Office of the Consumer Protector Western Cape obo Sebeela v Royal Cape Glass and Aluminium (NCT/68923/2016/70(3)(b)) [2017] ZANCT 46 (13 February 2017)
The Tribunal found that the Office of the Consumer Protector acted as a consumer court or mediation entity within the meaning of section 70(1) of the Consumer Protection Act. The settlement agreement between the consumer and the respondent was properly facilitated, reduced to writing, and signed by both parties. The...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [2017] ZANCT 46
- Parties
- Applicant: Office of the Consumer Protector: Western Cape; Applicant: J Sebeela; Respondent: Royal Cape Glass and Aluminium
- Court
- National Consumer Tribunal
- Jurisdiction
- South Africa
- Case Number
- NCT/68923/2016/70(3)(b)
- Procedural Posture
- Consent Order Application / Application for Confirmation of Settlement Agreement as Tribunal Order
- Outcome
- Application granted; settlement agreement confirmed as Tribunal order.
- Judges
- JR Simpson
- Legal Topics
- Consent Order, Alternative Dispute Resolution, Settlement Agreement, Consumer Protection Act, National Credit Act
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Office of the Consumer Protector: Western Cape
Applicant
J Sebeela
Applicant
Royal Cape Glass and Aluminium
Respondent
Procedural Posture
Consent Order Application / Application for Confirmation of Settlement Agreement as Tribunal Order
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the settlement agreement between the consumer and the respondent may be confirmed as a consent order by the Tribunal under section 138 of the National Credit Act and section 70 of the Consumer Protection Act.
- 2 Whether the Office of the Consumer Protector qualifies as a consumer court or mediation entity under section 70(1) of the Consumer Protection Act.
Ratio Decidendi
The Tribunal found that the Office of the Consumer Protector acted as a consumer court or mediation entity within the meaning of section 70(1) of the Consumer Protection Act. The settlement agreement between the consumer and the respondent was properly facilitated, reduced to writing, and signed by both parties. The Tribunal is empowered under section 138 of the National Credit Act and Rule 20 of its Rules to confirm such agreements as consent orders without hearing evidence. The application met all statutory requirements, and the Tribunal accordingly confirmed the settlement agreement as an order of the Tribunal.
Court Disposition
Application granted; settlement agreement confirmed as Tribunal order.
Orders
- The signed settlement agreement between the consumer and the respondent, dated 15 August 2016, is confirmed as an order of the Tribunal.
- No further evidence is required for confirmation of the consent order.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
51 paragraphs
IN THE NATIONAL CONSUMER TRIBUNAL
HELD IN CENTURION
Case number: NCT/68923/2016/70 (3) (b)
In the matter between:
OFFICE OF THE CONSUMER PROTECTOR:
WESTERN CAPE
Applicant
and
J SEBEELA
Consumer
ROYAL CAPE GLASS AND ALUMINIUM
Respondent
CONSENT ORDER
1. The Applicant in this matter is the Office of the Consumer Protector (“the Protector”).
2. The Respondent is Royal Cape Glass and Aluminium, further details of which are unknown, represented by Mr Ismael Patel.
3. The Consumer is Ms J Sebeela, further details are unknown.
4. The Protector filed an application with the Tribunal in terms of section 138 of the National Credit Act 34 of 2005 (“the NCA”) to have a settlement agreement reached between the parties made an order of the Tribunal.
5. Section 138 of the NCA states the following -
138. Consent orders.—
(1) If a matter has been—
(a) resolved through the ombud with jurisdiction, consumer court or alternative dispute resolution agent;
or
(b) investigated by the National Credit Regulator, and the National Credit Regulator and the respondent agree to the proposed terms of an appropriate order, the Tribunal or a court, without hearing any evidence, may confirm that resolution or agreement as a consent order.
(2) With the consent of a complainant, a consent order confirmed in terms of subsection (1) (b) may include an award of damages to the complainant.
6. Section 70 of the Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008 (“the CPA”) states the following –
Alternative dispute resolution
70. (1) A consumer may seek to resolve any dispute in respect of a transaction or
agreement with a supplier by referring the matter to an alternative dispute resolution agent who may be—
(a) an ombud with jurisdiction, if the supplier is subject to the jurisdiction of any such ombud;
(b) an industry ombud accredited in terms of section 82(6), if the supplier is subject to the jurisdiction of any such ombud;
(c) a person or entity providing conciliation, mediation or arbitration services to assist in the resolution of consumer disputes, other than an ombud with jurisdiction, or an accredited industry ombud; or
(d) applying to the consumer court of the province with jurisdiction over the matter, if there is such a consumer court, subject to the law establishing or governing that consumer court.
(2)……
(3) If an alternative dispute resolution agent has resolved, or assisted parties in resolving their dispute, the agent may—
(a) record the resolution of that dispute in the form of an order, and
(b) if the parties to the dispute consent to that order, submit it to the Tribunal or the High Court to be made a consent order, in terms of its rules.
(4) With the consent of a complainant, a consent order confirmed in terms of subsection (3)(b) may include an award of damages to that complainant.
7. The Protector facilitated the settlement of a dispute between the Consumer and the Respondent which was reduced to writing and signed
by both parties on 15 August 2016. The Protector can be regarded as a consumer court or even as an entity providing mediation
services within the meaning of section 70(1) of the CPA.
8. The Applicant has applied for the settlement order to be made an order of the Tribunal in accordance with its Rules, being Rule 20 of the Rules[1] and Section 138 of the NCA.
9. The Tribunal hereby grants the application and confirms the signed settlement agreement, marked as Annexure A, as an order of the
Tribunal.
Dated and signed at Centurion on 13 February 2017
ADV JR SIMPSON
PRESIDING MEMBER
NATIONAL CONSUMER TRIBUNAL
[1] 20. Consent orders.—(1) The Tribunal may confirm a resolution or agreement as a consent order— (a) on application by the facilitator of that resolution or agreement; and (b) without hearing any evidence.
[1] 20. Consent orders.—(1) The Tribunal may confirm a resolution or agreement as a consent order—
(a) on application by the facilitator of that resolution or agreement; and
(b) without hearing any evidence.