19760604 TZHC Mwanza

• ••.SS uruncs-j tfl. r'tjq Or oeuqtM 9,10LU pT GT eivcoq ttT1dct 30 JflOArj Ut uwnC PPJI .Jfl03 1tJ. 8t{. tfl. pirDs flsJt oso eq. o 'qo9Ts1 utqxoc1uit uics uo itoswTq P.0JtP9TW e qst3vui 0TJ5TD tTT - CTCT t? P 1 IT aufl Tti1TtI I 40tIePtAO aq. ;o itOtA .xdo.xd U uc q.ng xnoo rtiq eqq. jo qrip wox; eoUGpTAq eqq. 30 IA9TA .UeJ233ep t T1I)f4 J431 1 q otJsrp Gtll qortcr 1? JDOo otqstp Oqq. O p 0 VUn;sseoons tJAYMcq ej-j •pS0 .tWstp SM 1UIT0 s 1 .uouodsej sucsvaq qAOqP etp .xo °stJrpunOq pert; otTm szeqwew U1 0 014 30 e0uepta9 GT4 peJBJeJCT xnoo oqj, •s.xqwew uwo — uou ei suoq {qwt[aiun SM U( 9T 103 0UePIAe CM JtM S8S5OU.TM 0Mg. Ct 30 DOUOPTAe eu4 fliLT 'Ptfl 4VTPJttt1 'P1° s1t?EIc U9AOS XTS Ufl. St?M Ot!M U0S tfl'3Ut 18t TO ;ieq uo PUTWEW00 CAtt PIUM j.UCSJCI StM 07 xeqow sctr. 'pu st jc uotrocT p.usqns v OuTsoT .uepuods Otfl ut pepisi pu hIM 041. jc SUOTsIAQId etq o. Ravjquoo pexi; eJeM r@TJnPUOq 9,qT 91761 Ui 31 T[q MOTA OI JO 8JM 'tPU00e '91761 Ut serxpunoq et. j tztxTj Tunl-O le GtTT ul peoIwT ejam 0M sieqww TZt0 JO e9U9piAE 014T PoTdL4 00P 901 6 TSJTJsu0s8J 90JIT0, 103 U0St0ep S110WtUUfl B'ttfl nV P9ATJJU q.Jfl03 tJOWt1çJ TJI t1If4 etjq. JO SUOtSTAOJd et.fl tfltM eOtzt?pJ0oo3 ut ejam. 91761 Ut pxçj sP setrpunoq etq. q..q. pUUOJ IV1Sfl(JWtUUfl q.XnOD IVJ?WtJd Gqq. e0TPTA 8141, tf 9UtJ8tt Jq.J 'se11opuncq CSETq. Utt utoTdwOo iut ueeq q.ou st eJetfl. COUTS JCAO pule Jeqq.JW Tq. UtPti1OUt pettJeo'oo TTV Jo eouesecT iq. Ut PGXTJ 01CM V0Tq. q.tiq. 'U'M 9t4 JO MUOTSTAQTd eq. tfl.TM aoUvpaOooP UI '[DeXTJ 01CM S0JUfl0 91761 oqq. q.tq i4etL sTLI peq.Joddns OtJM sJeqwew UnO TTP SOSSCUq.TM peTo si-i TTTM tI94JM s 1 JO?q.s0q. etq. tflTM aoxzvpa000p UT 01CM SJ&tU8W U[0 -fl 91761 Ut PCXTJ s0i..ttOq .............. 9H:st)i4h1 9SCq_ pCq.ndstp q.UUeCTdP eq. q.rEd STt UO 'JOq.t?q.sCq. 0tfl Aq q.j1 hIM 0tq. WE SUOTSTAOJd Ctfl. MOITOJ q.ou pip Aet. 'PUnOaP etp. uo setpunoi oqq. uixt; 01CM seqwew u[o eq. 91761 lIt UeTM q.tnq. pepp Veqj q.uepu:)cT$PJ pu q.UO0ddU etq. oq. oqq.ecibeq oq. pBtstM CT.{ suotq.od OMq. etfl. 3.0 setJpurt'.q t31:Jq peq -çJosep 1ctxteio J0S0q. etfl hIM Sttq. Ut q.UT.fl. pUt. 'T1hI eqq. Oq.OJM UJCq.t[ eq.[ otq. UC4M q.tzesod 01CM iVetq q.Tq. peq.o sseuq.t OSCI.IJJ pUt?q. St IDE4JOthIrtS OtiM '(M'd) VXIDq, etjq. puo (Iid) ovvaoi 51OV 11.3 fla 'sesseuq.tM P11O OH Uotq.1oCI JCh1ULU I.[OflW T_' SUTq.TO-3 ott put ThIN 0111 1pufl eq. p0[q.tq.u9 SUM O UU4q. U0Tq.1O( o23çq qonw uçq.q.o q.U'aCdd'a otq. UT PTflS0J stqq. PUU 'hIM tt- J' SUOTStAOICT Ot{q. qq.t!4 00UUJ000U ui q.ou 01914 91761 UT pexJ sOt.xUpufl)q otn. q.ttl iVUS oq. uo q.tZCM q.UOpuOdSeJ eq prqlloêep TrIo 01CM suctq.ot oMq. eqq. u9Mq.eq setJupunoq eqq. ThIN sttfl. UI •q.UU0dC3 CTq. 1109 2UtATAjnS TEll Dt t uospUtJ sru 'wrq ueeMq.eq U0WttS IqC1A1 OTT TTTY, SITfl uI [TIM V TUIAUOT peto 'JsLv CUO 'eqq.jpu'J sn q.tq. petjtq.seq. q.uoptzoseJ otjq. 