RE GOLDCONE PROPERTIES LTD.

RE GOLDCONE PROPERTIES LTD.

Where prima facie evidence shows unfinished, investigable matters (suspect payments, director loans, potential avoidance claims) and where the existing liquidators were appointed or advised in circumstances creating a real and reasonable perception of lack of impartiality (including prior solicitors advising company then advising liquidators), the court should exercise its discretion to order a compulsory winding-up so that neutral liquidators can be appointed and creditors’ class remedy be vindicated; delay by the petitioner did not amount to acquiescence on these facts.

Citation
RE GOLDCONE PROPERTIES LTD.
Parties
Petitioner (creditor): Kong Mou Holdings Limited; Company (in Creditors Voluntary Liquidation): Goldcone Properties Limited; Opposing Creditor; Director and Shareholder: Cheung Shuen Lung; Provisional Liquidators / Liquidators: Messrs John Robert Lees and Desmond Chiong Chung Seng; Creditor (opposes Petition): Faith On Industrial Ltd; Creditor (supports Petition): Young Brothers Development Co Ltd
Court
Court of First Instance
Jurisdiction
Hong Kong
Judgment Date
4 November 1999
Case Number
HCCW391/1999
Procedural Posture
Companies Winding Up Petition / Judgment (decision on Petition)
Outcome
Compulsory winding-up order made against Goldcone Properties Limited
Legal Topics
Compulsory Winding Up Vs Voluntary Liquidation, Liquidator Independence and Perceived Impartiality, Fraudulent/unfair Preference and Avoidance Actions, Directors' Loans and Potential Misfeasance, Creditor Voting and Majority Wishes, Mareva Injunction and Asset Dissipation
Source Language
EN
Company Law Insolvency Law Civil Procedure Compulsory Winding Up Vs Voluntary Liquidation Liquidator Independence and Perceived Impartiality Fraudulent/unfair Preference and Avoidance Actions Directors' Loans and Potential Misfeasance Creditor Voting and Majority Wishes +1 more

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 5 Authorities cited 18 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 7
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Kong Mou Holdings Limited

Petitioner (creditor)

Goldcone Properties Limited

Company (in Creditors Voluntary Liquidation)

Cheung Shuen Lung

Opposing Creditor; Director and Shareholder

Messrs John Robert Lees and Desmond Chiong Chung Seng

Provisional Liquidators / Liquidators

Faith On Industrial Ltd

Creditor (opposes Petition)

Young Brothers Development Co Ltd

Creditor (supports Petition)

Procedural Posture

Companies Winding Up Petition / Judgment (decision on Petition)

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether an unpaid judgment creditor is entitled to a compulsory winding-up order where the company is already in voluntary liquidation and other creditors disagree
  2. 2 Extent to which the court must give effect to the wishes of the majority of creditors and when special circumstances justify overriding them
  3. 3 Whether prima facie evidence of misconduct or inadequate investigation by existing liquidators justifies a compulsory order

Ratio Decidendi

Where prima facie evidence shows unfinished, investigable matters (suspect payments, director loans, potential avoidance claims) and where the existing liquidators were appointed or advised in circumstances creating a real and reasonable perception of lack of impartiality (including prior solicitors advising company then advising liquidators), the court should exercise its discretion to order a compulsory winding-up so that neutral liquidators can be appointed and creditors’ class remedy be vindicated; delay by the petitioner did not amount to acquiescence on these facts.

Court Disposition

Compulsory winding-up order made against Goldcone Properties Limited

Orders

  • Compulsory winding-up order made against Goldcone Properties Limited