19931208 TZHC Dar es Salaam

IlJ TD :s::, Gt: OCT.LT CF T.:Ji::-3..J;L_ JUDGE::11:T - - · - •..••• .. ••r••- T;ie o:.:t:iolJ.. ·.l1t JlJ'C.".3 T....I..10 1r~ s o:...~'2G~c.1- wit:.:. encl co::viotoa. of the Off enco oi ,~;teclil1G 0/s 265 of -;;1-.c ?c;.1,2J. Cocte. TiJ.o t:.•ir,1 oourt prooeeded t,.;.1c~c~ t:10 IJl'Oit:i.sio:.'lS of s. 226 of t!:i.c Cri;;.1incl P:..•ooedv.ro . Let 1985 o.fto:.' ~1 cJ.l0c;0d f 0-iluro 1)? t)..1.0 c~p0ll,J1t to ::-:_)~)oC.:? in oourt M o::.:-de:.•cd. Follow-inc the col1V:i.ct:i.011 :.10 uc..s s0:1to;.1occl iio a dischm-[;o ooi'lCl:\tioncl 1..1.pon his no;.1 - co:lllittcl of otLo::, o:Zi'c:.1oes for a po:::.•:'.ocl oi' o;.10 year. ~10 ti•icJ. Ooi.L,t fu::..•t::.cr 1:1r.cLo r.:.1 o:...<l.er for l'esto:::di:'.on .rit!1 iwr1edide effect of t:10 Go ii-on s::oots, the subject of t: .0 s:-:j_c1 stco.lin[;, to t:,.e ooi.!pl,,i.nc'llt one ~Jb~ cxtl'oo Swai., Dist-,t:'.r.;1'~.ca. t:ie r,p:pellr.11t is ~.,::.10din:; .c.=;dnst t: .c oo:rviotion Md tl1e o~clo::.:: :?o~? il.:E.edic,te '.i:'esto:r: .tio:.1 of t:,:.c i:;_,on s::,cots to tao oomplninr.at. J.C• I do not fL'ld. it nocossr.1' _· to nc~-:.•:.:to i:..1 cletcJ.l t:C.c: f1.1J.l f,~cts lend.in[; to t: .o C:;;):}ellcnt rs ~;~:?est, c::.i ...:?_,o c·.110.. ov:::mtu:J. oo:1.Viotion. It I me,;r s._-,rn,r.1..:.::1i,~0 thou.gl1, tho fc.ds ~.eiof'ly c;o a8 f ollo·:mi- Tb.rt the co~J)lc..iiu.---.nt hes 8.. plot no. 12';7 Dlock G situ:·to

c,t T. lie.ta a:rea, D2J.:- es 3cl.t'.r...:-:i. On 10.5.90 l:.o ontl'"~'.Stccl ltls oont:-~.cto~ ,rith iron sheoto fo~ j_)tU--posos of fm."T:'il1u t>o o.::-~;ie to t:).e plot ~1 question. T:.:.o u_,on s;.ieets never l'or.o:1cd t:10 intendoc". dost:t..1:..·.tion, • Re xepo~?tod t:.·.o :..i::-,tter 1r:i.t2 tho ~)olioo c.:i.lc'I. t\ so:x,:-ol: lT::::i mot:ntod. · 1..fter vicit:..:1c.; one or tuo plr-cos i;.1 sec:-.::o:.-. of t!10 st;;..ic, t>.c soc.rah pa...---ty eventi.1.C.J.l~r e:i.dect up d r.lr..11:,;cso. Ono 3nidi is sc:ic'!.. to ;}.o,Ve led tllc police (DC :.00di r..nd ◊J?l• illicJ;j) to 1lr1.J.1:.;osc c;'i; :.: . 08:dcwi house. .:..t t::.o :;.ouso t:1ey i:1ct c. c,ctc-,i:.1 :-.'O:L'son 1r:.10 tole. t>.0:.1 tlle:;:-e uore iron o:.J.cotn ~~oucht therein l;n.t t:.'.d t:10 s:-ne >.-:.<l. si:.100 ~;0on shifted to 2, 11oic.,~J.~Jou.ri.i.1G · 1iou.so w:.:~•c t~·-:::'.!:.:o is t:, sl:.op o~r:.1.cd 1;:~ one Da,vid Ki,.1::--;i:'o, · ... ,/2- - 2 Tb.e said Dr-,vid. ICiL1u!'o is scid 1:0 h:-,vo told then thd t:::.c iz,o;o. sheets t110:::0i11 ;;elonged to one J\-,:i.:ro - t:.,.o a:ppellc;.,t. I.i.1 t:.,.e arsenoe of t:~.o 2~_12_,ellc.nt the bm,1.Sc wr-.z s·02:,:-ol;.ed 2Xlcl Cio i:;_,on s:.:.eets . allegedly lJelon:;inc to the cor·:;,lc.i11r11t kl;:011 the1.~efror.1. T.'.·.o;;, ~ook the s,:.uc to Bugu,rv.ni Pol.'.ce Stc.tion uli01.•e tl:e cm~)J.r.:J.:.1 ..'.i.Tt is said to ~c.w icl~1tif

