Njeje and Another v Member of the Executive Council for Health And Social Development Province of Gauteng . (19101/2011) [2015] ZAGPJHC 43 (3 March 2015)

Njeje and Another v Member of the Executive Council for Health And Social Development Province of Gauteng . (19101/2011) [2015] ZAGPJHC 43 (3 March 2015)

The plaintiffs failed to present any evidence to substantiate their allegations of negligence against the defendant. The only witness, Ms Njeje, was not present at the time of the incident and could not provide relevant testimony regarding the hospital staff's conduct or supervision. The particulars of claim set out various grounds of negligence, but none were supported by evidence. The court held that it could not speculate or draw inferences in the absence of proof and, applying the established test for absolution from the instance, found that no reasonable court could find for the plaintiffs. Accordingly, the defendant was absolved from the instance and the plaintiffs were ordered to...

Citation
[2015] ZAGPJHC 43
Parties
Plaintiff: Beauty Bongiwe Njeje; Plaintiff: Elias Shikhundla; Defendant: The Member of the Executive Council for Health and Social Development Province of Gauteng
Court
South Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg
Jurisdiction
South Africa
Judgment Date
3 March 2015
Case Number
19101/2011
Procedural Posture
Civil Trial / Absolution From the Instance at Close of Plaintiffs' Case
Outcome
Defendant absolved from the instance; plaintiffs ordered to pay costs.
Judges
FHD Van Oosten
Legal Topics
Medical Negligence, Hospital Liability, Duty of Care, Absolution From Instance
Delict Medical Negligence Hospital Liability Duty of Care Absolution From Instance

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 2 Authorities cited 2 Party arguments 2
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Beauty Bongiwe Njeje

Plaintiff

Elias Shikhundla

Plaintiff

The Member of the Executive Council for Health and Social Development Province of Gauteng

Defendant

Procedural Posture

Civil Trial / Absolution From the Instance at Close of Plaintiffs' Case

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether the defendant owed a legal duty to the deceased and plaintiffs to provide reasonable medical treatment and nursing services.
  2. 2 Whether the defendant breached the duty of care by failing to supervise and protect the deceased adequately.
  3. 3 Whether there was sufficient evidence of negligence on the part of the hospital staff to hold the defendant liable for the deceased's death.

Ratio Decidendi

The plaintiffs failed to present any evidence to substantiate their allegations of negligence against the defendant. The only witness, Ms Njeje, was not present at the time of the incident and could not provide relevant testimony regarding the hospital staff's conduct or supervision. The particulars of claim set out various grounds of negligence, but none were supported by evidence. The court held that it could not speculate or draw inferences in the absence of proof and, applying the established test for absolution from the instance, found that no reasonable court could find for the plaintiffs. Accordingly, the defendant was absolved from the instance and the plaintiffs were ordered to...

Court Disposition

Defendant absolved from the instance; plaintiffs ordered to pay costs.

Orders

  • The defendant is absolved from the instance.
  • The plaintiffs are ordered to pay the costs of the action.