19770903 TZHC Mwanza

~:I-II~ JIIC+II co·\j r_r•.l C:~· ·1 :.t~J::2!_:· j~rii1. -;_?....... ~-~ ·."{·!·. _____ ...·. ·.: ·?,JJ. .__ _ ...... Cr-,cc ~~o. 67 of 1S77 ,_,f the 'before '· CIL:':.HG};; ~ Obstruc-!;j_n __:-: c-, rolj_ce Offj_cor oi-:,_ ':',:-·cd in Lnwful .. exoc·ution of -PI'OC''"' 0 ,~·~ • .JJ.. .; ·:1 _ r:·---lrj_r,.,-· rl ; T,r,,,.rf11l ._,_.,t. _ ·- • \ _,,;_)1-J, ..i.J..._ .l<.."-- -'-'- .• , L., • . dis.tress co1:.tr 0 r;r to SOl~tion 243 (d) of the Pen:.-::1 ,Code • '· ·.· . . . ; o. . - ·J -u···. __D,_.__ G ....T:', _1 · 1··,. -Y w n1:..1 .J..'J ·..::" S1SYA ....._ _ , , . ~ 9 .J. ,,! . . . .::··-,,. rn11·-- v ,:,_, 7 ; :\n·t ~,.....• ..L-Ll...'1 .r.-,...\ 1. ..... c·'·s l, . i,;o_l_l 'tl,..... --f- (J_._ -'·-.,J..110 ·n l ("lo Cl!.:iJ _,_ ... · __..,J'.Ou J.ccl.,: •• . --'--~ ...0 n '" rio Cc..,.J Sli. on ~9._J-1.76 t!-;_? c.:)npl . . . i1:i~,:.t 5-n tho c::1.sc 9 j"o.-B7~30··.:?:0.- . Ju,r,~, :..,i._..:. ,,,..,-,11..r...., -\.c.·.,,, -~·.,c.., (•ll· 1) -,,....,("< 'J·~s+r~•,c-1-,-,d ,j.. :: • tl v. ~-c, \!\ ,.,.(-· u,L. t,., •. ::J ,..,.,d o6 8lZ(':.:.:. -·"']llC ;._; •... .J.l . \.A. · tJV.. .J ho:-.clf.'l. o:i c2- ttlo ;·.nd throe ,r,:of'.tS be:lo;::c_ in.g to· cno Ironzcla 00 Iy:u.Ec., 1-.Jy o~::-dor ,,f the :;ulcl::\ Prir-·.-:-·.ry Cou:rt. · /-.:cnec.l :;:•i-d1: [:. d -i<•+r,-~c:,c, Ov-'-'UO T,r···1:~"~.--,-1'.lt \,c,, (T;xh :11) ··.l':'..lo J.1., ·,- (I (.,,,-~l,, L~ , ~cco-J:•1·~;f'J"'' ... l"'d' . . ···---V . 1-:-,r .-1,, •·- 011n ___ v l,..,U.L~ 0 Deus ~.;;-,_chor,1b2.. ·c:T:.2) :.''.nd one '~<:'..ryobc\s r-, :-:ilJti::::~ ri::..n who did :not toDtify r:t tho trj_':.l, left for the hone· Gf -:·110 said. I·.,.onz_olr:. J-yur.1?... ~hoy •did not f'ind hi1-:-t. i'hoy, :b•y·,;-cvcr, found l1is 9 i. ~:. J.rJ:or1zcla is. n:.r1:ir.~r:. ls :'Yr't'.;...~ i.11:~-~ j_n r:, · s.11.f'j:·ilJa. ·.· -- Lookinr;,: 2,ftor. thoi . 1 wc,:J -::ho :,,.ppcll::.nt who, incicl;:nto..Tly ;· :ts__thc sone of Ir,·oi1zl)];c,. l'. C. ,Tu: 1r'c Fho 1n:u; tl.1c;1 in Police Un:ifcn:~ introc}uccd hir;;zclf to tho l.'..]1pcl-l-,nt: n,.'ld ho 2:lso: told hi::.-. 9 i.o. thcJ 2.ppollr'..lTt~s the r,1x;:'J?0Se ol th2ir aission. 