ied t~e s ?,De rn lJ.is ].->:i.'O}?ert:;o It is :{;1 evidenoe furtb.ax tad; t:10 awell2.l'lt wD m'Testec.l r.t :Ju(,U,j_•uni Polioo Sto,tion where he hc,d cone to j:'eport tll~;t the 60 h•on sheets td.:011 fro:Jl Kima.ro 's plc.ce a.re his ·P:iX>l)erlye Go:L11c, tl. :ough the tric:w. oou::.."'ii ;;:ecoJ:d it is o,pp;:-zc:;.-i.t t::,d there a.re a numi)o:o: of f ea.tuxes showinG th::,,t the a1:>pollc.nt w::-..s not c,'i-..re'h a. f ru.r tr5.oJ.. On the first plc.oe it is Ol3:;:_• tl1at tho o:i.so W8.S initiaJ.ly hero:~ iW one t1GGistr2,t0 (Hiss Th.'1dr.y-BM) wl10 1t:·.o e-;rentually transferred oi'to1· :recording the evidence of three p:ro:::emition witnesses. tn1en tcld.nc CNo~, the suoceed:i.l'.!G l-L:.[;ist:.:-de does not :-i~110,2 to have applied tho 1~07isions of s. 214 ( 1) F'.llc'L' (2)(a) of t:10 Cbi;-1i.noJ. Pl'ooedJ.i..1.~e .'.:.ot 19G5 whioh :r'ead.s M follor;rJ:- t. 11 2140( 1) :niere 2.:ny' ],h3ist~:2,to, cft0r h1;1,vil1r.J l,.e,·.::d. o.na. reoor:d(;)d the 1-1hole on coy pr..rt of t:i.10 av:i.dence in D.tlY tricl o~ conduct0c1~ in whole o:..· l)~-ti any oomraittal 1):rooocdi1-i.cs i:3 fo;:: c.;.1~: :...·o:--.son u.nD.ble to complete t:~.c- tz-ia.l 01· t:.~c ooJI:ri.t:-:Q procoedinc;s or: JJ,c, is t'.11~1:,le to oon1}letc t:1a trfr,l or oomu:tttc-J. p::.•ococdi11..:;s uj.t>:L1 e, rensonr.1Jle tir.10, c.not:.\O:i? w::cist:-r,to 17::ao :ici:i , end who ezej.~oisos

jw:-isdictio1:i- m.:~,- k2:e over: and oont:tnue or: t::;.0 t:;:-in.1 OOillilittcJ. 1,;:oooodings as t:ie cc.se. nay 1)o ma tho r.1...-,,,:.;ist:;:•c~-bo so taking over may act on th0 cVidenoe o~ 1)20cocclil1r; :reco:i:-ded 1Jy his predecosso:i: ~1cl, ;~i::,;y- in t;J.o 02.sio ot a trial re-summon tho 1ritnosscp 1:>.ncl :,:,eeom:.10nco the trial er th0 coramittr.,J. l)~Oooodin[;s ol' ot';:o;:'iriae subject to subsection (2). (2) ".J.1erever t.b.e J?rovlsi011 of sul,seotion (J.) a:.:_:,plies ( a) i11 a.ny t:..•ie.l t;:.c 2.CCttscd Lla3r, u:.\011 t:2.0 suoh ot1:i.e:r ~istj;'c,to oo:.traonces b.j.s 1,z-oaoed~fl'S 1 deiik""1J.1d tll~),t t~.,.0 1rit110sscs on c..11~· of t:.iem be re-sm;i~GC! 4UL1 ;;.~G--JiGo..i.---d and S:: .c..ll ~;o Wormed of SU:oh richt i):7 t;1e othel" lI..\~__,-b.:ox:to 1,.lle.n he ~il0J.1oes l'd.s IlJ:'oc00d.i11t.,r.&§. 11 • 3 ii.11d. unde:-...· S,21.:t (2)(b) of th 1 scl:10 ..'..ot t~w ITie;]l Cotu:-t r.ic.;;· "bot a.side c111y cond.ction }.K:DG...,"'- 0,1 evide1100 not u~.i.olly I'COOJ:-ded by the L. ,gist20.t0 :)cf ore tl10 con0..otion .:recs i1c..d., if it is of ;he opinio~1 thd tao 2..cc-.'lJJod ?.1.2;9 °lJoen m2,te1•iaJ.l~ _pz-cjudiood tho:re~)Y r.J1d L1ci.:;· o:,.'doj_• c-. new In tl1e inst~:.nt oc.se it is c·: J['J:' tl:o;ii t: ..0 Lii.to':·.~::idi11f.; N..·-,cist:::-r,to could have ad.cl:i:-oss0J. :.:.o...:- 1:1lnd -~o i-;.1.0 alJov-0 o:.;:i;ocl

