Canada (Fisheries and Oceans) v. Ahousaht First Nation

Canada (Fisheries and Oceans) v. Ahousaht First Nation Court (s) Database Federal Court of Appeal Decisions Date 2014-09-24 Neutral citation 2014 FCA 211 File numbers A-119-14 Decision Content Date: 20140924 Docket: A-119-14 Citation: 2014 FCA 211 CORAM: SHARLOW J.A. PELLETIER J.A. STRATAS J.A. BETWEEN: MINISTER OF FISHERIES AND OCEANS Appellant And THE AHOUSAHT, EHATTESAHT, HESQUIAHT, MOWACHAHT/MUCHALAHT, AND TLA-O-QUI-AHT INDIAN BANDS AND NATIONS Respondents Heard at Vancouver, British Columbia, on September 24, 2014. Judgment delivered from the Bench at Vancouver, British Columbia, on September 24, 2014. REASONS FOR JUDGMENT BY: PELLETIER J.A. Date: 20140924 Docket: A-119-14 Citation: 2014 FCA 211 CORAM: SHARLOW J.A. PELLETIER J.A. STRATAS J.A. BETWEEN: MINISTER OF FISHERIES AND OCEANS Appellant and THE AHOUSAHT, EHATTESAHT, HESQUIAHT, MOWACHAHT/MUCHALAHT, AND TLA-O-QUI-AHT INDIAN BANDS AND NATIONS Respondents REASONS FOR JUDGMENT PELLETIER J.A. [1] The appellant Minister of Fisheries and Oceans (the Minister) appeals from the decision of Mr. Justice Mandamin of the Federal Court granting an interlocutory injunction restraining the Minister from opening a commercial herring roe fishery under the auspices of the Pacific Region Integrated Fisheries Management Plan – Pacific Herring, November 7, 2013 – November 6, 2014 (the 2014 IFMP) on the west coast of Vancouver Island. [2] The motion for the interlocutory injunction was heard on February 21, and the injunction was granted on February 28, 2014. [3] The open dates for the commercial herring roe fishery in the 2014 IFMP were February 10 to April 30, 2014 (Appeal Book, vol. 1, p. 127). Thus the open season had passed even before the Minister requested an expedited hearing of this appeal in June 2014. As a result, there has not been a live issue between the parties with respect to the interlocutory injunction since April 30, 2014 since nothing this Court did after that date could revive the possibility commercial herring roe fishery within the open season. The First Nations agree that the injunction under appeal applies only to the 2014 fishing season and that any decision with respect to the 2015 season will have to be made pursuant to the 2015 IFMP. [4] The parties are free to continue their litigation as to whether the Minister’s decision to approve the 2014 IFMP should be set aside. In the meantime, the research and negotiations as to the 2015 IFMP will continue and if the Minister once again approves an IFMP over the objections of the First Nations, there will be another opportunity to litigate these issues. If the time frames in that case are no shorter than they were in this case, we are certain that any challenges to that decision could, with the assistance of the Federal Court and this Court, be heard and decided in sufficient time to permit a commercial fishery, if warranted. [5] As a result, this is not a case where the factors listed in Borowski v. Canada (Attorney General), [1980] 1 S.C.R. 342, at paragraphs 31-41, would favour the Court hearing this appeal notwithstanding its mootness. [6] The appeal will therefore be dismissed with costs. "J.D. Denis Pelletier" J.A. FEDERAL COURT OF APPEAL NAMES OF COUNSEL AND SOLICITORS OF RECORD Docket: A-119-14 (APPEAL FROM THE ORDER OF THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MANDAMIN OF THE FEDERAL COURT DATED FEBRUARY 21, 2014, NO. T-404-14.) STYLE OF CAUSE: MINISTER OF FISHERIES AND OCEANS v. THE AHOUSAHT, EHATTESAHT, HESQUIAHT, MOWACHAHT/MUCHALAHT, AND TLA-O-QUI-AHT INDIAN BANDS AND NATIONS PLACE OF HEARING: Vancouver, British Columbia DATE OF HEARING: September 24, 2014 REASONS FOR JUDGMENT OF THE COURT BY: SHARLOW j.a. PELLETIER J.A. STRATA J.A. DELIVERED FROM THE BENCH BY: PELLETIER J.A. APPEARANCES: Judith Hoffman Aneil Singh For The Appellant mfo Matthew Kirchner Lisa Glowacki For The RespondentS the ahousaht and others SOLICITORS OF RECORD: Department of Justice Vancouver, BC For The Appellant mfo Ratcliff & Company LLP Vancouver, BC For The RespondentS the ahousaht and others