'T1he ::-:,ppQll::.nt 0bjoc-;;-ocl to the sciz1.1..:co OI'-. tho .r,ro1..u1d that the 01crnc:c of tho 2.i.1ir:·".lo 9 :r,·:cn~:-cln. hirisolf 1~2..c th0n r1ot ,::,resent. Tvontuc~lly, the c-.ppc:118.nt c.:::rood tci (·. ncl clj_d. drivo tho anir:1nls to his_ f;:-.thcr 's ho;_.:_130 ·whore :', C. th.UT, into:'.:!.dod · to . seize th~r in tho praaancc cf witnoscc □• Howcvor 1 on their a~ri~cQ_ tho c"'.. l)p,::11;--i_,~t suc.1s~.:mly. jU(\?Cd on r. CO ,TUI:lC', ~ throw O hin dm·1n ~-nCL tore .::ns m;i:LOrn -i:;o :nccos. ?oorJlo i:-rnnt :to·. thG aid ..:,of ~?. C. c.1U1JC... Thc•r ovcrIX)i:!Cl"Od the ; ~.L•,1)0llnnt V .L •· who:roupon (.!\iri;"',, so :Lzocl tho c.nil :.21G nncl took theP top:ether with ··tho e:.pj,oll.'.:'.n t to thG ~c1 0licu Stz,tion uhcro the ·1ntter w::..s --thon s1..1..bsoquontly chc.r_r;:cd. ]::r1 hi;-, ·dcfo::.1co, the ;--..ppull;1.nt clcniccl o.,ss:,ultjn[~_::2.C:~' Jur.10, accordin/: to hir. when J?. C. Juj~K~ ro::--,d · out tho distro-ss-___ 0 • wG.rr2..nt -~c h:lJ:.: · ho believed it to bo n --01,x·.ine wr'..rrnnt o.nd th:-.t Jw·:1c. who Wfcs in J?olj_co un:i.:.i.'orn N?.B j_ndood EJGnt to seize tho nnin:_:_J.,s ._ IfowGvcr, for no c.J)pr:.rc:1t rc~,.r:;on, Jun.['.. 2nd his conp2.nion c. ssc,1...1.:i_ tod hj_r:1 bcfoJ:'O Doj_z,:i_r_,:-•· th0 2.njne"ls. 0 •••• /2 2 The ~ppcllnnt c~llod two ~itnoss~s on his side. ~oth of thor1 9 l10-v.rovcr· 1 r-1~·. i(:_ tl:-~t tJ:10~/ f"..T'I~\,rcd at tl1c scc110 ~:.t'tcr· tl1c "pnc,11° J_J.,, Ci.. ;1-J: (.., . . \... ,:1 L~ . . . . .1-., r,]__ 1~ -,<',,-::i ~r l)·"' __,_V<..•--lj , ': "'•··•n ~. -1-ea·-• ,·-11 ,_,..,1..L•.~:Jl., ;;1_.11('"J1 /' ·r,;e 1..,,,., .~ .~ l'r., I.._:;' -:; 1.-1 n 1,._.)9 ,:, 1·. __,-.l. Ol''"'llt C'l'l .._.,. t...1.-t... .. of wk\t t:c::'..nsp=LrecT bc:twoc.m LL~::: pr.~r-ties prior to t: 1·)c•5.:,· :.:-.rrivnl. mhc 1,,,- -·11(•(1 +-·,, i ,-, 7 7 1"' ,.,-; ,..,tr-· ·;-c, . not 8'1)j_'_nriuj_n:·:1v' r,_; J ectecl 0 :,.;,. tl10 Cl 1,,...-.L,...,.!'1. . C 0 '-\_:- .... --~.~f-;)· ":Y .,.,_ .· ·.:·,-:.~ -.l1 1,.),;\__1_ ~:I·;/, .... 0 :,:~:o' [_,_!_.,_· I) ;_' 1·' .: -~ .i.'•---~L\...L ('. .f:JL_ ,::, tc) ···"C'·'·' -,,. 7·'1,, :.; ,... 1r Ve-·~ r .•- ),._) -1..j ·····-'·-•...., . i.J_ cn-1 y· '--'.1.I. 1 ---' be ric~·,nt to T:i.{1-:i..cuJ.c thu iI,telJcc 1:: Qnd noth5.n: '.'_io:r•,). Ti1 his pcti t·~.on o:t' c~_pJJC'.-~J-f the ..-,p1:cllc·.nt db'i;D not r,--j_s<..: r.ny no-;~ lino of d.otc11c~. ..'..,.11. 11(: c1oc:s •i,s +o :i...