Riddle v. Canada

Riddle v. Canada Court (s) Database Federal Court Decisions Date 2020-09-02 Neutral citation 2020 FC 878 File numbers T-2212-16 Decision Content Date: 20200902 Docket: T-2212-16 Citation: 2020 FC 878 Ottawa, Ontario, September 2, 2020 PRESENT: The Honourable Mr. Justice Phelan

CLASS PROCEEDING BETWEEN: JESSICA RIDDLE, WENDY LEE WHITE and CATRIONA CHARLIE Plaintiffs and

HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN Defendant and

THOMPSON DORFMAN SWEATMAN LLP Moving Party ORDER: PAYMENT PROTOCOL UPON READING the motion record of the Moving Party; UPON CONSIDERING that this Court approved an almost identical Order: Payment Protocol in McLean v Canada, 2020 FC 701 [McLean, 2020 FC 701]; AND CONSIDERING that the Reasons for that approval in McLean, 2020 FC 701, are essentially the same as on this motion and such reasons are adopted (subject to necessary changes) as the Reasons for this Decision; THIS COURT ORDERS that: The Claims Administrator shall communicate with counsel for the Moving Party and make payment in trust to counsel for the Moving Party for any amounts payable to the Moving Party in accordance with the terms of the Payment Protocol for Claimants with Individual Counsel [Payment Protocol] attached hereto as Schedule “A”. The Payment Protocol may apply to such counsel retained by a Claimant to assist with their Sixties Scoop Class Action Settlement Claim as may elect to be bound by it and they shall be subject to the Court’s jurisdiction over the Settlement and the provisions for payment to counsel. There shall be no costs of this motion. Blank “Michael L. Phelan” Blank Judge SCHEDULE “A”

PAYMENT PROTOCOL FOR CLAIMANTS WITH INDIVIDUAL COUNSEL This Protocol shall be provided by the Claims Administrator to any lawyer retained by a Claimant other than Class Counsel to assist with the Claimant’s Sixties Scoop Settlement Agreement Claim [Individual Counsel] and such Individual Counsel shall be subject to the Court’s jurisdiction over this Settlement and the provisions for payment to counsel. Any Individual Counsel not prepared to be bound by the Payment Protocol shall apply to the Court for such other order as they deem necessary otherwise Individual Counsel shall be bound by this Payment Protocol. Individual Counsel shall provide the Claims Administrator the following documents, copied to the Defendant and Class Counsel: The Retainer Agreement/Contingency Fee Agreement identified in paragraph 3 above must clearly indicate that legal services are available from Class Counsel at no cost to the Claimant, and that by retaining Individual Counsel, the Claimant is releasing Class Counsel of any ongoing responsibilities or obligations Class Counsel owes the Claimant. For Claimants/Individual Counsel who have provided documentation identified in paragraph 3(a) above, the Claims Administrator shall communicate directly with Individual Counsel with respect to matters concerning the Claimant that would otherwise be communicated directly to a Claimant who has not retained

Individual Counsel. For Claimants/Individual Counsel who have provided complete documentation identified in paragraph 3 above and in accordance with paragraph 4 above, upon completion of the Claims Process, the Claims Administrator shall deliver to Individual Counsel, in trust, the full amount of compensation payable to the Claimant under the Claims Process. Payments made in accordance with paragraph 6 above shall be made as part of the regular payment process as determined by the Claims Administrator. Individual Counsel shall make best efforts to transfer funds received in trust in accordance with paragraph 6 above, that are not subject to legal fee determination in accordance with the Retainer Agreement/Contingency Fee Agreement identified in paragraph 3 above, to the Claimant within ten (10) days. Individual Counsel shall file a motion in accordance with Federal Courts Rule 334.4, on notice in writing to the Defendant and Class Counsel, within sixty (60) days of receiving the payment in trust. Individual Counsel shall make best efforts to transfer any monies remaining in trust that are not approved as legal fees to the Claimant within ten (10) days after the right to appeal the Federal Court Order approving fees has expired or all avenues of appeal have been exhausted unless otherwise ordered by the Federal Court. Individual Counsel shall report to the Federal Court, copied

to the Defendant and Class Counsel, verifying all funds transferred to the Claimant within thirty (30) days after the right to appeal the Federal Court Order approving fees has expired or all avenues of appeal have been exhausted or such other date specified. The report shall include confirmation of the amount(s), dates(s), and method(s) of transfer. In the event that Individual Counsel is unable to transfer funds to the Claimant in accordance with paragraphs 8 and 10 above, Individual Counsel shall report to the Federal Court advising of the steps taken to transfer the funds and the reason(s) why the transfer could not be completed within thirty (30) days after the right to appeal the Federal Court Order approving fees has expired or all avenues of appeal have been exhausted. In the event that Individual Counsel is subsequently able to transfer funds to the Claimant, Individual Counsel shall report to the Federal Court in accordance with paragraph 10 above. Nothing in this Protocol shall interfere with the Court’s ongoing supervision of the Settlement nor in any other way addressing other specific circumstances as they may arise. This Protocol shall apply from the date of the Federal Court Order approving this Protocol moving forward. Retainer Agreement/Contingency Fee Agreement executed by the Claimant and Individual Counsel; and Direction to Pay in Trust executed by the Claimant and Individual Counsel.