19840918 TZHC Mbeya

WC tc) Ill ¶I ¶CI JFT or mA.r, ii • ciDIcTIoii RIrnJ A2L .O. 48 OF 1984 ' 0Gi CTLLL ç U OF 1904 or -i DiThI co.: e yr rrp •p Before 1iprra, TJsq., Resjcrnt Mai.str'te. tt'fl3A !I!t!IYJICUtJJ .•••. TRuç ¶rI R3.II?U13I4IC ,,,... •... . iSPOND..' CHLt Detjqmer$ of a. gjrl u twelvo d/s.136(l) of the P.n1 Code. J)11)ITT BAIiT1, J. M413A AXTJCUL, the app3lltulb in this oIe was convicted, of the offen8• of DfitectVt of thOi twelve Zteaki 801tit6ry to siction 136 (1) ôf the I'erial Coc1 e d t'E sentenced 'to b for three ycax'e Xo J- 8. P'oW 6 pp e alin8, oth atast onYittioi awl sentence, Halina 21xti, 1w.1, i -' i'l who was aged under 12 yea-s in Der, 193, T'w$ 1Uøw bbe ppe11M obe. wan a noihbour. 0r 13412.3 the ape11ant h,rect 1v4 nb4 t.jd SO) iiith ha and £r *eturn ho av her 1 gjj 14 anA. SIisA,`IW* ProLi t-ierco'i tl -ic aapoll ant ride a hf1't of hAVing Sex with Pw, wtt3. one d ourt of fw,l tond. the a tnt with fw.]. and the apalant h4 his tousors down. t is W)én th Po1••too1 her tôir zothÔr .(1w.1 1 nouhtr). Th CathL'of IJ. &udj PW4?2 4ras th,ly inforned of what ho 11enc&, ?u1 esti.oned and ht aeeI that' she had been having sex with the poi'at. The' iacter was refered "tdC.CIL Office and 1101 , 3 Jbi, K'.it-cio,. a oel der ofiit area wnt to the hor.1e of PW,2 where many wmexi and u(rA had Gathee. P'1,3 S ul1uone the apPellant at the raeotinf vthe hoñeofjW.2. i3. 1n askedthc appellant vhethcr i. we truee (3fJ Ie the oirl of Pw2. At fiät the appefl.arit 5 ec di ' sç i ir3. (T'J.i) was atined by a tQn of old women who found bcc no lntae:t. Lae,on th: appellant adn,tted to ha ve 4eflled te f piece of paper was iiii4en appe.larit sied it on lus o\rn in. hout ooipu1son. 'The pdo of paper was not prodtzoed in court s Ac06.7-dino to PW.2, aSter I9.1 1d been excinecl az to whe -bMv bhe vAs a virin or no the appeiant adnittc to have '•fl/ :- - - -:'-•• •.'•' • ,--- . 1• —2- ifilod T _t hp. 11iitcs :ii to çc;d -to the oharge but he s-1 he i1ii.e c -s. $o o rotp his 1ijion aria the appellatit thun rtniod 'h't w ttcn 1'\1 1 2 a10 S'i( iat Pw.. wt..o hoL'rt in 1972 w Zt detenco the tppel1t ae i e d to rv I' leii z,.. iJo told t he tial qowi t that he wra r oio y tu .u. r a neøttng, . He went there and he Fas, t01LIth he 1' L'CL s3c WLth*Pwel fe He dinie it . .. . ...........1 l3ut jnajated t) hc ha1 4i pl1ant duod i' Th*n pckopip-.abbd hu tmd presed ha.s tu on pie Off, pe.i -ther had written an witiesee inec1 on The le arned triA' ait t to.3. ived fi%. .nd f. 