·1c'..lce 1)roto:::it:1.tio11s :-Jf.. l:Lj_8 innocu11cc. 1,•5_ ';Ji.out 11cJ::·. tin:.' :-·.bDut the hush, tho :..·vj :J.0~1co on rcco::.~c1 10:1.vcs no roon f,-,::.n clonbt th::---:; tho c.'op)Gll;:nt cl:i.r.'.: ·:-:.ss2u.l t :F~:- () C () J LlI''L.~ .• _:n ,2r•" ·i.n: ont tJ' is ::;,iJJ 1 82,l ~:,uf ore, ;-~-5; , tho .lc::.r,~.cd Stc:\tc 1 1; 1 J:..ttornoy, LT. ·,·;,:Tz;riyjJ;:~,. , su".x :Lttod th."t s:L:.co tho c,1:,_j_·::::t·-:-:.ls 1 rerc still in the pom:;ession of tho o.ppoll:,n~t rat tho tine of tho "'l lt 1 he 1 ass cv 1 ,t p;,,....,J_J .. n·'t,- C(''! J_"'c1 ·,·o+ 0 '--"_J:-'-' _l ·.151 "-},c·"nnfol'."' __ ,_.,... .,....,1 :'l'' 7 __ ..,_\,_, /vl. r,r,·ial tu-, _.,_,.__.., u<....J___ ,\. .... h,,·v·,-,"V -J-.1. J..,._, assm.11 tGc1 J:l" ~;. .fu.:1': i:iith :L:.tot:..t to rescue tho s:::c;::c, i. o. tho aniIJ2..ls, lcnrf1,,J_ly t~;;;::c~A~ unc::or clistroEis. "fith raopact, this point j_s well tz.-,L::cm by the J.ry·rnoc:_ State Lttornoy. 8ectj_on 243 (d) of the l'~n; •,l Codo :.,ni:lo:c ·Thi.ch tho c:.pl)oll~_nt ,;2,s chc:-.. rr::ed 0 and subsoquor:.~;lv C:T':,victec1 covers 2, sit1.1.0.tion 1·rhoro cm. 2sccusod .J .._ 11 .... u I"81"SQY> c:i;~P-?i': .1-' L,o _.... ;'., ,- 7'>':,c•: _,_ -..,w .......,.:o-'-c, .J,.,., ·;.. __,_,w ,,-,, n;·,-,....t,,,..,-,,_·t~s V . r•ny -p:OY'':•or, c,.,__ .J _.,_ 1.J..i.. C>J:".C"QPOd c ,_ 1_,.,.) in __., __ L..-... l-.J,_ .. _ ,., •. 12.wful ox0c1.. :~ion < :;_• rrccus,J, c--T in °.:2.kh1.c1: a 1::->.Fft'..l distress,._ wit~ inte;;nt to ::".."esct1-o ;:.:r::\:. :Y1'op.,:c::v lc'_T,,:i:ully t:d:cn 1.,--.,.ndcr such ]2!-'6cobn or distress.,; In tho ~~nsta:nt .-cfl.s,::::, 2.s tho ovide;;ncc st:-:..nchc;, .it1.dood, the aniLlnls were still in tho poc3ession of the ~ppallrnt nt the tiLle cf tho nss~ult. 8 he qu0 □ tion of r.,scuo docs not thcroforo arisCJ. In sho:ct, it 1:r;-:,_s ,,;rro:i::J.J to chz;rc_:c tl10 2-J)I)cll.r-,nt l1.nder sGction 243 ( d) of the :::'0112,l Codo. Hurrcvo1' 1 sinccJ tho ~:.r:rticula:: -s of the offohcc in tho Gh:",:'.r'.·e: ~"-S lr..id ['..S well ';,S the c;yj_donce 2,dduccd rd; the tri;,~"1 2o11 j:,oint to tho fc;ct Jch:\·\; :::·, C. ~Tuma was nssz:ultod i:c-'. the tl-ue oxcc1.'.tion of hj_s d1.,1_ty ~;_ hcJ_d that· tho propor sc;ci~ion of the 1c,~·J under w.hich :"..ppell:::.nt on ·ht t_o he-ave been ch~rped is soc+ion 243(b) of the 2onnl Code. 