19891006 TZHC Mwanza 1
The appellant was found in possession of recently stolen property, identified by the complainant, and failed to provide a credible explanation. The conviction and sentence were justified based on the evidence and applicable legal principles.
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- 19891006 TZHC Mwanza 1
- Parties
- Appellant: Appellant (unnamed Tanzanian); Respondent: Republic of Burundi
- Court
- TZHC
- Jurisdiction
- Tanzania
- Judgment Date
- 6 October 1989
- Procedural Posture
- Criminal Appeal / Judgment on Appeal
- Outcome
- appeal dismissed
- Legal Topics
- Housebreaking, Theft, Jurisdiction, Sentencing
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Appellant (unnamed Tanzanian)
Appellant
Republic of Burundi
Respondent
Procedural Posture
Criminal Appeal / Judgment on Appeal
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the appellant unlawfully broke into a dwelling and committed theft
- 2 Whether the conviction was supported by evidence
- 3 Whether the sentence imposed was appropriate
Ratio Decidendi
The appellant was found in possession of recently stolen property, identified by the complainant, and failed to provide a credible explanation. The conviction and sentence were justified based on the evidence and applicable legal principles.
Court Disposition
appeal dismissed
Orders
- conviction and sentence affirmed
- appeal dismissed in entirety
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
1 paragraphs
I 'T J.1 _ L?..........._,_. i~ILF::fl. District Varsua JU'J.GMENT Court of' J.Tg2.r:-. :)i:3-t:.:-ict at Fgara. years imy::-iso::--~-:e.::1.t on t.':rn count o-f' :1.01..'.Ge ':-ree?::i!:g ;_:-_:~::. 12 mont;,.s in::)l... :i.sor:.:::19nt :'.:or t 1:1e count of c ·::;e2.ling. TJ:::.e y2,rtict.~l2.rs o:f t·!e charge all egec~ t~-:,_2. t o:-: t>.0 16th of .Fe:::r·1.-s:.ry 1989,2.t about 10 a.m at Chibali vil:!.2.ge in I~uyinga Region in t:-:,_e :::ept.6lic of ::3ur:U:1.di, t,·:te O.:):;:>ellant ~-r:::i.o is a Tanzanian did brea~ into t½e dweling ~o~~~ of·o~e 3e~ishalu· s/ o ~rrr.:1a'.'.1uel a!"d cor::r:d tted a:1 of'f'e:1ce t~c.e::.... ei::.. Anc.. t>.a t is, f:; stole :fro::1 tb.e:-ei:n an assortment.of' ite:::;s t-f:::i.c:_-:,_ ir2eluded a sewing ~~c~i~e ~Gad, a radio cassette,·bicycle, clot~es of the cz.oe are t:::i.2.t on the 16th of Fe;:-ruary 1?S9s i:n t:::e · . .:.i moJ?IU.ng, '"' e 1:>1· s ·..-~.a,.-:-.u · ~ . 1s ;::,~/ o --"'11':!12.nue (P:J1) , . , · .....,._,,-7 --~- s __ ____ •..,; _ "•····- ly w-ent ·'."