alliance one tobacco tanzania ltd vs grayson mcharo 2021 tzhcld 141 2 juni 2021

alliance one tobacco tanzania ltd vs grayson mcharo 2021 tzhcld 141 2 juni 2021

Mahakama imeona kuwa kuweka kadi ya gari kama dhamana kunaleta usumbufu na hakuna ushahidi wa kutosha kuhusu mali nyingine za Mleta Maombi wala thamani ya gari. Kwa kutenda haki kwa pande zote, dhamana mbadala ya fedha taslimu inafaa zaidi kuliko kadi ya gari.

Citation
alliance one tobacco tanzania ltd vs grayson mcharo 2021 tzhcld 141 2 juni 2021
Parties
Mleta Maombi: Alliance One Tobacco Tanzania Ltd; Mjibu Maombi: Grayson Mcharo
Court
TANZLII
Jurisdiction
Tanzania
Judgment Date
1 January 2021
Procedural Posture
Marejeo / Hukumu Ya Marejeo Dhidi Ya Amri Ya Naibu Msajili Katika Shauri La Ukaziaji Hukumu
Outcome
Amri ya Naibu Msajili ya kuweka kadi ya gari kama dhamana imefutwa na badala yake Mleta Maombi aweke fedha taslimu katika akaunti ya Mahakama.
Legal Topics
Stay of Execution, Security for Judgment Debt, Execution Proceedings
Source Language
English
Labour Law Civil Procedure Stay of Execution Security for Judgment Debt Execution Proceedings

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 2 Authorities cited 2 Party arguments 2 Amounts and remedies 1
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Alliance One Tobacco Tanzania Ltd

Mleta Maombi

Grayson Mcharo

Mjibu Maombi

Procedural Posture

Marejeo / Hukumu Ya Marejeo Dhidi Ya Amri Ya Naibu Msajili Katika Shauri La Ukaziaji Hukumu

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Iwapo Naibu Msajili alikuwa sahihi kuamuru kadi ya gari iwasilishwe kama dhamana dhidi ya tuzo ya Tume ya Usuluhishi na Uamuzi.
  2. 2 Iwapo Msajili alipaswa kukubali kuwa Mleta Maombi ni kampuni ya kimataifa yenye mali nyingi na hivyo dhamana ya gari haikuwa sahihi.

Ratio Decidendi

Mahakama imeona kuwa kuweka kadi ya gari kama dhamana kunaleta usumbufu na hakuna ushahidi wa kutosha kuhusu mali nyingine za Mleta Maombi wala thamani ya gari. Kwa kutenda haki kwa pande zote, dhamana mbadala ya fedha taslimu inafaa zaidi kuliko kadi ya gari.

Court Disposition

Amri ya Naibu Msajili ya kuweka kadi ya gari kama dhamana imefutwa na badala yake Mleta Maombi aweke fedha taslimu katika akaunti ya Mahakama.

Orders

  • Mleta Maombi aweke fedha taslimu shilingi 5,565,263 katika akaunti ya Mahakama ndani ya siku 14 toka tarehe ya uamuzi huu.
  • Kila upande utajilipia gharama za kuendesha shauri lake.