19701218 TZHC Mwanza

SS9U.Tb% et.q. JO Vttqipe.iO 914q. UO JVOJTU9 posq SM UOTSTQO TH e0ue3Jo e ' jo Tr2 pesitooc ei punoj PUC uotnoesod eq. jo JnOAej UT uoiqsonb eqq. peptoep eso eouejep et Se ITM Se uotnoeso.xd et.. piet 2upt4 ioj iqtew etj o; jouotqsenb v s uutcTduioo Olql. I.Tness e qou ptp xo 'ptp pos -nooe eqq. .xetqet •uotqnoosod otq. Aq pee1 a j. up.uivTdwoo etq. P DI.Tne sse pestioo eq eqqaqzt IwTiq exojeq eoueprAe ot. uo 'optoep o. sw.t es -tew .U 8PTSDa PBUa U OI etq 9JOM OSO U SEIM 9tt UOtOtAUOO SUt 1odd ei.q Ut q.Tiew ou eq U90 exe14 uottsod et. 9UT@q sp. ;tt. pps pu uo uoit OH pesnooE ei jo JflA?J UT 9M tjOTqM (1Md) UUJ1OH eqsuoo CottOd Jo AUOWtS4 O1fl. pe T oeCoj pue 99SSOUtM OJOM (Md) STS cI pU (M°d) UUtt[dWOO Ot UOtStV[OUOO Ot OT OUJO pU 99UUTM o. SO .xtioueowep o. 9 UTAa09qO Jo tutizoddooq. p ecist2w •Zfl. qtqq ponk, ze pouxoooqj uotqoiuoo e. toddti o. oouepte $ E31dUJ S2M OJOT.. qeT41. uotutdo eiqq. jo 9CM p uuTq JOTo Ctfl. uo CWC J UOT0tAUOO Ot. qsunb o. q.inoo e11edde ue xOJ purloJ u9tOtJJtiS s um ST71. qCi puo pesrtooC oq. JO qotfl. O. jJOS OT.fl. 30 tTOtSJOt UO14TIOOSOJd e. UTJOJOJd Ut P OJ.TD ocqs -cw et. eoueJop et. o. 2UTPJOOOV •eo 0Jt1OAC UT OOUOPTAO OAC2 OtM ssOttM o Jo uowt.seq etj peqd0000 o &eouepTAe uottioesojd UT UOTOTpCJtI00 9CM exe CT.fl. .uewepnC stt ut peou ezstw ot. TP11 OTMU pon2.IC ueijeddc etq. Jo; CqoCuTtti OOUC!UOS pue UOTOTAUOO Ot. J.SuTe 2 e qJnQO stt. o. pO1OddCoU SCt4 OH ueWuoSTJdUJT sUuow a-i: o. peoueies PUC OOUOJJO Otfl JO 1 tTt PU n OJ SCM °H •OPOO ICUOd e. jo £i7 e s/o sefl.tip STIJ jo rjorioexe tip eq. Ui xeot;;o eot1od U 2UT !~ JMSSSejo eoue;;o ot t4 iVtToC OJOM (pettiboC SCM otM) tuCwtit.1J cxwv ouo pu uw1eddC ei lL • c • v SC!.CzuW ILMEDGfif ° 9M9'] O JO I 1°A 91 O OPOD ICUOd Jo v s/o 99.XO AOf JO UOTSSeSSOd IDJMCIUfl VWDOD pu A1 edeo OPOD ICUe 0 1 ~O tfl JO c9 UC ( 69 2uiioe :unoo t :jvr-j LM'ECMOdS&U a OI'IafldU LqHl GfliA — a a a ° a JMIIrIddV INNflhILV VIUVHOVZ e.CJqat2euepTseu :bs T"1W ar eiojea CZUCMN .0 .0TJ..BTU CZUCMW JO JflO3 oTJsTa 9t. JO OLT JO 6L . °M 8 S U O ICUTWTJO 1uTxO 'oL6i dO L o& 'ivddv 'IVNINIUO (x&sIDru VZNVMN NOLLOItSIHflf &JVT1ddV VZNVMW JV VIMVZNVJ, JO JHflOO HDIH a lll kfl a tJsT 0 i; 2 l* TI —2-- This being the position, I can only say that the learned Magistrate who Baw. and heard the witnesses is in a very much better position to assess their truthfulness or integrity than this court which merely reads the record. f agree with the de'ence that. there may be cases where prosecution witn sses so obviously contradict themselves that an appellate court may find it necessary not to uphold a conviction - but this, with due respect to the learned counsel, is not one of those cases. In this case there was the testimony of the complainant, supported as it is, by the evidence of Police constable Silas (PW.3), that it was the appellant who assaulted him. The only evidence contradicting their testimony is that of Police constable Hermes (P.W.l); which evidence did not impress the learned magistrate as truthful. I fail to see why I should differ with the learned magistrate's conclusion, based as it is, on a finding of fact. I agree with the Republic that there is no merit in the appeal against conviction.. .ppeal against conviction is hereby dismissed. As the defence has withdrawn the argument regarding sentence on the ground that the appellant has since been released under the recent Presidential Amnesty Order, I do not propose to deal with the •.uestion of sentence in detail.1 I would however say that in the circumstances ,of this case. a sentence of 12 months imprisonment cannot, by any stretch, be said to be excessive. (L !ML /NZ AG. JUDGE. Mwanza. 18.12.70. Dc - ti6rez,$ for Republic. Accused present & represented by Tukunjoba & Co.