N

. ., .... .. .. 4T. •r~BO:-tA . .--~- :.,·: ·9 .OF lj~,. ~-- .j· Dis·rrUCT COU.dT ... .i . ;CIVIL 1 I • . ?TO 9 OF l~ , "• ao) \·,· .. , I.ii:,~i qr(! . ~ • •.. · ~ • ". o • o .-~ • -~-- • • "· • • o o o () 0 o 4 •• ·-APP.EL·L AI~T ·°lersus (Or1 6iual tl1::spondent) ,HJDG3IV!Zl\f T Tbe a;~._,,;,el_l_3._p/, a_ 1.s.cr;ooteacl1er , was su€.:: ~J t11e respondent for ·making his ;;mrpil,.· ~eJ b.,:1u:· ,. J.) •• ·......,_ \' ' -· ' .:../o M:-,__g,::i_tl/~~t th~ rGspondent'.~- iaughter, p regnan te TLtl ·it··.:~~.1i.~/f:rim;,~:; Co.ur_t 11~.u: ao d.iff icul ty i~·; u~_~olding the respondent's claimii~; view of the preponderance of eviden~e . . t ·e against the q,P1>0lian to ;i Bdefly, the facts vJti:i.ch have C'?,me out in tLe course of this case v:ere ths.t tt3 qppellant befrien'dcd. D.-,_L,. 1v~:ile sr..s was ·his purpil at Buk.,.,,..,i Prim~.ry Sci,oula .\ 1,tJ<i,rently t.hes he.a. sevcrg,J, amorous encounters bofor-.• th.a On hearing th3,t 1.such. ,-i3,s t!Je :c::tse ti10 A,ppel:'..a.1H stA,rted in!:l.king ,, arrangemc,nt.3 to minimi;:::~ tLe uffectc of his :nisd.GmE.anour~ He called the pupil at his Lome ~Hi_ w~ ilG his wife W<>.8 uor.10 distance in the 1 kitchen he beseeched un.1. )1p il to help him prGserve his career by n naming another pDrson ~~ I ·d,o 9.u.thor of her progn::i,ncyo He woud marry her in returnc ;\,, f' . . ·~e ',wo.u.ld l1RVG it the pup::.l .iuly implicat,ed one KasL.i.lje by writing hem ,'1- letLr w:_icl1'· s!.:o' q,rra,ngea. to fa.11 into the hands of the 3c!:uul ,,,utli.o ...'itieso She -;;;-Jon i)Urportod: to ;::i,dmit·having ·,· been made pregnt:.nt by K?:shi,nje to har un.cl0~ one S~i..u.. She wuut further and re3istered Kh,Si,.injo ::.t the clin.ic c1,c the f'3-ther of her . ,l expected chiidc: , All this, howaver, did,, not fool the rea~ondent who went ahead and succeeded to clair.i 5 ! 1:c~da, of c9.ttl0 9.S compensation from the appellant. Tllc tria.l court allowed the claim with one voice as they were fully justified to do. 1:- The Di..,trict M"'gistr:;te who heard the aP.,_al -•CJ' . ■h-keA . ~by .~h• -'. oopi_o1.1a . .. 1~~biase. :tb'3:. -~peilan_t ~ . , :~~plo,ved . JL . . ' 0 •.•••• 0 0 0 / 2.. to impeach the Itwa,ng Prim~.t'Y Court. , 0"1 tb.:, guest~on whether the appellant's liability should be rev1:: :~seJ 011 the g;r©und. that the • : • • ·-:-.:: ., ·'. . ,.J pupil mistakenly deacrib_ed him as circ.imsised 9 tb!:1 -.:3,p)e'3.l magistrate abserved:- •. •-! .. , ; ~ { : ... · 11 .U c_hi. wa ;r1;.-Jq,nci,ur.i·e ukisimarr!q, · gov-i ),.:a,zima : uri;.di nyum;:,, 9 .a~, 'kwakiiw'3. kr1.ti/:;:."3. shauri. . ',: .;. . . r hili 3.fiq,J-J~UGi kg, ni' insich¥--':l- r.1_;~ _hq,Kuol-GW:i • f' :• 11 q muo:n l:., "l. ruf a.1 i "\us sm ~ k.u 'N~ i,,JqJUek·'l?: ':'.)'rif-10 j P. ·· nq q,S3'N'J zq, kumuoni:,. nchi W,9,ka: bil::i, kus{mq.ma ni a/laj'. at-Jr.:b~_,:i_ ."l,,._/c -h~<.~t,-,,Liri,-Jg,,i 11 In his memo r'J.nd.i;:,r:i 9 ti~., ·a...?)e_ll-:i,.~ t tai:os i.3 ,ue vJi th the•'.:fin:dings of fact which two courts have so f_:,,r fou..'1,d h9ca,u.se to disoolieve • . :-~~>L ·J'~'- ·_· ..... ~ His insi5tence tt13. t .:1e W8,S mist,1,k~nly'· d::f~1•i h::;d_'-·As ci r::m.msi sed while-'.h_e in f;,,ct hac::. ::i, ::oreskin c8,fir_•)'t_r.ol_d w3,t,ar, in ,,_;:,·m:.ich as _he ' .. . ' ' ' did no.t_ di.spla3,· ~1i3 ?:riv<?.,t0 p3,rts -to_ tho ·trb.'.l. court for vorific;:i,tion of \ ·.. ·,. ' . . ··, his coiitentiono, The ::i,~)Gll~,nt conv:::nbntl_y f8-ile..:i. to_.:?.how to th1:; same •.,, • ...._~I.-,.• •• court eith•er t ..at K.,.:;:linj.e_vJ;:i,s cr:rc:..wnoiscd_. ... H.j.s liability.. i's··-t-J;nj~::~.· . . a matte·r of .certai.ntj. even_. witii~lit •111.ri.if b,&",-,l ~.~ovfsion unj_er G.N. -;;~:-·:::~79 of 1965 th:ct the mA,I'. ns,mod by 'l. ~ornyt -~s i;,hj -:l~_t}~or ,of h,0r·p;agn~6y -is held to be sue:·. unl·Jc·:·t.2. t-.:Tb~ld p'~·0ve_ . ,·:;i-J:, .co.'.i·tr;:-.ryJ _ _1-!is \ppea1 .. . . , ' . . ' .- .. · :, ·: thus l~cks me.ri t 8,,"ld it _i·s hereby dismissed ;-,i't~: ·dost-E!.,, :•~Th,is- judgemarit'· is t0 ~-e cortv:e1ed tC> tl·1-, M-:HAIC.CDur~-~ Siiinyanga~ ··. ;- •,\· I 0·. :, CTING JTJDGE~ '· . _I·. V, ;·:·.' ....,. ,. : _;, !· .,.,'\.