lXi.'ovision on 11.c.92 before she oven ~Jecnn roco1·, 11.nt:; tho eviclenco of P::4. Secondly, I r,.=i"-'oe vri th the n..1'.)mission r:1..:.de by Hr? Lipild t:_:;.r,t . followinc t>.o t::.•c'.J1sfer of l\iss Kh::tday ~:-::: then tl10re foJ.lo,rca. c. nur.:ibor of r..cljoti.:."lwients whic!J. raust h2:v·0 oonfusecl the c\;_):,)ellc..iit t For 0:im.raplo on ~--12690 in the :prcsonco of thJ 2.J?pelln.nt t:.o oc..se 1ras set fox mention on 2.1091<> The roooz-cl tl1011 is silo.:at M to ·w'hat hc1i:r2011cd 011 this de.to ( 2~ 1 ,,91). T)e 02,130 houove:i.· o::;.18 UJ.) uea,in on 4s 1. 91 1i10n it liU8 Sv ~ .L'.f..' hcz..:1c o;.1 4. 2., 91 when it iTc.'3 O.C,'D.in adjourned f o~ hoc.:r-inc 011 3.. 3.

91. Ilut t>.c record is t..c;·ci:1 silent as to whnt llci1J?oned on this dc:.te ( 3. 3. 91), Ins tor.cl. ti~c o:.:.::rn C[uue I ~ for mention on 403 .. 91 w:J.cm it 1-rc.s Got for heo.rin.:-; 011 11.3.91. It is sioutior..i.1t to note h01~0 th:.--.t 0:x:Q®t ,f07.' 4.1 e 91 ~1c.l I;-. 2. 91 the app0J.I:.'-"-1t u-.s 1.·acoroe'd to h:::vo ~:;cc;.1 1):;:,ccc11t on t:::.oco ot::.or• do.ys 1 1-r:•~io:\ b r~1 indicdion th..,t :10 wcJJ trj-:U'lG to follo,r 1-r::..::.t was hn.l)J.)G1Ull3 in oou..:;:-t. Indeed ev011 011 stfJsec:uont cl.doc t~ .c magistl"r.to cvc:1 conceded thr.t ins].)itC of t:.-:,.c freg_ucnt '---.djm.'.:.'ni-~ts the a.ppellr..:.1t 1ro-..:ld still OOiJC to cotti:-t to 1010w the 1,osit:'.0~1 of his • oru:ie. T'.L1.o rnc-.(}.st:i."'2.te adr.1ittcd so on 27 .1 .92 uhen she a2,elo e.11 order thus "Ls t~:.e aoct1Sed h,:.s 1)een cotlill.':;" to oot\-::-t :,:,ecuJ. ...-.:i:-1;;=- e-.ro:1 after the judl,"'raent of sot Mide the orclej_.. :fm.' j ..i.d(;.:1ent,. n I IIowever tho 110,.-r::t or unf ortunD.te pr..i.'t of the oonfusin(: ck;bc of a.:f'fa.i:rS happened 011 16.fi,.• 93• On this date t;.::.c C.:i.Jl)ellv.nt uas l)Z-Csc:at 2.nd made a submission to tl1e effect thv,t his advocri,te hnd t:r2.vollcd. to Ubeya. The CO'l..1:.~t houevo:r D..::.Jpem:-cd to disboliev-0 M rn when tac ILt;ist.'de said and reco1-clcc.l in t:.10 proceodlllGs s owet}1i11.:; to the off cot t:::.d

