NATIONAL ENGINEERING INDUSTRIES LTD. versus ITS WORKMEN

NATIONAL ENGINEERING INDUSTRIES LTD. versus ITS WORKMEN

When quotations for machinery are available, the Tribunal should use them to determine replacement cost for rehabilitation calculation and avoid the multiplier method, as the quotations are more accurate. Rehabilitation for old machinery must be based on the cost of new machinery, estimates should be item-wise if practicable, a graduated divisor reflecting actual remainder life should be used, and only notional normal depreciation (not statutory depreciation or development rebate) is deducted. Claims for bonus can be denied if made after a substantial delay (laches).

Parties
Appellant: National Engineering Industries Ltd.; Respondent: Its Workmen
Jurisdiction
India
Judgment Date
06 October 1967
Procedural Posture
Civil Appeal / Appeal by Special Leave Under Article 136 of the Constitution
Outcome
Appeal by company allowed, appeal by Union dismissed
Legal Topics
Bonus Payment, Calculation of Rehabilitation Cost, Interest on Paid Up Capital, Depreciation and Development Rebate, Delay and Laches
Labour Law Industrial Disputes Bonus Payment Calculation of Rehabilitation Cost Interest on Paid Up Capital Depreciation and Development Rebate Delay and Laches

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Legal principles 6 Authorities cited 12 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 9
Sign in to unlock

Parties

National Engineering Industries Ltd.

Appellant

Its Workmen

Respondent

Procedural Posture

Civil Appeal / Appeal by Special Leave Under Article 136 of the Constitution

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether multiplier method is necessary for calculating rehabilitation cost when quotations are available
  2. 2 Whether item-wise or block-wise estimate should be used
  3. 3 Whether a uniform or graduated divisor should be used for machinery installed in different years

Ratio Decidendi

When quotations for machinery are available, the Tribunal should use them to determine replacement cost for rehabilitation calculation and avoid the multiplier method, as the quotations are more accurate. Rehabilitation for old machinery must be based on the cost of new machinery, estimates should be item-wise if practicable, a graduated divisor reflecting actual remainder life should be used, and only notional normal depreciation (not statutory depreciation or development rebate) is deducted. Claims for bonus can be denied if made after a substantial delay (laches).

Court Disposition

Appeal by company allowed, appeal by Union dismissed

Orders

  • The direction for payment of bonus for 1957-58 to 1959-60 is set aside
  • Appeal by the Union is dismissed