LAW MAN WAI v. KWAN SAU SIM

LAW MAN WAI v. KWAN SAU SIM

On the balance of probabilities the judge found that 6th Aunt intended the transfers to Wai to be held for the joint benefit of Wai and Kam; the monies used to acquire the Properties were repayments of that joint entitlement, therefore Sim is the beneficial owner of the Properties and Kam is entitled to an account...

Source-derived case information.

Citation
LAW MAN WAI v. KWAN SAU SIM
Parties
Plaintiff (hca 2307/2009); Defendant (hca 143/2010): Law Man Wai; Defendant (hca 2307/2009): Kwan Sau Sim; Plaintiff (hca 143/2010): Lo Man Kam
Court
Court of First Instance
Jurisdiction
Hong Kong
Judgment Date
1 November 2013
Case Number
HCA2307/2009
Procedural Posture
Civil Trusts/proprietary Claim and Accounting / Judgment (court of First Instance)
Outcome
Wai's claim in HCA 2307/2009 dismissed; Sim's counterclaim succeeds with declaration of beneficial ownership of the Properties, award of damages and release of stakeheld rental; Kam's claim in HCA 143/2010 succeeds with an order for an account in respect of the 6th Aunt's Gift; tracing order not made at this stage;...
Legal Topics
Beneficial Ownership, Resulting/constructive Trust, Accounting by Trustee, Gifts Versus Trust, Tracing, Credibility Assessment
Source Language
en
Trusts Property Equity Probate/estate Civil Procedure Beneficial Ownership Resulting/constructive Trust Accounting by Trustee +3 more

Source-derived case record

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 4 Authorities cited 3 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 5
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Law Man Wai

Plaintiff (hca 2307/2009); Defendant (hca 143/2010)

Kwan Sau Sim

Defendant (hca 2307/2009)

Lo Man Kam

Plaintiff (hca 143/2010)

Procedural Posture

Civil Trusts/proprietary Claim and Accounting / Judgment (court of First Instance)

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether monies transferred by the deceased (6th Aunt) to Wai were held on trust for Wai and Kam jointly
  2. 2 Whether the payments from Wai to Kam/Sim were gifts or repayments of the 6th Aunt's gift
  3. 3 Whether Wai is the beneficial owner of properties purchased in Sim's name

Ratio Decidendi

On the balance of probabilities the judge found that 6th Aunt intended the transfers to Wai to be held for the joint benefit of Wai and Kam; the monies used to acquire the Properties were repayments of that joint entitlement, therefore Sim is the beneficial owner of the Properties and Kam is entitled to an account of the 6th Aunt's Gift.

Court Disposition

Wai's claim in HCA 2307/2009 dismissed; Sim's counterclaim succeeds with declaration of beneficial ownership of the Properties, award of damages and release of stakeheld rental; Kam's claim in HCA 143/2010 succeeds with an order for an account in respect of the 6th Aunt's Gift; tracing order not made at this stage;...

Orders

  • Dismissal of Wai's claim in HCA 2307/2009
  • Declaration that Kwan Sau Sim is and was at all material times the beneficial owner of Shop 7 (No.27 Cannon Street) and Flat E 14/F Fung Yip Building and that Wai has no interest in either property