CHAN CHUNG YEE v. CHAN WAH CHO, JOE AND ANOTHER

CHAN CHUNG YEE v. CHAN WAH CHO, JOE AND ANOTHER

The court found on credibility and objective conduct evidence that a concluded verbal agreement was reached at the June 8 2008 meeting containing essential terms (transfer of car parks to HL, waiver of HL's debt by HIECL as agreed between siblings, defendants' personal repayment of HK$500,000, equalization payment and procedural share transfers). The 2 July 2008 share transfers and HL's subsequent use of the car parks amounted to part performance evidencing the contract. Specific performance was granted against the defendants to procure the agreed outcomes; separately, HIECL's claim for repayment of the inter-company book debt was dismissed because, on the evidence and accounting context,...

Citation
[2018] HKCFI 611
Parties
Plaintiff (hca 1419/2011): Chan Chung Yee; 1st Defendant (hca 1419/2011): Chan Wah Cho (Joe); 2nd Defendant (hca 1419/2011): Chan Wah Chui (Yolly); Plaintiff (hca 1228/2014): Huning Import & Export Company Limited; Defendant (hca 1228/2014): Huning Limited
Court
Court of First Instance
Jurisdiction
Hong Kong
Judgment Date
20 March 2018
Case Number
HCA1419/2011
Procedural Posture
Civil: Consolidated Actions for Specific Performance and Inter Company Debt / Trial Judgment (court of First Instance)
Outcome
Judgment for plaintiff Chan Chung Yee in HCA 1419/2011; claim by Huning Import & Export Company Limited (HCA 1228/2014) dismissed
Legal Topics
Specific Performance, Part Performance, Inter Company Debt, Estoppel, Unilateral Mistake, Share Transfers, Valuation of Assets, Directors' Resignations
Source Language
EN
Contract Equity Company Law Evidence Family Law Specific Performance Part Performance Inter Company Debt +5 more

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 4 Authorities cited 7 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 5
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Chan Chung Yee

Plaintiff (hca 1419/2011)

Chan Wah Cho (Joe)

1st Defendant (hca 1419/2011)

Chan Wah Chui (Yolly)

2nd Defendant (hca 1419/2011)

Huning Import & Export Company Limited

Plaintiff (hca 1228/2014)

Huning Limited

Defendant (hca 1228/2014)

Procedural Posture

Civil: Consolidated Actions for Specific Performance and Inter Company Debt / Trial Judgment (court of First Instance)

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether a binding verbal agreement was concluded between the siblings and its precise terms
  2. 2 Whether the share transfers and changes of directorship effected on 2 July 2008 constituted part performance of that agreement
  3. 3 Whether terms requiring the transfer of assets could be enforced against a non-party company by ordering parties to procure that transfer

Ratio Decidendi

The court found on credibility and objective conduct evidence that a concluded verbal agreement was reached at the June 8 2008 meeting containing essential terms (transfer of car parks to HL, waiver of HL's debt by HIECL as agreed between siblings, defendants' personal repayment of HK$500,000, equalization payment and procedural share transfers). The 2 July 2008 share transfers and HL's subsequent use of the car parks amounted to part performance evidencing the contract. Specific performance was granted against the defendants to procure the agreed outcomes; separately, HIECL's claim for repayment of the inter-company book debt was dismissed because, on the evidence and accounting context,...

Court Disposition

Judgment for plaintiff Chan Chung Yee in HCA 1419/2011; claim by Huning Import & Export Company Limited (HCA 1228/2014) dismissed

Orders

  • Defendants to procure HIECL to transfer the two car parking spaces in Kwan Yick Building to Huning Limited at nominal value of HK$1 within 28 days; parties to bear legal costs of the transfer equally
  • Defendants to procure HIECL to waive the debt owed by Huning Limited in the amount of HK$956,874.89 within 28 days from date of judgment