Trevor, Inquest into the Death of [2023] NICoroner 3 (19 April 2023)

Trevor, Inquest into the Death of [2023] NICoroner 3 (19 April 2023)

The death of Gillian Trevor was caused by cerebral infarction due to subdural empyema resulting from sinusitis. There were multiple missed opportunities for earlier diagnosis and intervention during her hospital attendances, including failure to seek urgent ENT input, failure to perform timely MRI or contrast CT imaging, and inadequate documentation and consultant review. These failures, on the balance of probabilities, contributed to her death.

Citation
[2023] NICoroner 3
Parties
Deceased: Gillian Trevor (deceased); Family/next of Kin: William Chestnutt; Family: Claire Chestnutt; Witness/gp: Dr Hawe; Witness/emergency Medicine Registrar: Dr Gilani; Witness/consultant Radiologist: Dr Tam; Witness/consultant in General Medicine: Dr Unamuno; Witness/foundation Doctor: Dr Cubitt; Witness: Dr Maybin; Witness/clinical Sister: Nurse Perry; Witness/middle Grade Doctor: Dr Njisane; Witness/gp Trainee: Dr Donaghy; Witness: Nurse McNicholl; Witness/deputy Ward Sister: Nurse Maguire; Witness/locum Medical SHO: Dr Hamida; Witness/locum Consultant Physician: Dr Jelly; Witness: Nurse Dillon; Witness/foundation Year 2 Doctor: Dr Morrow; Witness/patient Flow Co Ordinator: Mr McCloud; Witness/consultant Neurosurgeon: Mr Cooke; Witness/consultant Neurosurgeon: Mr Quigley; Witness/ent Consultant: Dr Toner; Witness/medical Director NIAS: Dr Nigel Ruddell; Expert/consultant Neurosurgeon: Professor Crimmins; Expert/consultant Ent, Head and Neck Surgeon: Mr Cox; Witness/consultant in Emergency Medicine: Dr Dunn
Jurisdiction
Northern Ireland
Judgment Date
19 April 2023
Procedural Posture
Inquest / Findings Delivered After Full Inquest With Oral and Written Evidence
Outcome
Death by misadventure contributed to by missed opportunities and inadequate medical management
Legal Topics
Inquest, Medical Negligence, Hospital Procedure, Death Investigation, Clinical Governance

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 4 Authorities cited 1 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 1
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Gillian Trevor (deceased)

Deceased

William Chestnutt

Family/next of Kin

Claire Chestnutt

Family

Dr Hawe

Witness/gp

Dr Gilani

Witness/emergency Medicine Registrar

Dr Tam

Witness/consultant Radiologist

Dr Unamuno

Witness/consultant in General Medicine

Dr Cubitt

Witness/foundation Doctor

Dr Maybin

Witness

Nurse Perry

Witness/clinical Sister

Dr Njisane

Witness/middle Grade Doctor

Dr Donaghy

Witness/gp Trainee

Nurse McNicholl

Witness

Nurse Maguire

Witness/deputy Ward Sister

Dr Hamida

Witness/locum Medical SHO

Dr Jelly

Witness/locum Consultant Physician

Nurse Dillon

Witness

Dr Morrow

Witness/foundation Year 2 Doctor

Mr McCloud

Witness/patient Flow Co Ordinator

Mr Cooke

Witness/consultant Neurosurgeon

Mr Quigley

Witness/consultant Neurosurgeon

Dr Toner

Witness/ent Consultant

Dr Nigel Ruddell

Witness/medical Director NIAS

Professor Crimmins

Expert/consultant Neurosurgeon

Mr Cox

Expert/consultant Ent, Head and Neck Surgeon

Dr Dunn

Witness/consultant in Emergency Medicine

Procedural Posture

Inquest / Findings Delivered After Full Inquest With Oral and Written Evidence

  1. 1 Whether there were missed opportunities in the care and treatment of Gillian Trevor leading to her death
  2. 2 Whether the medical management at Causeway Hospital was adequate and appropriate
  3. 3 Whether the cause of death was properly established and attributable to substandard care

Ratio Decidendi

The death of Gillian Trevor was caused by cerebral infarction due to subdural empyema resulting from sinusitis. There were multiple missed opportunities for earlier diagnosis and intervention during her hospital attendances, including failure to seek urgent ENT input, failure to perform timely MRI or contrast CT imaging, and inadequate documentation and consultant review. These failures, on the balance of probabilities, contributed to her death.

Court Disposition

Death by misadventure contributed to by missed opportunities and inadequate medical management

Orders

  • No formal orders as this is an inquest, but recommendations for improved clinical practice, documentation, senior review of re-attendances, and awareness of cerebral empyema as a complication of sinusitis.