TAN KEEN KEONG @ TAN KEAN KEONG TAN ENG HONG PAPER & STATIONERY SDN BHD & 4 Lagi

TAN KEEN KEONG @ TAN KEAN KEONG TAN ENG HONG PAPER & STATIONERY SDN BHD & 4 Lagi

The Federal Court set aside the High Court winding-up orders because the findings of illegality and statutory contraventions were not established with sufficient evidential support or nexus to the companies' corporate objects, the petitioner and key witnesses lacked credibility and the petitions were an abuse/for a collateral purpose; the court must be slow to wind up solvent companies for alleged director misconduct where alternative remedies and criminal or tax processes exist and proportionality and statutory purpose do not support dissolution.

Citation
02(f)-5-02/2017(P) & 4 Kes Berkaitan (Mahkamah Persekutuan)
Parties
Appellant/petitioner: Tan Keen Keong @ Tan Kean Keong; Appellant/respondent: Tan Eng Hong Paper & Stationery Sdn Bhd; Appellant/respondent: Tan Eng Hong Holdings Sdn Bhd; Respondent: Peace Centre Sdn Bhd; Respondent: Tan Seng Choo; Respondent: Tan Seng Kiat; Respondent/director: Tan Seng Kow (TSK); Respondent: Tan Kin Seng; Witness/instigator Alleged by Respondents: Tan Choo Leong (TCL)
Court
f
Jurisdiction
Malaysia
Judgment Date
17 December 2020
Case Number
02(f)-5-02/2017(P) & 4 Kes Berkaitan (Mahkamah Persekutuan)
Procedural Posture
Civil Appeal (company Winding Up) / Final Federal Court Judgment on Appeals From Court of Appeal and High Court
Outcome
Appeals by Tan Eng Hong Paper & Stationery Sdn Bhd and Tan Eng Hong Holdings Sdn Bhd allowed; High Court winding-up orders set aside; appeals by Tan Keen Keong dismissed
Legal Topics
Winding Up, Just and Equitable Ground, Illegality, Quasi Partnership, Abuse of Process, Minority Shareholder Relief, Section 218 Companies Act 1965
Source Language
Malay/English
Company Law Insolvency Law Equity Tax Law Criminal Law Civil Procedure Winding Up Just and Equitable Ground +5 more

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 4 Authorities cited 20 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 3
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Tan Keen Keong @ Tan Kean Keong

Appellant/petitioner

Tan Eng Hong Paper & Stationery Sdn Bhd

Appellant/respondent

Tan Eng Hong Holdings Sdn Bhd

Appellant/respondent

Peace Centre Sdn Bhd

Respondent

Tan Seng Choo

Respondent

Tan Seng Kiat

Respondent

Tan Seng Kow (TSK)

Respondent/director

Tan Kin Seng

Respondent

Tan Choo Leong (TCL)

Witness/instigator Alleged by Respondents

Procedural Posture

Civil Appeal (company Winding Up) / Final Federal Court Judgment on Appeals From Court of Appeal and High Court

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether illegality or statutory contraventions justify winding-up under s218(1)(i)
  2. 2 Whether petitioner with impugned credibility can obtain equitable relief under s218(1)(i)
  3. 3 Whether contraventions by directors can be imputed to company to justify winding-up

Ratio Decidendi

The Federal Court set aside the High Court winding-up orders because the findings of illegality and statutory contraventions were not established with sufficient evidential support or nexus to the companies' corporate objects, the petitioner and key witnesses lacked credibility and the petitions were an abuse/for a collateral purpose; the court must be slow to wind up solvent companies for alleged director misconduct where alternative remedies and criminal or tax processes exist and proportionality and statutory purpose do not support dissolution.

Court Disposition

Appeals by Tan Eng Hong Paper & Stationery Sdn Bhd and Tan Eng Hong Holdings Sdn Bhd allowed; High Court winding-up orders set aside; appeals by Tan Keen Keong dismissed

Orders

  • Winding-up orders against Tan Eng Hong Paper & Stationery Sdn Bhd and Tan Eng Hong Holdings Sdn Bhd set aside
  • Appeals by Tan Keen Keong dismissed