MALAHON CREDIT COMPANY LIMITED v. SIU CHUN WAH, ALICE AND ANOTHER

MALAHON CREDIT COMPANY LIMITED v. SIU CHUN WAH, ALICE AND ANOTHER

The charging order under Cap.4 gave Malahon a charge against Mr. Ng’s interest only in the proceeds of sale, not an interest in the land; on the evidence (uncontradicted affidavit and deed evidence) Madam Siu held a one‑half beneficial interest which had been exonerated under the doctrine of equity of exoneration, so after repayment of the mortgage and further charge the surplus must be divided one‑half to Madam Siu.

Citation
MALAHON CREDIT COMPANY LIMITED v. SIU CHUN WAH, ALICE AND ANOTHER
Parties
Plaintiff in M.p.413; 1st Defendant in M.p.526: Siu Chun Wah, Alice; Plaintiff in M.p.413; 2nd Defendant in M.p.526: Ng Leong Fah; Defendant in M.p.413; Plaintiff in M.p.526: Malahon Credit Company Limited
Court
Court of First Instance
Jurisdiction
Hong Kong
Judgment Date
26 May 1987
Case Number
HCMP526/1987
Procedural Posture
Consolidated High Court Miscellaneous Proceedings / Hearing in Chambers — Judgment Delivered
Outcome
Judgment declared in favour of Madam Siu: she is entitled to one‑half of the surplus proceeds after repayment of the mortgage and further charge; Malahon entitled to repayment of its mortgage and further charge.
Legal Topics
Charging Order, Mortgage, Co Ownership, Proceeds of Sale, Equity of Exoneration, Default Judgment Enforcement
Source Language
EN
Property Equity Trusts Civil Procedure Enforcement of Judgments Charging Order Mortgage Co Ownership +3 more

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 2 Authorities cited 6 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 3
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Siu Chun Wah, Alice

Plaintiff in M.p.413; 1st Defendant in M.p.526

Ng Leong Fah

Plaintiff in M.p.413; 2nd Defendant in M.p.526

Malahon Credit Company Limited

Defendant in M.p.413; Plaintiff in M.p.526

Procedural Posture

Consolidated High Court Miscellaneous Proceedings / Hearing in Chambers — Judgment Delivered

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether a charging order under section 20 Supreme Court Ordinance Cap.4 gives a judgment creditor an interest in land or only in proceeds of sale
  2. 2 Whether Madam Siu is entitled to one-half of the surplus proceeds after discharge of mortgage and further charge
  3. 3 Whether absence of written instrument or limited monetary contribution defeats an asserted beneficial interest

Ratio Decidendi

The charging order under Cap.4 gave Malahon a charge against Mr. Ng’s interest only in the proceeds of sale, not an interest in the land; on the evidence (uncontradicted affidavit and deed evidence) Madam Siu held a one‑half beneficial interest which had been exonerated under the doctrine of equity of exoneration, so after repayment of the mortgage and further charge the surplus must be divided one‑half to Madam Siu.

Court Disposition

Judgment declared in favour of Madam Siu: she is entitled to one‑half of the surplus proceeds after repayment of the mortgage and further charge; Malahon entitled to repayment of its mortgage and further charge.

Orders

  • Declare Madam Siu entitled to one‑half of the surplus of sale proceeds after discharge of the mortgage and further charge.
  • Malahon entitled to repayment of the outstanding mortgage and further charge (recorded at $726,803.49 subject to small adjustment).