1,2,3, PRINTING SERVICES LTD v. MAN SANG ENVELOPE MANUFACTURING CO LTD

1,2,3, PRINTING SERVICES LTD v. MAN SANG ENVELOPE MANUFACTURING CO LTD

Printing Services was not entitled to cancel the Settlement Agreement or the subsequent sales orders because Man Sang was an unpaid seller entitled to retain goods pending payment; Printing Services had not performed conditions precedent (notably failing to supply all films) and could not rely on an unsigned Master Agreement; the Finnish paper supply was subject to set-off against the posters order and Printing Services could not recover tracing paper costs, therefore Man Sang was entitled to the sums awarded.

Citation
1,2,3, PRINTING SERVICES LTD v. MAN SANG ENVELOPE MANUFACTURING CO LTD
Parties
Plaintiff (lead Action Hca1352/2001); Defendant and Counterclaim Defendant (hca3804/2001): Man Sang Envelope Manufacturing Co., Ltd.; Defendant (hca1352/2001); Plaintiff and Counterclaimant (hca3804/2001): 1,2,3 Printing Services Ltd.
Court
Court of First Instance
Jurisdiction
Hong Kong
Judgment Date
14 May 2004
Case Number
HCA3804/2001
Procedural Posture
Consolidated Commercial Contract Dispute (sale of Goods) / Trial Judgment (court of First Instance, Judgment Delivered)
Outcome
Judgment for Man Sang in HCA1352/2001 for US$206,586.37 with interest; counterclaim dismissed. Judgment in HCA3804/2001 in favour of Man Sang in damages of US$296,928.09 with interest; claim dismissed. Costs to Man Sang, taxed if not agreed; costs nisi at first instance.
Legal Topics
Repudiatory Breach, Delivery of Goods, Unpaid Seller Lien, Incorporation of Terms, Set Off, Measure of Damages
Source Language
EN
Contract Law Sale of Goods Commercial Law Civil Procedure Repudiatory Breach Delivery of Goods Unpaid Seller Lien Incorporation of Terms +2 more

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 4 Authorities cited 4 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 3
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Man Sang Envelope Manufacturing Co., Ltd.

Plaintiff (lead Action Hca1352/2001); Defendant and Counterclaim Defendant (hca3804/2001)

1,2,3 Printing Services Ltd.

Defendant (hca1352/2001); Plaintiff and Counterclaimant (hca3804/2001)

Procedural Posture

Consolidated Commercial Contract Dispute (sale of Goods) / Trial Judgment (court of First Instance, Judgment Delivered)

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether Printing Services was entitled to cancel the Settlement Agreement and various sales orders for repudiatory breach by Man Sang
  2. 2 Whether Printing Services or Printing Services' agents failed to supply films/proofs and whether that precluded Man Sang's performance
  3. 3 Whether Man Sang was an unpaid seller entitled to retain goods under the Sale of Goods Ordinance

Ratio Decidendi

Printing Services was not entitled to cancel the Settlement Agreement or the subsequent sales orders because Man Sang was an unpaid seller entitled to retain goods pending payment; Printing Services had not performed conditions precedent (notably failing to supply all films) and could not rely on an unsigned Master Agreement; the Finnish paper supply was subject to set-off against the posters order and Printing Services could not recover tracing paper costs, therefore Man Sang was entitled to the sums awarded.

Court Disposition

Judgment for Man Sang in HCA1352/2001 for US$206,586.37 with interest; counterclaim dismissed. Judgment in HCA3804/2001 in favour of Man Sang in damages of US$296,928.09 with interest; claim dismissed. Costs to Man Sang, taxed if not agreed; costs nisi at first instance.

Orders

  • HCA 1352/2001: Judgment for Man Sang in the sum of US$206,586.37 and interest at prime from 15 November 2000 to date; counterclaim dismissed; costs to Man Sang, taxed if not agreed.
  • HCA 3804/2001: Judgment on the counterclaim in favour of Man Sang in damages assessed at US$296,928.09 and interest at prime from 8 May 2001 to date; claim dismissed; costs to Man Sang, taxed if not agreed.