Goni v S (SS93/08) [2010] ZAWCHC 95 (23 March 2010)
The court found that, although the applicant's alibi and supporting witness were not accepted as reasonably possibly true in light of the identity evidence, there remains a reasonable prospect that another court may reach a different conclusion regarding both the convictions and the sentences imposed. Accordingly,...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [2010] ZAWCHC 95
- Parties
- Applicant: Mthetheleli Goni; Respondent: The State
- Court
- Western Cape High Court, Cape Town
- Jurisdiction
- South Africa
- Case Number
- SS93/08
- Procedural Posture
- Leave to Appeal / Application for Leave to Appeal
- Outcome
- Leave to appeal is granted to the Full Bench of this division against both the convictions and the sentences imposed.
- Judges
- Louw
- Legal Topics
- Leave to Appeal, Alibi Defence, Identity Evidence, Sentencing, Life Imprisonment
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Mthetheleli Goni
Applicant
The State
Respondent
Procedural Posture
Leave to Appeal / Application for Leave to Appeal
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether there is a reasonable prospect that another court may reach a different conclusion regarding the applicant's convictions.
- 2 Whether leave to appeal should be granted against the sentences imposed, including two life sentences.
Ratio Decidendi
The court found that, although the applicant's alibi and supporting witness were not accepted as reasonably possibly true in light of the identity evidence, there remains a reasonable prospect that another court may reach a different conclusion regarding both the convictions and the sentences imposed. Accordingly, leave to appeal is granted to the Full Bench of the division on both convictions and sentences.
Court Disposition
Leave to appeal is granted to the Full Bench of this division against both the convictions and the sentences imposed.
Orders
- Leave to appeal against the convictions and sentences is granted to the Full Bench of this division.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
17 paragraphs
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
(WESTERN CAPE, HIGH COURT, CAPE TOWN)
CASE NUMBER: SS93/08
DATUM: 23 MARCH 2010
In the matter between:
MTHETHELELI GONI Applicant
and
THE STATE Respondent
JUDGMENT
(Application for leave to appeal)
LOUW, J:
The applicant in this matter was accused 1 in the trial He was found guilty on a number of counts arising from events which took place on the night of 30 September 2006. The applicant raised an alibi, gave evidence to that effect and called a witness. I found that the evidence of the applicant and his witness was not reasonably possibly true in the light of all the evidence regarding identity which placed him on the scene on the night in question.
This is, however, a matter I believe where there is a reasonable prospect that another court may come to a different conclusion and in my view leave to appeal should be granted on the convictions.
Turning to the application for leave to appeal against the sentences imposed, two life sentences were imposed. Again, this is a case where another court may reasonably come to another conclusion in regard to the appropriate sentence and I believe that leave to appeal against the sentences imposed should also be granted.
I therefore make the following order:
The application for leave to appeal against the convictions and sentences succeed and LEAVE TO APPEAL IS GRANTED to the Full Bench of this division against both the convictions and the sentences imposed.
LOUW, J