A Local Authority v The Mother & Ors [2023] EWFC 166 (15 September 2023)

A Local Authority v The Mother & Ors [2023] EWFC 166 (15 September 2023)

On balance of probabilities, the repeated polymicrobial infections in C's neurosurgical devices are most consistent with direct contamination, but the evidence does not conclusively establish deliberate or negligent causation by any individual. The court must weigh expert medical evidence, witness credibility, and circumstantial factors, applying the civil standard of proof and not reversing the burden. Rare medical events can occur naturally, and the presence of risk factors in C's condition cannot be excluded as contributing causes.

Citation
[2023] EWFC 166
Parties
Child Patient: C; Parent: Mother; Parent: Father; Applicant: Local Authority
Jurisdiction
England and Wales
Judgment Date
15 September 2023
Procedural Posture
Family Proceedings (fact Finding) / Judgment
Outcome
No definitive finding of deliberate or negligent contamination; causation remains unproven beyond balance of probabilities.
Legal Topics
Burden of Proof, Expert Evidence, Hearsay Evidence, Credibility of Witnesses, Child Welfare, Medical Device Infection
Family Law Child Protection Medical Negligence Burden of Proof Expert Evidence Hearsay Evidence Credibility of Witnesses Child Welfare +1 more

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 5 Authorities cited 13 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 3
Sign in to unlock

Parties

C

Child Patient

Mother

Parent

Father

Parent

Local Authority

Applicant

Procedural Posture

Family Proceedings (fact Finding) / Judgment

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Causation of repeated polymicrobial infections in child C's neurosurgical devices
  2. 2 Assessment of evidence regarding deliberate, negligent, or accidental contamination
  3. 3 Evaluation of witness credibility and reliability

Ratio Decidendi

On balance of probabilities, the repeated polymicrobial infections in C's neurosurgical devices are most consistent with direct contamination, but the evidence does not conclusively establish deliberate or negligent causation by any individual. The court must weigh expert medical evidence, witness credibility, and circumstantial factors, applying the civil standard of proof and not reversing the burden. Rare medical events can occur naturally, and the presence of risk factors in C's condition cannot be excluded as contributing causes.

Court Disposition

No definitive finding of deliberate or negligent contamination; causation remains unproven beyond balance of probabilities.

Orders

  • No order as to findings of culpability; child protection measures to continue as appropriate based on risk assessment.
  • Expert medical monitoring and hygiene protocols to be maintained.