLean, weapons in duffel bag dumped nearby, proximity and timing of arrests — supported only one rational inference for Herd and McLean: they were co-principals in the robbery and in joint possession of the firearms and brass knuckles, establishing guilt beyond a reasonable doubt; McIntosh, though suspicious, was acquitted because Crown failed to meet the beyond‑reasonable‑doubt standard as to his identity and participation.

Citation
2014 BCSC 986
Parties
Crown: Regina; Accused: Rick Shane Herd; Accused: Jordan Glen McIntosh; Accused: Joel Jeremy Shawn McLean
Court
Supreme Court of British Columbia
Jurisdiction
Canada
Judgment Date
8 May 2014
Procedural Posture
Criminal / Judgment
Outcome
Mixed: Two accused convicted, one acquitted
Legal Topics
Robbery With Firearm, Possession of Prohibited/restricted Firearms, Possession of Prohibited Weapon (brass Knuckles), Circumstantial Evidence, Eyewitness Identification, Party Liability S.21 Criminal Code, Section 117.01 Criminal Code
Source Language
English
Criminal Law Evidence Firearms Law Identification Law Criminal Liability Parties Robbery With Firearm Possession of Prohibited/restricted Firearms Possession of Prohibited Weapon (brass Knuckles) +4 more

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Legal principles 4 Authorities cited 12 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 5
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Regina

Crown

Rick Shane Herd

Accused

Jordan Glen McIntosh

Accused

Joel Jeremy Shawn McLean

Accused

Procedural Posture

Criminal / Judgment

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Identity of perpetrators
  2. 2 Whether circumstantial evidence established guilt beyond reasonable doubt
  3. 3 Weight and reliability of eyewitness identification and media-influenced ID

Ratio Decidendi

Judge found the circumstantial matrix — vehicle linked by licence plate and key, victims' phones found on McLean, weapons in duffel bag dumped nearby, proximity and timing of arrests — supported only one rational inference for Herd and McLean: they were co-principals in the robbery and in joint possession of the firearms and brass knuckles, establishing guilt beyond a reasonable doubt; McIntosh, though suspicious, was acquitted because Crown failed to meet the beyond‑reasonable‑doubt standard as to his identity and participation.

Court Disposition

Mixed: Two accused convicted, one acquitted

Orders

  • Rick Shane Herd: Guilty on Count 1 (robbery with a firearm), Count 2 (possession of loaded restricted/prohibited firearms), Count 3 (possession of a prohibited weapon - brass knuckles)
  • Joel Jeremy Shawn McLean: Guilty on Count 1 (robbery with a firearm), Count 2 (possession of loaded restricted/prohibited firearms), Count 3 (possession of a prohibited weapon - brass knuckles), Count 5 (possession of firearms while prohibited under s.117.01(1))