1. ) Bukit Tinggi Hospital Sdn Bhd 2. ) Dr Prashanth Nambiar a/l Padmanabhan 1. ) Navin Sharma a/l Karam Chand 2. ) Saroop Rampal a/p Hardyal Rampal

1. ) Bukit Tinggi Hospital Sdn Bhd 2. ) Dr Prashanth Nambiar a/l Padmanabhan 1. ) Navin Sharma a/l Karam Chand 2. ) Saroop Rampal a/p Hardyal Rampal

Aggravated damages must be expressly pleaded, particularised and proved; an estate may only recover aggravated damages for aggravating conduct that occurred while the deceased was alive and sentient and perceived such conduct; post‑death conduct and litigation strategy cannot form the basis for aggravated damages and should be addressed by costs or procedural sanctions; loss of dependency must be supported by cogent evidence of actual contribution, and where such evidence is absent the dependency award must be set aside. Applying these principles the Court adjusted several quantum items and set aside the RM700,000 aggravated damages and the RM176,280 dependency award.

Citation
B-02(NCvC)(W)-1482-09/2023 (Mahkamah Rayuan)
Parties
Defendant/appellant: Bukit Tinggi Hospital Sdn Bhd; Defendant/appellant: Dr Prashanth Nambiar A/L Padmanabhan; Plaintiff/appellant (administrator of Estate): Navin Sharma A/L Karam Chand; Plaintiff/appellant (administrator of Estate): Saroop Rampal A/P Hardyal Rampal
Court
NCvC
Jurisdiction
Malaysia
Judgment Date
23 September 2025
Case Number
B-02(NCvC)(W)-1482-09/2023 (Mahkamah Rayuan)
Procedural Posture
Medical Negligence; Estate and Dependency Claims Under Civil Law Act 1956 / Appeal to Court of Appeal on Quantum (liability Accepted by Parties)
Outcome
Appeal allowed in part and dismissed in part. High Court awards varied: some special damages reduced, pain and suffering reduced, dependency and aggravated damages set aside, trial costs increased, interest rate reduced.
Legal Topics
Aggravated Damages, General Damages, Special Damages, Loss of Dependency, Pleadings, Trial Costs, Interest
Source Language
Malay/English
Tort Medical Negligence Civil Procedure Damages Estates and Succession Aggravated Damages General Damages Special Damages +4 more

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 5 Authorities cited 13 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 8
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Bukit Tinggi Hospital Sdn Bhd

Defendant/appellant

Dr Prashanth Nambiar A/L Padmanabhan

Defendant/appellant

Navin Sharma A/L Karam Chand

Plaintiff/appellant (administrator of Estate)

Saroop Rampal A/P Hardyal Rampal

Plaintiff/appellant (administrator of Estate)

Procedural Posture

Medical Negligence; Estate and Dependency Claims Under Civil Law Act 1956 / Appeal to Court of Appeal on Quantum (liability Accepted by Parties)

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether aggravated damages may be claimed by an estate for conduct occurring after the deceased's death
  2. 2 Whether aggravated damages must be specifically pleaded and particularised
  3. 3 Whether the estate proved loss of dependency under s.7 CLA

Ratio Decidendi

Aggravated damages must be expressly pleaded, particularised and proved; an estate may only recover aggravated damages for aggravating conduct that occurred while the deceased was alive and sentient and perceived such conduct; post‑death conduct and litigation strategy cannot form the basis for aggravated damages and should be addressed by costs or procedural sanctions; loss of dependency must be supported by cogent evidence of actual contribution, and where such evidence is absent the dependency award must be set aside. Applying these principles the Court adjusted several quantum items and set aside the RM700,000 aggravated damages and the RM176,280 dependency award.

Court Disposition

Appeal allowed in part and dismissed in part. High Court awards varied: some special damages reduced, pain and suffering reduced, dependency and aggravated damages set aside, trial costs increased, interest rate reduced.

Orders

  • Item 1 (hospital charges) reduced from RM49,601.50 to RM33,000.00
  • Item 2 (funeral and memorial services) RM15,000.00 maintained