BORRI S. p. A. v. TRALACO TECHNOLOGY LTD AND OTHERS

BORRI S. p. A. v. TRALACO TECHNOLOGY LTD AND OTHERS

The court found on the evidence that the plaintiff enjoyed substantial reputation and goodwill in the BORRI mark; the 1995 agreement and contemporaneous invoices/catalogues demonstrated plaintiff's ownership and use; defendants' contrary allegations (abandonment, lack of authority) were not credible and unsupported by affidavits; defendants knowingly used registrations, incorporations and a website to deceive the public and pass off goods as the plaintiff's; no real triable issue existed and summary judgment was warranted; consequential relief (Hong Kong injunction, assignment of Hong Kong and Mainland registrations and transfer of the domain name) was ordered, security for costs...

Citation
BORRI S. p. A. v. TRALACO TECHNOLOGY LTD AND OTHERS
Parties
Plaintiff: Borri S.p.A.; 1st Defendant: Tralaco Technology Limited; 2nd Defendant: Borri Electronics (China) Limited; 3rd Defendant: Borri Electronic International Inc.; 4th Defendant: Borri Electronics (HK) Limited; 5th Defendant: 5th Defendant (individual); 6th Defendant: 6th Defendant (individual); 7th Defendant: 7th Defendant (individual); Associated Individual/third Party: F C Yu
Court
Court of First Instance
Jurisdiction
Hong Kong
Judgment Date
19 August 2009
Case Number
HCMP1352/2007
Procedural Posture
Civil Passing Off, Trade Mark and Conspiracy / Application for Summary Judgment (judgment Delivered)
Outcome
Summary judgment for plaintiff; injunction granted in Hong Kong; orders for assignment of trade mark registrations and domain name; security for costs application dismissed; costs ordered (order nisi); further hearing to refine reliefs directed.
Legal Topics
Summary Judgment, Security for Costs, Assignment of Trade Mark Registrations, Use of Websites as Instrument of Deception, Double Actionability (territorial Limits of Relief)
Source Language
EN
Passing Off Trade Mark Law Conspiracy (joint Tortfeasance) Injunctions Domain Name Disputes Summary Judgment Security for Costs Assignment of Trade Mark Registrations +2 more

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 5 Authorities cited 4 Party arguments 2
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Borri S.p.A.

Plaintiff

Tralaco Technology Limited

1st Defendant

Borri Electronics (China) Limited

2nd Defendant

Borri Electronic International Inc.

3rd Defendant

Borri Electronics (HK) Limited

4th Defendant

5th Defendant (individual)

5th Defendant

6th Defendant (individual)

6th Defendant

7th Defendant (individual)

7th Defendant

F C Yu

Associated Individual/third Party

Procedural Posture

Civil Passing Off, Trade Mark and Conspiracy / Application for Summary Judgment (judgment Delivered)

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether plaintiff owned and enjoyed goodwill in the BORRI mark in Hong Kong and Mainland
  2. 2 Whether defendants committed passing off and acted jointly pursuant to a common design or conspiracy
  3. 3 Whether there existed any real triable issue precluding summary judgment

Ratio Decidendi

The court found on the evidence that the plaintiff enjoyed substantial reputation and goodwill in the BORRI mark; the 1995 agreement and contemporaneous invoices/catalogues demonstrated plaintiff's ownership and use; defendants' contrary allegations (abandonment, lack of authority) were not credible and unsupported by affidavits; defendants knowingly used registrations, incorporations and a website to deceive the public and pass off goods as the plaintiff's; no real triable issue existed and summary judgment was warranted; consequential relief (Hong Kong injunction, assignment of Hong Kong and Mainland registrations and transfer of the domain name) was ordered, security for costs...

Court Disposition

Summary judgment for plaintiff; injunction granted in Hong Kong; orders for assignment of trade mark registrations and domain name; security for costs application dismissed; costs ordered (order nisi); further hearing to refine reliefs directed.

Orders

  • Summary judgment entered for the plaintiff
  • Permanent injunction restraining defendants from perpetrating acts of passing‑off in Hong Kong