19890904 TZHC Lindi
- Citation
- 19890904 TZHC Lindi
- Status
- Judgment
- Jurisdiction
- Tanzania
- Court
- TZHC
- Decision
- 4 September 1989
- Posture
- Criminal / Judgment After Plea and Sentencing
- Language
- English
More details
- Court
- TZHC
- Decision
- 4 September 1989
- Posture
- Criminal / Judgment After Plea and Sentencing
- Language
- English
On this page
Professional case brief
Research organized from the available case record
01
Holding and result
The accused admitted to causing the death of the deceased by striking him with an axe handle, and the court accepted the plea of guilty to manslaughter as the act was not intentional but resulted in death.
Court disposition
Convicted of manslaughter on own plea of guilty; sentenced to 14 years imprisonment.
Orders
- Accused convicted of manslaughter under section 195 of the Penal Code.
- Accused sentenced to fourteen (14) years imprisonment.
02
Material facts
Parties
The Republic
Prosecution Counsel: Mr. SangasweWilliam Hamisi Chande @ Polo
Accused Counsel: Mr. KumwembeAmounts and remedies
- Sentence Length: 14
03
Procedural history
Posture
Criminal / Judgment After Plea and Sentencing
04
Questions and positions
Legal issues
Whether the accused is guilty of manslaughter under section 195 of the Penal Code
Party arguments
- Applicant
- The prosecution presented evidence that the accused struck the deceased with an axe handle, causing fatal head injuries. The accused admitted to the act but claimed it was not intentional.
- Respondent
- The accused pleaded guilty to manslaughter, admitting to causing the death but without intent to kill.
05
Court’s reasoning
Legal principles
- 01
Section 195 of the Penal Code
A person who unlawfully kills another without malice aforethought is guilty of manslaughter.
06
Ratio, limits and disposition
Ratio decidendi
The accused admitted to causing the death of the deceased by striking him with an axe handle, and the court accepted the plea of guilty to manslaughter as the act was not intentional but resulted in death.
Obiter and limits
- The court has a duty to discourage acts of violence by imposing severe sentences.
Court disposition
Convicted of manslaughter on own plea of guilty; sentenced to 14 years imprisonment.
- Accused convicted of manslaughter under section 195 of the Penal Code.
- Accused sentenced to fourteen (14) years imprisonment.
Source and reliance status
TZHC · 4 September 1989
This page organises the available record for research. Confirm quotations, current status, and subsequent treatment against the official source before relying on the case.
Judgment reading view
Judgment text
The complete available source text.
TZHC
Judgment· 4 September 1989
IN T"dE nran comT OF TA.NZL1ITA A1.. LDT.DI
ORIGINAL JURBDICTION (Mtwara Regi:3try) CRDCTi:ii.l.L :3:ESSIONS CLJE rJO o 27 OF 1989 The Republic versus WILLIAM IIJJUSI OIIJJ.'J.DE@ POLO Hieb- Court Sessions at L.1-ndi Date.I J().8.89 Coram, Ma.:l.na, Juci~-e Mr. San8'e,we, Jtate ·Attorney for the Rep..tblico u.,. m.um.tembe, 0o1,111Gel for the Aooused.. AOO\\Sed. '(name) ltillia-m llamisi Chand.e @ Polo ie present un1ler ouatody and. represented. by Mr, ro.,.mwembe. Interpreter Mr. ,Mohamad Na.mkumba.., En5liah into IG.swahili and vice versa. Notioe of t::i:-ia.l 011 Into:~'l'lle.tion for l!lU%'der oontrar~r to section 196 r:,'£ the Pena.l Cod.e wo.a duly F.JGl"V'ed on ·tile ;.;ousGds ~ow before the Court, ,,. Info:rmation iG rend ovor and axplain(id .to the accused in his own laneua,~~ and he is r;quirod to plead thoretos- Piea, It is not 1zlliue. Entered. as a. plea. of "Mot Guil ty11 to tho Cha.rcroo Trial to tollow latQr in the 8.esaions and aoousad, :ccn~:idcd into custody. G$d. I W, J, Ma:i.na, Judt;e 30.8.89 I I agtla. W.J. Maina Jud~ 30.8.89 \ . 