MASTER UNIVERSE DEVELOPMENT LTD v. MASS OCEAN INTERNATIONAL LTD AND ANOTHER

MASTER UNIVERSE DEVELOPMENT LTD v. MASS OCEAN INTERNATIONAL LTD AND ANOTHER

Consolidation of all five actions with a single set of pleadings was refused; the court found the tenancy/third‑party actions (TA Actions: HCA1295/2015, HCA1849/2015, HCA1850/2015) and adverse possession actions (AP Actions: severed parts of HCA691/2015 and HCA694/2015) are distinct and severable; ordered the AP issues severed and stayed the tenancy issues in HCA691/694 without prejudice to claims in the TA Actions; designated leading actions for each stream, directed unified management and trial before the same judge, allowed third parties to participate on liability in the TA Actions, refused expunging of pleadings, and made specific timelines and directions for amended pleadings,...

Citation
[2019] HKCFI 2323
Parties
Plaintiff in HCA 691/2015 and HCA 694/2015; 1st Defendant in HCA 1295/2015, 1st Defendant in HCA 1849/2015 and 1st Defendant in HCA 1850/2015: Mass Ocean International Limited; 1st Defendant in HCA 691/2015: Trinity Holdings (Hong Kong) Limited (順利達控股有限公司) formerly Treasure Day Inc Limited; 2nd Defendant in HCA 691/2015; Plaintiff in HCA 1295/2015, HCA 1849/2015 and HCA 1850/2015: Master Universe Development Limited (宏灝發展有限公司); 3rd Defendant in HCA 691/2015 and 5th Defendant in HCA 694/2015 (unrepresented Occupiers): All other occupier(s) of the remaining portion of Section D of Lot No. 372 in D.D.99; 1st Defendant in HCA 694/2015: 東源大地有限公司; 2nd Defendant in HCA 694/2015: 東成貨運有限公司; 4th Defendant in HCA 694/2015: Li Mei Sing (李美成); 2nd Defendant in HCA 1295/2015; 2nd Defendant in HCA 1849/2015 and HCA 1850/2015: Grand Fusion Limited (宏昌順有限公司); 3rd Defendant in HCA 1295/2015: Crown Spread Limited (振冠有限公司); 4th Defendant in HCA 1295/2015: Benefit Huge Limited (利宏有限公司); Plaintiff in HCA 1849/2015: Fortune Gain International Investment Limited (福達國際投資有限公司); 1st Third Party in HCA 1295/2015, HCA 1849/2015 and HCA 1850/2015: Siu Choi Fat; 2nd Third Party in HCA 1295/2015, HCA 1849/2015 and HCA 1850/2015: Chui and Lau (a firm)
Court
Court of First Instance
Jurisdiction
Hong Kong
Judgment Date
18 September 2019
Case Number
HCA1850/2015
Procedural Posture
Multi‑action Civil Land Disputes: Application for Consolidation/severance and Case Management / Decision on Consent Summons and Case Management (judgment on Consolidation/severance and Related Directions)
Outcome
Consent summons for full consolidation refused; orders made severing adverse possession issues from tenancy/third‑party disputes, staying parts of proceedings, designating leading actions, and setting case management directions and costs allocations.
Legal Topics
Consolidation, Severance, Adverse Possession, Tenancy Agreements, Third Party Proceedings, Expunging Pleadings, Case Management
Source Language
EN
Civil Procedure Property Law Land Law Civil Litigation Costs Consolidation Severance Adverse Possession +4 more

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 5 Authorities cited 5 Party arguments 2
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Mass Ocean International Limited

Plaintiff in HCA 691/2015 and HCA 694/2015; 1st Defendant in HCA 1295/2015, 1st Defendant in HCA 1849/2015 and 1st Defendant in HCA 1850/2015

Trinity Holdings (Hong Kong) Limited (順利達控股有限公司) formerly Treasure Day Inc Limited

1st Defendant in HCA 691/2015

Master Universe Development Limited (宏灝發展有限公司)

2nd Defendant in HCA 691/2015; Plaintiff in HCA 1295/2015, HCA 1849/2015 and HCA 1850/2015

All other occupier(s) of the remaining portion of Section D of Lot No. 372 in D.D.99

3rd Defendant in HCA 691/2015 and 5th Defendant in HCA 694/2015 (unrepresented Occupiers)

東源大地有限公司

1st Defendant in HCA 694/2015

東成貨運有限公司

2nd Defendant in HCA 694/2015

Li Mei Sing (李美成)

4th Defendant in HCA 694/2015

Grand Fusion Limited (宏昌順有限公司)

2nd Defendant in HCA 1295/2015; 2nd Defendant in HCA 1849/2015 and HCA 1850/2015

Crown Spread Limited (振冠有限公司)

3rd Defendant in HCA 1295/2015

Benefit Huge Limited (利宏有限公司)

4th Defendant in HCA 1295/2015

Fortune Gain International Investment Limited (福達國際投資有限公司)

Plaintiff in HCA 1849/2015

Siu Choi Fat

1st Third Party in HCA 1295/2015, HCA 1849/2015 and HCA 1850/2015

Chui and Lau (a firm)

2nd Third Party in HCA 1295/2015, HCA 1849/2015 and HCA 1850/2015

Procedural Posture

Multi‑action Civil Land Disputes: Application for Consolidation/severance and Case Management / Decision on Consent Summons and Case Management (judgment on Consolidation/severance and Related Directions)

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether five related actions should be consolidated into one with consolidated pleadings
  2. 2 Whether adverse possession issues in HCA 691 and HCA 694 should be severed from tenancy/third‑party issues
  3. 3 Whether pleadings should be expunged

Ratio Decidendi

Consolidation of all five actions with a single set of pleadings was refused; the court found the tenancy/third‑party actions (TA Actions: HCA1295/2015, HCA1849/2015, HCA1850/2015) and adverse possession actions (AP Actions: severed parts of HCA691/2015 and HCA694/2015) are distinct and severable; ordered the AP issues severed and stayed the tenancy issues in HCA691/694 without prejudice to claims in the TA Actions; designated leading actions for each stream, directed unified management and trial before the same judge, allowed third parties to participate on liability in the TA Actions, refused expunging of pleadings, and made specific timelines and directions for amended pleadings,...

Court Disposition

Consent summons for full consolidation refused; orders made severing adverse possession issues from tenancy/third‑party disputes, staying parts of proceedings, designating leading actions, and setting case management directions and costs allocations.

Orders

  • Mass Ocean’s claim against Trinity Holdings and Trinity Holdings’ counterclaim relating to the Eastern Portion of the 691 Land severed to form part of the AP Actions
  • HCA 691/2015 designated as the leading AP Action; parties bound by findings in each AP Action