'T.'ho q_l1.cstion -:,hc--,t nrisos now is whether thi.s orror h~"s any effect on thq coJ:'lFictic,n. I do not hosit8.-~C to· s:-,,,y thr,t it does not hc:vc 2..ny off ect. Jn the f L.'.'st j)l2..co, ::: :-,r very f r:.r froi::. b c j_i'J.( _pe1'°'sur:.(locl tl1:J- t tho 2 lJJ!V llD,r1 t ]:1~.;,s iI1 r~-::.1y T!':1.Y 1 : boon projud:i.cod by tho error n~d socon~ly, tho error iB cbtable under secJsion 346 of' tho Crii,'.innl ~-'rococ1ul"'O Cod.o. ·. . :, Ls rG::cards tho sr:.:ntonco, the lc~:ri'J.cc1 trj_Ql ~.,::ic;istro.te jur~tif j_s,bly took the o..ss:::,ul t as a serious ns, ttor bccrmse ? , C, tTur1c, wt·~s exccutinc; ~1 lc1:wful wnrr::~nt iosuecl by n, court of 12,w. ;; and the 2,:;::'~)cllc::nt TJC.s fully nwni'o of thiso Irl tl1c CGS8 of ;~I1~JJ)I <:::r:.<_;JI VS F\.c ci~j:c:5.::-LC~l L.iJl)O[~]_ l.Jo.69. _,, c,..... _ .... i, .... v.____ v _ .._) .· 7t. -Fo Of. 10.74 (-i;,-,rn c-c• ~.)';-,1"-::-r1-·n°.c··'Lc'+r::,::--;:::-;;-c w ~--·'r'y .. l lr1·10T,.rl0d:~,,~o 1u1r0.p· orntr.:,d) ~ ~ J...) t.1 c_.,.._ __ .Ll,,. l ,_, ..... J . ;- :!Jiron, J. , obsorvor.l "th~,, t the 2. sscsr:5rle:n~~ of punishr1e:nt ~ thn, t is scm.tonco, iu ,, t the cL c;crctj_on of tho co:cvictinG court, nnd an 2.,ppoll[·, to co11Tt 1rl.ll not interfere vd:th the oxorciso. of such dj_scr. ~~ion 1;,nJ_. so the co1.:rt ::1j_sdiroctod itself either on thG prj_ ncipl0s to be ::::,}i'J)liccl; or on tho fncts, or -[;he~ t the sontonco is so n2.::.df,.)stly oxaes.Jivo or in°,diqunto th2, t j_t calls fer intcrfcn.~cmcc. ;; ..... /3 3 ·:.:.:__:j_u; I 1c:~ ·::.x-:,;j _pc::.. ·c:.~ l:,1J.,; 9 .,. .. .,,,.,, , .. ,. l--'LJ-!.... ,,, ..__ • • caec ·:♦.]_1(:; f2' :·1 ·- 7 7 ::J1-~~ C, )~1(; ~ a. - ~ cl ··\;~1c..-c . !_i~-.-::.~: ' j t:..~·; ~~ 5. C .:J ':.: j_ . \~.-~- Otl --;j i.:].J) ._ ~ J_ i ..: J. ,__: ~J. '.~. r: ? :_ j_ C :~ 1.. l :) J~· \::-·::.2~~-<c· irJ.:\, .-,:1.,_c· 1 r·:..~--: c1 -~.;- :.L --~;.1~ 1 7 ~; /~;-";_ _::.. l'..<:i. ~/:;!J -~; j,.: .. -·.loc:~c ')_·;_~L:i.- __ c·Li:x~~·- .;.:. :L:·:i 0 J?i.:_.1.i :;_;_1_ -·'J.C '·' ,t.'·1-,,·,.· •. .1.,., -GJ}.0L7-( ~.:.1 ,;;; :J_l c..2.~f:~:1c.-:C:L -,7 ·:,:r ·•..._ ,•·-l, is Dc:.L:L\-' ~--;1-· _.c~ ~L2.1 D_p~.-J.1 c: CJu.1·•-tj C- ·l; !"~;:77..J.1~,C. 1.. 1S77. _/· / . \ : YlAitlA II.~~ • ~0 ; S J~·;;.~:LA 3RD _f3EP·.i. ~,~~~:\·::_.J:~~al, :LCJ77. 1 SGDGE ----- ,.