t:1ct inforrar:tion 001.D.d ju.,st not be true ~s ~:.~c J.o.nd seen t: . c .--.dvoo::t~ . that mo1....1ilt, ..:J.011::,· the I'.i.d-:·. Cou.:::-t 00:;:-1,ic~o:;~s.. Thon ti-.0 Ik-c:iot:.:-de went on to i·.d;:;0 t'.:lc follo1ri11c; o:rdeJ~Z- 11 3ocond].y a,s t~ .ir:: er.so is 11.1 old one nna. it hr,s 1)oCn .:-,<ljoui··necl fo~~ sovo:..'rJ. t:J_;:ios 1:>00~'..t1.Se of the 2.bsenco of tl~o c.cct1Sed 0,cl:voc:_.t3s in i:lOllY oocc.nsions n.nd sooetit1cs n~:-sclf uecc,usi, 0 of fJOT.lo ot:.1.er cl:.·,:tiGo I am nssie,nccl in t:1.c :·~:i.cJ.-:.. Cot'.It 2110. ;.C ..:c t::..o a.ocused. ! s n·.,_•.:-, j;' J· er fo..,...,_ .--.P. ·,o·•;.. ,., 0 C..."\.A.v . 1.. ... ~ • • --...,_ .. .,. . ,··,not i'" "lloTrod ...,_,,_.. ,Jv 4,,.., • t 4 I t:::.1.i.s adjOUJ.--n fo-:.: 301:ic fem :Jinutes to cJ.lo::- t::.c c.cetWed to t:..•2,oe his e..a.vocr te ct t~.:,c Zic,:.1 Gou.rt~ tt J,a.ter d 1. 00 DtID4 thc.t sni:10 le.:- it 0-1)1)02.:i.'3 t~1e c..:ppoll:'..}:lt :,.e,d not managed to :::-eJoi--t be.ck £l,t th(, Co1.1.-;:-t uit>. M.s c..dvocc,tc c..11c1 so -&:le Oow.--t l)rooeodo·,1_ to L.Kuco c.i."l o: 'Cle~ fo~ c10live:ry of juo.;::,::.io::1t &.1 1O. 5, 93• :·:'bile holrever t::.o juc1.Gi11<mt w<lS not d0liv0:·ecl on 18.. 5. ~ 3 c.B oci•lier set, it is olo['.j.' t;.1c,t there m·o 0110 o:.· two a.nomcJ.ies i:.1 t:.:.0 o:--del' 0 &f 16.4.93. T>.o l:Io,eistr"~tc ::it:rita cler.:/'.~p t:1d t::e

blc..-:.10 fo:- the severru. cljO-l.\:.'lt-1G..1t uc.s j_)2.:;:-tly on :1or otrn fc.ilti.:..•e r..ncl t:·.d of t:ie ·edvocr.teo Ii' t~o mc.cisti•r.to wr.s r.lco. to i)lr,:ie tli~n u>.:· s:'..:.~:ld the o.p)?e.1J..ant a:..a-..::J.to:i:- all the I'CS~onsi~;ilit:"1 .;,not;;.er c.1.1oucl~· is the fa.ct whe-'1. t.c or.so u2,s c,djot1.J.."'l'led fo~.• soz.10 f m·r m:i111..1tc:::; 110 s:;_,ooifio time wns aosi;:;1ocl on set f Ol' the c.J1:;_icll[·.:nt to .rej_:)oz-t ~)t:o1.:: c.-:.,01.1.t 'the whereabouts of !1is citvo cct 0. In ·00l1olu.sion, wl1e11 cll t::..'1..0 n~Jov-0 f 0r.tl"(L•e~ Ll'e t:-J.;:0~1 toc;other it beooBos alee.:..· t:1,,t tno ~JJ?ellc.nt m:-..c t,.."1t,,hly t:c-ec.tod :):- t:.::.e trial 001.r-:'ii. ~1 t:10 justic0 of this o~.so r.. ncu tj_'.'iru. ~ro·~D.o. ~)otta:r serve the 11\L1_)0,'1Ct :~coOJ:"dinGlY the tJ:ic.J.· oou:,:at. :fY.i:'00~1:;r~ t'..ilcl oonviction c..:-o (Jll.?.S!lod Slld ocmtonco set Mido. ..:.J.so ·t:.~o o.-:c1..<l'.i.' for xGStox-c,tio.1 o£ t:.io ~'1 sheet& to t:le,. .QlliJ?l~,in:.nt 1r.i.t:.·. ~.incdic.te affect io sot wSj_de, ::. t~ic:il de novo 1)of 0'.::'0 a .diffe:.:-0:.11.. l:U'.c;-'.....etJ:o.te is orocrccl '-000.·~l'lGlY• JJ1 ~~ io ·c,void ~'ll'l~sw•:· lJC".otG; If tiIJe it is ,Q.i.:.,~~ <t~t the ti•it'J. s:.:-.ot1.lc1. ~-0 i..."tlti1:.tod :·a aoon cs ).)<)Ssible. i:uwi.nc m.,--,ci.o t:1.0 c.1~ c.eoisiori./0~0~: I do not f ina. it 11oogo38..7Y to dec.J. uit::. a.-i ~1Sider tb.~ often i8s1.:0 ;;.•r..ised ~:p ~·.;:1.Gel.4e• 1i'hetll~ ~i~ not iJI:.e .6o L.---on c ~ lfe.:i.--O ide:u;ifiod to ~Jc. ·t:~ 11~perty rJ-x ~ ~)l;.i::~",,,.'rb, J'v1DGZ c.12.~ ~i~ed Mr. Ln.and.:!.-~ ~- ~11lj.e rit-. ~iki: :Cl. ~.:i.e ~Di)e J.w.1t. . J. ::, .1:IBOF:lr~l

JUDGD