Hibbert Pownall & Newton (A Firm) v Whitehead & Anor

Hibbert Pownall & Newton (A Firm) v Whitehead & Anor

The estate cannot recover damages from HPN for the loss of the opportunity to recover future care costs after Paula McLeish's death, as such damages would constitute an unjustified windfall and are not losses for which HPN owed a duty to protect. HPN owed no duty of care to Eric Whitehead in his personal capacity, as there was no retainer, assumption of responsibility, or circumstances making it fair, just and reasonable to impose such a duty.

Parties
Appellant / Respondent to Cross Appeal: Hibbert Pownall & Newton (a firm); First Claimant & First Respondent / Appellant in Cross Appeal: Eric Whitehead (on his own and as Administrator of the Estate of Paula McLeish, deceased); Second Claimant & Second Respondent: David McLeish
Jurisdiction
England and Wales
Judgment Date
04 April 2008
Procedural Posture
Civil Appeal / Appeal From High Court Judgment
Outcome
Appeal allowed; cross-appeal dismissed
Legal Topics
Solicitor's Duty of Care, Loss Assessment, Wrongful Birth, Limitation of Damages, Duty to Third Parties
Professional Negligence Medical Negligence Damages Solicitor's Duty of Care Loss Assessment Wrongful Birth Limitation of Damages Duty to Third Parties

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 4 Authorities cited 19 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 5
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Hibbert Pownall & Newton (a firm)

Appellant / Respondent to Cross Appeal

Eric Whitehead (on his own and as Administrator of the Estate of Paula McLeish, deceased)

First Claimant & First Respondent / Appellant in Cross Appeal

David McLeish

Second Claimant & Second Respondent

Procedural Posture

Civil Appeal / Appeal From High Court Judgment

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether the solicitors (HPN) are liable in damages to the estate for failing to bring the first action to a conclusion before the death of Paula McLeish, thereby curtailing recoverable damages
  2. 2 Whether HPN owed a duty of care to Eric Whitehead in his personal capacity to advise him of a potential claim against the health authority

Ratio Decidendi

The estate cannot recover damages from HPN for the loss of the opportunity to recover future care costs after Paula McLeish's death, as such damages would constitute an unjustified windfall and are not losses for which HPN owed a duty to protect. HPN owed no duty of care to Eric Whitehead in his personal capacity, as there was no retainer, assumption of responsibility, or circumstances making it fair, just and reasonable to impose such a duty.

Court Disposition

Appeal allowed; cross-appeal dismissed

Orders

  • HPN's appeal against the award of damages on the primary claim is allowed; the award to the estate is set aside.
  • Eric Whitehead's cross-appeal on his personal claim is dismissed.