<":-·-i out f'or o:::.amha ~-,ork. :Se:fore t'::.ey 1 ?f't 9 t~::.ey s--eou:.:.~e1y locked their houc.e. At a;Jout 4 pm P:•!1 ti1.e returned · ~... o,.'e ··- ·•• le2.. ..n.:1.g ~::.:ls f'amily behind still itorking on • s;_"_c::::.~"'.Jci. a:J.'.:~ ~f-:.e:.-:-. ~--e reached his houc:e, ::-Y.e f'o:xn.d t::.~.a t it. :1ad been bro::en i::·.to 2.~d ~:.7.s · property as spec:ii'j_e:i in t½e c•~arge s::.ee-t ~.:.ad ~)ee-c::. otolen. He hap:?ened. th@ir '20-□e loo:'::L:'lg f'or a bicycle to bor:.... 0~1 ~G I.:.i a ~-r:::.a out h.ave - been t?.:.e ~:)9:;:-oso:.: ~-rho broke into thoi.r :.,.ou:::e. was in::'or;:1ed by so:r.c ?eople th.at t 1:c.ey h2..d ocen. tJ:::.e c.:_::?ell?,nt · w:l t~-:,_ !J.is bicycle 2.:1d t~:ey had though.t 7.:0 ~-:.o.c.. le::1-t i t it:o·· hi,.m .. da,y' t-..,~ ,...c.. J_ l, • ,.... )...., ' by 'I'a.::1.za::-:-.ia:c 11 stE1gu su;:~gu" on suopie:ion. t>:;.t t·,.0 _::;oo::-:.c :.1.e was carrying· ,-t0re stolen l)robotaf. 'PW1 uiis l?_.·/;cn. . °t".~:e-r_1: to · Ruler..ge Police Stat:io:.1. where 1.1G saw 2.::::". i :-~e-:t::L':'ie·c.· ::;0::-10 of . . , t½.e b:icycle,,. ·tl:..e se~•rin.g machines;. hea? 0tc, The evido:_:ce of' ~-J1. as to _tJ~e arrest o,: _,__v.·.:G · by 'I'2.:1.zm:..iqi- 11 Sur..:;L'!. .Su:c.gu" was amply s~tp:;io::-t0d by P.'"Jl.'.. - Joseph . . . . ~~ . J~t;litlw-Gi;:2do - . the . .Chai·r.m2.n . .· or Co!:.)':13.nder . .. of' t::o 11 ..:it.:.:-:,_r;u Su."1.gu" '• . of' hi$ E',rea. . :It ?~.n )!s:,·:~ yist~~~e t 11.a t o:c.. t:.~.~. 1.·5·tl1 o'-t ):i'·eibruary 1 19$9· ctt. 9. Pm 720 c.::11. a g'z:-~up of': 11 Sungu S"L1ngt.1 11 i:-.rerc o~J. ::_:>c::.t'rol >'Jatong t:?.e Fg2s,_"a - :::.ule 1:1ge !toadt t'.ley sc.-r.-r t>.e· a·-·.-:::,:..12.rit '' -pus~~~_,.1g c. bic~rble ·f:'1.c~-:-: !-;i::l.o. :c:._ bi c b,mc~l~ ·o~ "its >:.c)-: c!tirrie~• ""1hey ,:-:to .......-~.':•~r-1 ~ 'J _ -· -f--.i..e.,,.,r·or'T'~-.,',-r-r,d' - = :-:,,-.·-.-.c~ _,___ " .,_ ..... _s-- v-- : t 1.•.i -e a~n~1i"'.:'l;l.u· _._.,_.,-,-.~---~--- v !'='\<"" ___ .., .., ........ - .Jro: ·.'t",T"'.'-.\~~e·"' 11"' .. ._, was go~-~"lg 2.::d. :1.e re:?liec. t 1--ia t be· ~-ms g·ci:::·g :to :::.u.1e:-:ge to one ... ,.ag/;ti::.nt ~::.i1:1. 'I';_:.Gy. t:1.?r13:fore. ord0red ~.:.~.:·.~ t~ o>otr -;;>.G::~ :-r:~2.t was ·, in r.i s 1 ug,;s,ge/?:n.1~;1·: .: ·.. ~·t r.-r~~ ·: ~~:j4·(s evice::::.ce t·.:2. t 2.::;:,·:--2'ila:it pul}Gc. o:.1t o:::G ~~2.±r of trpusers ~ one 11 ~:i t:c:::7-.g.e·"· c.::c: o:ee 1 ?..rge ,···•I.:.:: t~G .2owevsr t o ld t o scow . .i·n t~~.0 100 to . .. . .r. plec.c.ed, 1-ri t:-::. t!:.G'.;1 e..