Bella Casa Ltd v Vinestone Ltd & Ors

Bella Casa Ltd v Vinestone Ltd & Ors

Claims for general damages for loss of use calculated by reference to interest on the purchase price are invalid and irrecoverable in principle and on the assumed facts; only modest general damages for loss of enjoyment are recoverable in building/property cases, and only by natural persons. Special damages for service charges and utilities may be recoverable subject to causation, proof, and mitigation.

Parties
Claimant: Bella Casa Ltd; First Defendant: Vinestone Ltd; Second Defendant: Paxton Locher Architects Ltd; Third Defendant and Part 20 Claimant: Duffy Construction Ltd; Part 20 Defendant: Faberdex Installations Ltd
Jurisdiction
England and Wales
Judgment Date
09 December 2005
Procedural Posture
Civil / Preliminary Issue Determination
Outcome
Claims for general damages for loss of use are invalid and irrecoverable; claims for special damages (service charges, utilities) are not barred in principle but subject to causation, proof, and mitigation.
Legal Topics
Damages, Loss of Use, Defective Premises Act 1972, Special and General Damages, Measure of Damages
Construction Law Contract Law Tort Law Damages Loss of Use Defective Premises Act 1972 Special and General Damages Measure of Damages

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 3 Authorities cited 17 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 6
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Bella Casa Ltd

Claimant

Vinestone Ltd

First Defendant

Paxton Locher Architects Ltd

Second Defendant

Duffy Construction Ltd

Third Defendant and Part 20 Claimant

Faberdex Installations Ltd

Part 20 Defendant

Procedural Posture

Civil / Preliminary Issue Determination

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Are BCL's claims for loss of use recoverable as a matter of law under contract and statutory duty?
  2. 2 Is a claim for general damages for loss of use, calculated by reference to interest on the purchase price, valid in principle and on the assumed facts?
  3. 3 Are claims for service charges and utilities incurred during uninhabitability recoverable as special damages?

Ratio Decidendi

Claims for general damages for loss of use calculated by reference to interest on the purchase price are invalid and irrecoverable in principle and on the assumed facts; only modest general damages for loss of enjoyment are recoverable in building/property cases, and only by natural persons. Special damages for service charges and utilities may be recoverable subject to causation, proof, and mitigation.

Court Disposition

Claims for general damages for loss of use are invalid and irrecoverable; claims for special damages (service charges, utilities) are not barred in principle but subject to causation, proof, and mitigation.

Orders

  • Claims for general damages for loss of use at Paragraphs 40.2(Ai), 42.2(Ai) and 44.2(Ai) of the Particulars of Claim are ruled invalid in principle and have no realistic prospect of success.
  • Claims for special damages for service charges and utilities are not irrecoverable in principle and may proceed subject to causation, proof, and mitigation.