University College Cork v Electricity Supply Board (Approved) [2020] IESC 38_1 (08 July 2020)

University College Cork v Electricity Supply Board (Approved) [2020] IESC 38_1 (08 July 2020)

The ESB, having assumed control over the river Lee through its dams and public representations, owed a duty of care to downstream property owners. This duty was not excluded by its statutory obligation to generate electricity. The standard required was reasonable care in managing reservoir levels, taking into account weather forecasts and ground conditions. The ESB failed to exercise such care, and liability in negligence was established. The 'do not worsen nature' standard is insufficient; reasonable care is required where control is assumed.

Citation
[2020] IESC 38_1
Parties
Plaintiff/respondent: University College Cork - National University of Ireland; Defendant/appellant: Electricity Supply Board
Jurisdiction
Ireland
Judgment Date
08 July 2020
Procedural Posture
Civil Appeal / Supreme Court Judgment on Appeal From Court of Appeal
Outcome
Appeal dismissed; liability of ESB affirmed; issue of contributory negligence and damages remitted for further hearing.
Legal Topics
Duty of Care, Omissions in Negligence, Statutory Duties, Flood Management, Liability of Public Authorities, Nuisance, Measured Duty Jurisprudence
Tort Law Negligence Public Law Duty of Care Omissions in Negligence Statutory Duties Flood Management Liability of Public Authorities +2 more

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 4 Authorities cited 21 Party arguments 2
Sign in to unlock

Parties

University College Cork - National University of Ireland

Plaintiff/respondent

Electricity Supply Board

Defendant/appellant

Procedural Posture

Civil Appeal / Supreme Court Judgment on Appeal From Court of Appeal

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether ESB owed a duty of care in negligence to downstream property owners for flood damage caused by dam management
  2. 2 Whether ESB's statutory duty to generate electricity excluded liability in tort
  3. 3 Whether ESB's actions or omissions in managing reservoir levels constituted negligence or nuisance

Ratio Decidendi

The ESB, having assumed control over the river Lee through its dams and public representations, owed a duty of care to downstream property owners. This duty was not excluded by its statutory obligation to generate electricity. The standard required was reasonable care in managing reservoir levels, taking into account weather forecasts and ground conditions. The ESB failed to exercise such care, and liability in negligence was established. The 'do not worsen nature' standard is insufficient; reasonable care is required where control is assumed.

Court Disposition

Appeal dismissed; liability of ESB affirmed; issue of contributory negligence and damages remitted for further hearing.

Orders

  • Liability of ESB for negligence affirmed
  • Issue of contributory negligence by UCC to be determined in further proceedings