Trevor, Inquest into the Death of [2023] NICoroner 3 (19 April 2023)
The death of Gillian Trevor was caused by cerebral infarction due to subdural empyema resulting from sinusitis. There were multiple missed opportunities for earlier diagnosis and intervention during her hospital attendances, including failure to seek urgent ENT input, failure to perform timely MRI or contrast CT imaging, and inadequate documentation and consultant review. These failures, on the balance of probabilities, contributed to her death.
- Citation
- [2023] NICoroner 3
- Parties
- Deceased: Gillian Trevor (deceased); Family/next of Kin: William Chestnutt; Family: Claire Chestnutt; Witness/gp: Dr Hawe; Witness/emergency Medicine Registrar: Dr Gilani; Witness/consultant Radiologist: Dr Tam; Witness/consultant in General Medicine: Dr Unamuno; Witness/foundation Doctor: Dr Cubitt; Witness: Dr Maybin; Witness/clinical Sister: Nurse Perry; Witness/middle Grade Doctor: Dr Njisane; Witness/gp Trainee: Dr Donaghy; Witness: Nurse McNicholl; Witness/deputy Ward Sister: Nurse Maguire; Witness/locum Medical SHO: Dr Hamida; Witness/locum Consultant Physician: Dr Jelly; Witness: Nurse Dillon; Witness/foundation Year 2 Doctor: Dr Morrow; Witness/patient Flow Co Ordinator: Mr McCloud; Witness/consultant Neurosurgeon: Mr Cooke; Witness/consultant Neurosurgeon: Mr Quigley; Witness/ent Consultant: Dr Toner; Witness/medical Director NIAS: Dr Nigel Ruddell; Expert/consultant Neurosurgeon: Professor Crimmins; Expert/consultant Ent, Head and Neck Surgeon: Mr Cox; Witness/consultant in Emergency Medicine: Dr Dunn
- Jurisdiction
- Northern Ireland
- Judgment Date
- 19 April 2023
- Procedural Posture
- Inquest / Findings Delivered After Full Inquest With Oral and Written Evidence
- Outcome
- Death by misadventure contributed to by missed opportunities and inadequate medical management
- Legal Topics
- Inquest, Medical Negligence, Hospital Procedure, Death Investigation, Clinical Governance
Case Brief
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Gillian Trevor (deceased)
Deceased
William Chestnutt
Family/next of Kin
Claire Chestnutt
Family
Dr Hawe
Witness/gp
Dr Gilani
Witness/emergency Medicine Registrar
Dr Tam
Witness/consultant Radiologist
Dr Unamuno
Witness/consultant in General Medicine
Dr Cubitt
Witness/foundation Doctor
Dr Maybin
Witness
Nurse Perry
Witness/clinical Sister
Dr Njisane
Witness/middle Grade Doctor
Dr Donaghy
Witness/gp Trainee
Nurse McNicholl
Witness
Nurse Maguire
Witness/deputy Ward Sister
Dr Hamida
Witness/locum Medical SHO
Dr Jelly
Witness/locum Consultant Physician
Nurse Dillon
Witness
Dr Morrow
Witness/foundation Year 2 Doctor
Mr McCloud
Witness/patient Flow Co Ordinator
Mr Cooke
Witness/consultant Neurosurgeon
Mr Quigley
Witness/consultant Neurosurgeon
Dr Toner
Witness/ent Consultant
Dr Nigel Ruddell
Witness/medical Director NIAS
Professor Crimmins
Expert/consultant Neurosurgeon
Mr Cox
Expert/consultant Ent, Head and Neck Surgeon
Dr Dunn
Witness/consultant in Emergency Medicine
Procedural Posture
Inquest / Findings Delivered After Full Inquest With Oral and Written Evidence
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether there were missed opportunities in the care and treatment of Gillian Trevor leading to her death
- 2 Whether the medical management at Causeway Hospital was adequate and appropriate
- 3 Whether the cause of death was properly established and attributable to substandard care
Ratio Decidendi
The death of Gillian Trevor was caused by cerebral infarction due to subdural empyema resulting from sinusitis. There were multiple missed opportunities for earlier diagnosis and intervention during her hospital attendances, including failure to seek urgent ENT input, failure to perform timely MRI or contrast CT imaging, and inadequate documentation and consultant review. These failures, on the balance of probabilities, contributed to her death.
Court Disposition
Death by misadventure contributed to by missed opportunities and inadequate medical management
Orders
- No formal orders as this is an inquest, but recommendations for improved clinical practice, documentation, senior review of re-attendances, and awareness of cerebral empyema as a complication of sinusitis.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
Sign in to read
Sign in to read the full judgment text
Sign in to read the full judgment text. Downloads and additional research tools may depend on your plan.
Sign in to read the full judgment