19800828 TZHC Dodoma 1

•ic&-esq tx et, jo uopotm oqr. 2luTTpvozcddu 9XA OM.tZOtIM TCU O. Soqqar4 cux pOU.ICM JVTII o. txn. o. !.noqe evm i sr 'zo.otx. 914 O. poç @L4 wi SCM OT.jM Roqtur4 . v puT4 I ,Ops rrr SXCMO. 2UTOD SCM I '8CITtAIXBAUtI ? pso..t 2u0i .IO.00J. a upzp SCM I 'U" 006 .noq L6I/9/c2 uj '-°TJ4STa açq4 trç eunj 4i o uooq aiii oi I :ICcE 1fl pCS OM 'CCJC wna Vq UaAT2 SCM tZOTS.XOA ot1 uOptOoC a4 poSflCo ttoTTM saouCswno..ro euj. DUTpale,90a SUO-r&TOA OM. pesoijosp .uCrEecrcEC ei. EICC eTCos 911 tIT pTI SCM tOtt4 eoueptie euj '9L6I 'R Ounf tzO UT ç1pSCM UCIIeddC 0t4 Ot(OA io.oui ou qoçtM r2opTooC uU iox; esOIC t'ITeddC et. suTleDv 05t?O aTU /000' 'sue ;o out; U o. peotzetzos SCM PU 'q0V pOUOttZolII9J03t? Ot_ ,O o 'S O. JUUXqUOO 'OOqaA .ZOO1U C JO OSfl OCJaptStzOOtrç JO OOtAUOO SCM L6I 'oj o;;Cçj pCoj aT4 jo (q)9 puC (C)(T) 's o tquoo 'u&ip sse -poe.x ;o peoC; otm 4 JZ8flodcEC 014 cqOJ0t(M OJSçp 0MUTlJ go qanoo -T".STP 814 go uoiocoep C WOJJ tC0CdC tIC St sçu - '' f NwfafL L/oc ' 0 N !.OV OTITJV-x L pCoff Jo (q)()9 puC (C)(T.)j7 Z/O pCOX oqnd 814 tIC 01Otj8A I.0).oW ' trç.&].Ip ssoppa :0V}j5 l.N(MOdSaI orianaai aHi SflSt9 A aNV'ITtacIcIV '"'!'!.'""" IViI)WMNVAVX O/SNOSflIVH !ysIOv joisia 'bsa 'nmDNncr1\I TH ' : jQaa (Z'sm-mi ve 3M&TT1j JO JflOØ TO 9L61 d o P9 ¶°N OSC3 tCUTIIrPO ICT.ITt 1 O) ),L6I doLi • ON 'ivaav 'IVNII'IO NOIaOIasDInf glvTiaadv - - wioroa LIV VINVZNVJ do LIU1100 HOIH IH NI •1 • tb M T!d Gt oij a4 TO b'! paa q oL nq 'paeds tq z1;oJ Uaddv OtT p:tt qs o. ppo ot Aq dais V o 2io.xq axojq. pia&oo AOt—pU 14 140Tt USTp tloTSTUOO prpOALa o. sum - &tZf $MLIO St[ 'TT OtA IOOttt ST JO IOflGOUttI ut?floddt - e o pueq e-p aiot jiano et sp1tMO. peoui puts PL-OZ etq. JO POL( AOtPU1 eI) VY, UtM Jt3.X. aTAI,tçM Opfloo .IGiOX PT1BI flOO /OJ UO$Oi JO ØU tit. MOTIOJ O tlfl3 ttLW popflOO @AULI PP'A JeAoH pT.tr o.ia& j - p osnoo•eq tzoq 1uiIodth ai4 paeCox - iar peu.xoet etz Iwtod TvL4 Uo D.ZOM Otz U-T q'UOo qtxamBpnC OtX OtO Gt JO UOTUTXOGp uT ttOflSOflb TsTonio U SN s@ssOt4Tm JO f4TITUPOaD I OTTqnd0a Bt. .IOJ 1StbflOO '; ii q no petrçod SM sj •ooueop O 1L1TM POU&AOP XO9 Ot1dWT OT4 qu . p@ddo%e pox et. ;;O tTI et. 110 .O4ETt3 13 JO fl&. rocwt O! UO /i 01 30 0XflOO 0t3 t1 'ZOOX. 014 PTOAU O • ()JJ rrç po.x ot4 jo qtpz r.TTq '. potut.4 p snoobta7 • 0. Oflcj 11ZtU11M .fl0tTTA& Q 0U o. p1r4 STq-dnxqui.xç 0tZ% otq ooi o14 otddu ptT am ueuj 'e, -ço 4LE pUbJ fl !11 ptrçqq po001 .i0qou4 .014 JO J0A.xp OT 'Io:10 e4 109 pooOt.