Robertson (Re)

Robertson (Re) Collection Decisions of the Court of Appeal Date 2015-06-12 Neutral citation 2015 ONCA 417 Docket numbers C58439 Judges Laskin, John Ivan; MacFarland, Jean Louise; Rouleau, Paul S. Subject Criminal Decision Content COURT OF APPEAL FOR ONTARIO CITATION: Robertson (Re), 2015 ONCA 417 DATE: 20150609 DOCKET: C58439 Laskin, MacFarland and Rouleau JJ.A. IN THE MATTER OF: JAMES ROBERTSON AN APPEAL UNDER PART XX.1 OF THE CODE James Robertson, appearing in person Uma Kancharla, for the appellant Janice Blackburn, for the Person in Charge of Waypoint Centre for Mental Health Care Eric Seibenmorgen, for the Attorney General Heard: May 27, 2015 On appeal against the disposition of the Ontario Review Board dated, January 22, 2014. APPEAL BOOK ENDORSEMENT [1] The appellant raises two grounds of appeal. [2] First he submits that the Board Chair’s conduct of the hearing raises a reasonable apprehension of bias. We agree that some of the Chair’s comments to the appellant were disrespectful, and some of his comments raised concerns whether the Board had prejudged the appellant’s case. But the burden of making out a bias claim is high, and after reviewing the conduct of the hearing as a whole we are not persuaded that the appellant has met this high burden. [3] Moreover, at best, a successful bias claim would entitle the appellant to a new hearing, and the appellant has a new hearing scheduled in less than two weeks. [4] Second, the appellant submits that the Board failed to recognize that there is a treatment impasse between the appellant and the hospital, and thus failed to order conditions of disposition to break this impasse. In our view, and as previous panels who have dealt with Mr. Robertson have found, there is no treatment impasse. [5] The appellant has legitimate treatment options at Waypoint, which he has refused to pursue because of his unwillingness to engage with the hospital treatment team. [6] The appeal is dismissed.