ACHIEVE GOAL HOLDINGS LTD v. ZHONG XIN ORE-MATERIAL HOLDING CO LTD

ACHIEVE GOAL HOLDINGS LTD v. ZHONG XIN ORE-MATERIAL HOLDING CO LTD

The court allowed joinder and re-amendment to permit Clarigain to pursue the derivative counterclaim because the substantive issues are the same whether prosecuted in the companys name or derivatively; determining Zhong Xin s locus standi first would have no practical effect on the substantive disputes except costs, and therefore the Authority to Sue summons should be adjourned to be dealt with at trial; the Striking Out summons was restored for sensible disposal; costs of and occasioned by the amendments were ordered against the plaintiff/defendants by counterclaim and costs of the hearing reserved.

Citation
ACHIEVE GOAL HOLDINGS LTD v. ZHONG XIN ORE-MATERIAL HOLDING CO LTD
Parties
Plaintiff (original Action) and 1st Defendant by Counterclaim: Achieve Goal Holdings Limited; Defendant (original Action) and 5th Defendant by Counterclaim: Zhong Xin Ore-Material Holding Company Limited; 1st Plaintiff (on Behalf of Itself and Other Shareholders of Zhong Xin): Clarigain Enterprises Limited; 2nd Plaintiff (by Counterclaim): Bai Jun Tian Cheng Limited; 2nd Defendant (by Counterclaim): Angola Group Holdings Limited; 3rd Defendant (by Counterclaim): Zhao Bing; 4th Defendant (by Counterclaim): Ng Chi Kong
Court
Court of First Instance
Jurisdiction
Hong Kong
Judgment Date
6 March 2008
Case Number
HCA1987/2005
Procedural Posture
Company/commercial Litigation (derivative Action; Counterclaim) / Interlocutory Applications Decided (joinder and Re Amendment Summonses); Authority to Sue Summons Adjourned to Trial
Outcome
Summonses (13 September 2007 and 25 February 2008) granted in terms; Authority to Sue summons adjourned to trial; Striking Out summons restored for hearing.
Legal Topics
Derivative Action, Authority to Sue, Joinder of Parties, Amendment of Pleadings, Striking Out, Costs, Specific Performance, Misrepresentation, Joint Venture
Source Language
EN
Company Law Civil Procedure Commercial Law Shareholder Litigation Derivative Action Authority to Sue Joinder of Parties Amendment of Pleadings +5 more

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 5 Authorities cited 4 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 5
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Achieve Goal Holdings Limited

Plaintiff (original Action) and 1st Defendant by Counterclaim

Zhong Xin Ore-Material Holding Company Limited

Defendant (original Action) and 5th Defendant by Counterclaim

Clarigain Enterprises Limited

1st Plaintiff (on Behalf of Itself and Other Shareholders of Zhong Xin)

Bai Jun Tian Cheng Limited

2nd Plaintiff (by Counterclaim)

Angola Group Holdings Limited

2nd Defendant (by Counterclaim)

Zhao Bing

3rd Defendant (by Counterclaim)

Ng Chi Kong

4th Defendant (by Counterclaim)

Procedural Posture

Company/commercial Litigation (derivative Action; Counterclaim) / Interlocutory Applications Decided (joinder and Re Amendment Summonses); Authority to Sue Summons Adjourned to Trial

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether Clarigain can be joined to pursue a derivative action on behalf of Zhong Xin
  2. 2 Whether the issue of Zhong Xin's authority to sue should be determined before trial or can be adjourned to trial
  3. 3 Whether amendment/substitution can cure or render academic any lack of authority to sue

Ratio Decidendi

The court allowed joinder and re-amendment to permit Clarigain to pursue the derivative counterclaim because the substantive issues are the same whether prosecuted in the companys name or derivatively; determining Zhong Xin s locus standi first would have no practical effect on the substantive disputes except costs, and therefore the Authority to Sue summons should be adjourned to be dealt with at trial; the Striking Out summons was restored for sensible disposal; costs of and occasioned by the amendments were ordered against the plaintiff/defendants by counterclaim and costs of the hearing reserved.

Court Disposition

Summonses (13 September 2007 and 25 February 2008) granted in terms; Authority to Sue summons adjourned to trial; Striking Out summons restored for hearing.

Orders

  • Joinder of Clarigain to sue on behalf of itself and other shareholders and renaming of Zhong Xin as 5th defendant by counterclaim as per the summons granted
  • Leave to re-amend the Amended Defence and Counterclaim granted and further amendments permitted as per 25 February 2008 summons