'q.Jnc IVJUWIJd etq. ut peuedo tUTJ etq. U 911N 'aGqq.vJPTCJS sit Aq q.JGT. ITIM etq..tJq.M 80UUJO00 Ut q.ou pXtj 0J8 . '10qqUJpUU12 z7q 3° tflUep etfl Uodn 91761 Ut pexlj 9qwEtS CLtq.oCdSOl JI0Tfl. oq. s0tJpuflOa Otfl. q.U1q. St?M WtU[0 STICT JO STSwq eqa q.uUedde otq. OTOUn çq jo q.Uqq. pxU rqWUqt stL ueotq.eq S9Tavpvnoq jo uoTq.UOOTTUOI Ut31SU VJJX€[ Hd0f q.tT0d(t oqq. pens ijnj q.UOPUOCISOJ aq .T ?WOq.U{ q.u q.otq.sip uqo3Tng jo qnu 9,T'pLu -c,-zd eqq. u r. LLttJOfl! ° ... '..' 1JIdfl?T JtLI?flJAT JkII0cttJ S . 'nsJ0A TVNTcTcT T ' '. .. ° ' ' .. •... Hdc0r (L6t J°.0I Oj0SU3 hAlo q.o .USTW q.011q.Stff 'bs 'nuJnqoUD )LIa T cL6T Jc Li "& P Cd. dVTTATO III'. UO)![ q.e UqO)n[ JL q.noo 1_O1q.Stp etq. 30 UoTSIO0p aq WOTff ?..: ., ... cL6T 9 0 L 5.0NT 1T7TfT . . . S VIVMVJ 0 JTfl00 HDIH tH tiI 2 This is not true, the Primary Court arriveu at this unanimous decision after a very detailed analysis :f the evidence, and as remarked there were three reasons for this decision. Secondly I think that there were no good reasons for the district oouri in its appellate capacity o substitute its own opinion thn the evidenoecf the witnesses for that of the ttii oôürt As tiá cdntents of the Will were not in dispute but only the manner in whiàh they -ware cdrxiëL1 out, it was irelovant to prefer the evidence of P. W. I and P,.W.2 oqer that of the clan members simply beOai.s thëyP.I.idP 2'wr )rOsont when the Will was written. Thirdly the quesGion a.wha the principal heir is was also irrelevant for it was neither raised nor in issue at the trial in the Primary Codrt 0 But incê dllthecicheñbr rsent'agread that the boundaries as fixed in 1946 were in accordance with the provisions of the Will, there was no creuible evidence to contradict this, further I have not been able to trace any reason why the entire clan should have ganged up against the respondent, ahd if. these boundaries had been so unfairly fixed in 1946 in disregard of the Will, I cannot unders anci how the respondent could have chosen to remain silent for-l1....thse years from 1946 tp 1975 even if his mother had ohosen not to speak up against the aemarcation at the time. f the was sevei in 1946, by • 1957 he was old enough to lodge on his own behalf any cho1leg to his interests. . For all these re.sons I thintc that the cecisirn of trc Prirniy Court was mo r e ih dccb'dWith reason and. the evidence in the record. Accordingly r allow the appeil. The jugment and orders of the district court ar stt oside,and the rigihd.1 judgmont and., orders of the • Primhry Court are restored. The appellant will have the costs of this app eli. MWANZA. L. MFALILIT 4TH JUNE, 1976: JUDG - .- .