{ p0fl01J : 31 n JTO pto aut a;eatrsp aOLIZ tI 49J1J 'P il aiqj .&q tut Q o --i. 13 Oji UT E flA ecuMTQ tbTOSd GJOM 0A WLTM qgzt SL 110 p9StIOO 14A P4°S I /i 014 UT Om4 STUO o. o.ze o. out ej ip0oi eqO u. EnIVII O. ttrq - PtB .1 'toL BJO .XOALXp V Wa flpt0.&.Ie14 SM 0J ttL UT p09lO0 L6i/9/ 11O :PTS 0 - tzourj 0poqUt V I-V *Ma S. q UaATD sti. , tzoTs.IOA f10140 Ott 41 •.iVt-eVq 11 - 014 0bT 't0O.I 014 U.Xfl 0 flCC SI2M 014 poq seod hoqu S1M O[)Tt[OA s j !.Txettaddv eta. -2uT pxoaoV 'UTod d-çour.xc1 ouo uo qdooxro £.xo.s sp poJ0ddns Qoquar4 1 s9OUjTM ouj (PE:TTddno st sTseqdme e14)s; 011M pas-nooV ttsp oudmTot. .13 poddoo xooptx poeooy 9 0 IIM 13 0J. Pt(t tT.X 014. 110 ptO.I ot4 ;jO 0111 ptztoq emto posnoaJ 014 Aq tbOAtJp IoL as i/x M tg 0Ut 0A0W t 0 .&tcIWo 3 PM I U01bA !IftM 0tbI tXpxt 0M ot O. fVM-oq 14 trttrçod ULZ AaI POII13UT0 84M PuTtlaq tfl-oc oX .x01401111 stm oeq. V R I T4AM2 rJ.Lx-t •.0U pp OC—Uth4 AJ/ •0U1 ptrçtjoq WuTmoci - OTJJ. 011 ptrno; - pufl • -- t I- -3 Thi learned magistrate does not appear to have addressed hi mind to the contradiction between the evidence of 1 1W.2 and that of M,5, Elia Taraka. According to BV.5, there was no vehicle behind the trailer as he was a)Out to turn to the right. Thi is contradicted by PW.2, who i estified that at that time the appeUt landrover was about 45 paoe hind the trailer. IF PV,5 was not telling the truth on the p1r did his evidence not require great scrutiny before it was accep - i? I would nnawer fiat Luestionthe affirmative, The witness wolild appear to have been determined to put every blame for the ccident' on the appellant Judging from the total y of the evidence on record, I am not, u..Jke the learned tri.J magistrate, persuaded that the prosecutoil had discharged hi burden in the case. 2he probability that the appellant's story vas true existed at the end of the triali br the reasons I have g .iven t I allow the appeal, quash the convictions which g incidentally, was not supported by Mrs Paffdri it and set aside the sentencee if the fine was paid, the same should- be reftnded to the appellante . 7 .. \ B .. SMATTA -H. JUDGE Delivered this 28th day of August, 1989T in the presence of Mr1 Saffari. lB A SAMATTI JUDGE