2 I Corains Ma.ina., Judge. Mr. Sangs.we, 3tate .t.ttornoy.1 for the Ropublico Mr. Kumwombe, for the accusodo Accused :prescmt. -- ?-Ir. Kur:n·rnmboi 'Jho acou;-;er.l iG offering a 1,lGa of c,uil ty to r,,analaughter. O~urta The a.ocuood is rem.i.:n.docl of the cha1·,so. 49~l¼ii!ii @_)e.tOQf I ad.r,u. t I kill.0d tll.o W,JQ.O~;)Od but ;;. t W&,S not intentional. !£tC'l1S
... BY Iv!¥.-:. SJJIOl,riJ 'lhe· a,oounod and. th0 d o o ~ N';l.ollolau0 Uyam"vrozi N©,tli wore re13idonts of N~bu VillaGG in Liwalo Diawiot. On 16.9.1983 tho aoousod had been d.t-inking pombe ~.nd uhOJ:} he a.rrived. at b.ia hou.1:;o !lo founc.l his mother and his brother Majuto Ifo..r.,isi. They a.to food to,3oth0r. The aoouoed and his brother qual'r,ollcd ovor :t'artrl.11g. ~o aoousod was a!ll'lOy(ld wJ-?,on hia brother told him not to both.er him a.bout :f'a.rw.ll:£5• They fou~t, a11J. t!J.on the accuse<i"•s brotb.0r ran m-rn:J. '11'.lo a.couood oha.aod hie brother l-rl:iO rc;1.h into a, group of pooplo lr.J.o l were cla.i1cing. 'lho aooused, piokod a, axo hanc:llo,_ a.i.1.:.l ·Fhcn ho saw hie brother dancing, tho a.ocused airaed a. blow on his ?1"ot.!10r 113_ head, usins tho axe handle, but tho blow landod on the d.oo0v,r1ocl'o hoe,d.. Tho docoaood who had been da.uoill~ noxt to th4l aocuaod.'a brot.b.0:0, foll downo Bo sustained ·a big head injury £U1cl baoaxno W10.>11ooiouso ':lht:.J d.Go-oa.30-Cl wao oarriod to ld.we,lo Oovor1mont iloopi tal whore he died two day$ later, on 18.9.1988, •;'oatcoz-tor.1 ex..1.1:dnc,,tioll wei,a oonduotod, and I ihe dootor found. tha.t tho c1Ci>a.th wa.s duo ·to bra.in oono-uasion, following a.· direct and deprQ!Jr?JGtt ~a.oturo. of tb.o akull, oe,u::-sod b;y- a. blunt object. I t0ndo:r, a.ti oxhibit, b ,poartoartor:1 oxar.1:l.na. tion
report. Mr. lt_MmtlS1Jl~S.t ll'~ ~J~otion. 1 ifi.le aoouood. ,-rho ran a.way free. t.1._0 soono wa"3 e,rro;t~d on tho following day, 17.9.1988 anc1 ho uti.o Ql;11Jl:8'0d. '.,'·.· . ··· '-" . ··,i ' _· ;:,.~ . . . 3 CQ1,u•ti 'Iho accw3ocl is conv:i.ckdp o:'l !.,irJ own j_)lc,u, of 2,uil t;y-1 of nanslaucJ.: tor contrary to soc ti on 195 of tho Po;.1al Co,lo. Mr. Sanga:woa 1fo record of provious co:.n:i.Jtion:Jo I ask for a severe s011tono0 to bo :i.nposod. as a cloto:cr(::1coo fil ti&i:tion - Mr. I<llr:11101:1001 'Iho accused has boon in reman:1 cuotody for ono -;;-on:ro Ifo has a wi~e, ohildron and a divoroocl nothcr who doporn:l on .bin. '!hat iG all.- Ao:ouscda I have :::1othing to acld. Sentooooa 'lhe e,ooused eimod tho blow on tho clocoar.wd 1 s hoad uoin~ an axe handle. The oourt he,o the duty to disoouraGO rn.tct acts of violonco by imposing a aovero son~c0. T1..10 aceu::;od iG r;ontonood to fourteen (14) years imprisonment. Juclse
LINDI 4th 3optorober, 1989 •
Case-aware research
Ask AI about this case
The judgment and available research above are public. New questions open in a separate private conversation grounded in this case.