~.10 ~J't~red .t~'.\0:il a r2,,c:i0 C'.:'.050-tte ~:or his arre-stad into claimed . . .·.. 0 t•:1.a t t'::-e s2.:::c0 ~:2.c: '::Ga:: s6ld · to hi111 by :?-T1. ~-::2.ve r::o c:o:.;:i::t i:."1 my ::nir.id tl~at t>e 0;ric1c,::-.cc 2,c~c:·_-:_ced I estnb 1 :i_sheo.· .clee.rly r.. :..'i•· · ~ · ·. · -~7-::_o. t · the aDyGllant ~J::."'o 1rn i::.to ?~-!1 1 o house 2:::,c'. ::;tole· t~::-..3 c.cnort~1ent .of' artio1Gs S::>el t out i:~ th0 ch.argo. ~~ . . . .. . . t . . . . .!..r:o 1t0::.Jo ·t ..:2.t, ~';rcre :fo.u.nd 1.n .:-:-.:-1_0 -:>o_cs~a0~011. ~-.rer0 ... - . • • I •. .'·: convincingly ·. · ·· · · ·. .· eleaTly 2x.c'. :::y 1de·1ti:fi2cf by :'?~-!1 to ::-0 :-:,e.rt of :::.is .. J· p~operty otolan. As matte~ o~ f2ct the a~ry3llant hi~Gelf ~ie ~ot c~2llonge ::.:r-r1 a claim a:?pell.a::1.t I s cl::.i.'i~:1 '.TS.o rightly reject0c.• ,. to was tho eaaiec t 2.:'.!·c! mos·t convia.cing story to toll to t:::ese people, :I21st02.d :.~.e tried with out sue cc co .of co,1,:;:•so to :Jri be , . ' ·11m go. " to -do t;O i:? t:-::.0 i.~:;e'.:::D '~:ad bce:1 1.2..wf'ully o:.:--~.;..:.-:::oc.. ;-:,_::::: ·.-:-o J_::lter ;.a··· petition o~ a~7e~l~ ✓...L ~ U 11 y --.: -~ ~ -=--···- .:..~'·.G.-.·...:.--t::, e~'.TJ.C,GTIC0 · ' 0.17. .L-,~ . v .. _e . W·..-,.O~--, "· ,.., ver 8-.~ t<,;: :.:.~. -~,-, ... t·t,,, · c:::trei. CO.-:.;.! ' .i..•.:. u ..,G Oll recorv. . ,.1 ·~--.~ ,·..... C ·•··"' .:.._,.?·'-'--·an '-' pe t..:t• r . T '-~• .•. lO_1., . __ _-_, ,.•"'.J.. -~ .. :,·.·iG ·..:.O '":Oc.,-~ v J..Il ' my -· __ ,Q t··-+-t·- ... m-;",..,• ....c:. V e :.._.._~ __ ----✓-~ ... 1 1 an. t 1 <.:,n gu _, _ _ _ _ ··i1·t··,:.._,....· :Tc,0 e ,-,-'-~'~1"~'-,·..:\·-- ... .... 1.,,-••. .:-..!...:, ... 01.... ,.)'.:;_yOl1.d · doubt · reaso:'-2.'ble ./ ! .. :1~: t·-::.e ao:J.tence impono'i ··r?..c i.,::. -~~-'-e· :;i:!'C~':-.,::;-tac1ccs ~ offence ~~d t~o val~e of the ~ropcrty 0xcee~od s~a. 5000. .. . •' . Thoug:-:-. t~:e oi~:tG:~co •,ms com::-ii tte·d · i:.: :'T;'l'.":..:::c~i ::;·.:::: ::::~:.1ce the c:.:_)peJ.12.,:lt iq _2. Tn~zania natioan1/::it:..z,E1, .t'.~.s "Jiot~ict vour t . o:i:~ · i.. -:.00..:-..,c. c. .vi . ..:.!~~-ra f"' ·- 1 ' :tc~..,~0:1 2.. :::.d cc:~.~ ..:'-'J ,~-~:~ce t o 'ct·:•._. r:.!3. d ' Jt.1:r1s try t:::i.e a.~-~~;<:..lan.t f'or ·the off':en·c·b :-::e '::-.c.c2 co:::,~i.t-:;ed. .:L:: t~.e ~epublic Code. t:.?.0ro:for0 faj_ ls ' . ,J.. 1~ :.G • . . .:.., d_i_mnicneu. e:::::tirety. 6/10/89 on.._this ·-Sth c'.:::-..y ' ... ,- t("·TAII3A .....