'tov warnina hie1.f of the t1Aher of atihg on the ev(tendo eoboratio* he j Qonviotrl jI ap-'eJnt ao chec'. T* &ppel ant hi e iornclu J4 aea. at*p kod the jepett - of the ernod a'tr.to. Nr 1 Bate3, i4iGa leaxned Counø2 fr the P.e1li thAt ti ca 1967 204 ha. d, 1T)tCt h t ottion ot 1 evIce of 4.he 4 ioNq trix . Uas jaecess tr 1ei.a1 otencez. I h rwe 'øad the ase t1L pô by 1arm G6uI4. Cm X i of -t øø ideied opini }vtt it ctoe iti n9i this SeCtiun lfl of the JVic'61Ce 4ct rode titt $ once of at1d of t2d 3'e8!E IZ3T )ase p, t iotion CVeT } 1QX L iè not /1ff4fl on oath. Oto the trt1 t ha s iai te].t Of •thç clnØ fctjn on suoh evidenc, At 'y aot on it to OI1\2.t the accu z ;crs ft it is fu1l at5.stied 'r't thj &tld is teLL io$bji bi the tiuth, thia oaie the tria3. aum wcrned Jseif 0 ger 171, o.ao -i '4y the 14 sh olu ld,14,ez eaimst the a;jo11t Who WhOL, &a uec1 o c11 f and iho 'c10 to b 1967 HLD. 205 cied by firity. 19 ~ th 1rned Gowex does not he. It ciei tty * *btt eootion 121 () c.na (3 of 11e BVielatee Act toes j204 ç evi'onoe of i1d in sexual otfenooE. It oe iny trp. of e44ne 'hç tt ec'nccted with & sLral ofae ir n. The other o1nt roio.ed imr N, tring is with to th yoi. &tre eondtoted liy the letrncd ttiidl 1 a3iirate to 6-er ISI %i14ther 11,1 .Im s H seeasd of sufficiet nte11igenoe to ustafy $h€. rception of he ev14eee 41 the -. *idenea At svys or wheth in the Oirn ~ of th out under,tands the nature or an o'th TLr. Dat ei yun ea.. ijttod l't the wholc exaiiinatjon should have ben set out in the .proceo(ins it rs not ox.ih for the trial aistrate to r;cord as he i . . . pp O R 't q 4q oINe quoT por; u-q ptq ET1 7attr1nQ 0. . ti was q; pa eciOT; qnt( 4 puv oet et 9Oi2 Q 10 4VU &tt OEt zUflCbr 4 4qA I PTP ptTt q$. êtf$t%4 4t'q; % tzo O. ut psjp ueoq -t r .toqai& PUTAMO lz o tS B pult, lXt&OI -r T Cct owe Err e.it 'tt4 tOt.tt p0eOO (4 Ve ua sa& F--0 4 12UTIT IC0 ;r(Tt esQ 4 OAOTCI pflQ3 UC4fl000X o; ; -çq -it te-3ou rroq. so potxocrl rn i 8q0q4er, a ,6 0tfl 4i XS.I P° D(L .ct1 0,1 0* tjiliC O4dV U T1Ct O. porcIi [az q euoje ioj uotr po.LM )Vtt pLID, ;j peopul fle( et 'rT qt iT IOU s?ut000 ettt U .OU PW gemrv-nvrTx um a al lc: o; ntt; W& T ° i ttv p II4T JO It4JU OtR 33T1 pOUO'i fls .OU 0191i øecUqt' ;uicoduT aj. os p . no pe.oc tz ' .ectCt .XQ$ taUn0 pCUItt OtLL •cra b! Ikoi1 '. p•tTw) oq ;O u ot no L OOLOt7TAC G.ii 01r4 e1stt ' I -J .a Tz, e t(OTtTJ't Qcj TJ •ti( tLT .O )3 )LAO 0t E3Jt tlUOC O.XGt CLT T TJ ') tO ,O C Oq. 1fla1OE t.t 1 r y90 3SC CVTI4 AC VtOttO. eJYOOO.t vtm •pIott 6346xew r J tT( pu OouotI;u qq.3o PCTJP.LI 4.flOO tV4 0t tM 2UTIMI PUV UO 1OAUT Ct ;o §806 0 ZCdo ts pu cpc LIT) oi; ILI Vac qes oj ireoeu ou UT çu 0 t: GT pIoaI .sni q.inoo eq; xtq. , uori o. we-.-Vpr~V eq. r'z; j)OOfli øAO O4 e[ I '.r iooe.i oi zZrtc JpnC '- c cut •pu epu eq rtI T tC1 0U0 J'E. Lt1L tI -DC1 .CU ,)CGJ UCT' T.SOA.X' tZ tOfl, - flt IC'LIt t i pT ttT OU 6 e2xI uo ec1dV o rxtoo atil •es uit £oq O14. tTt .ITJJt tOJ3 UO' t tOAU1 £U )3CI )A t 0 'LOU eddt Jo .irco3 ot. £q pttr - J e1inC jvTj4 ar.. ei 4uUqj u •unq. 04g. t(1E O. 4np !40L oq. ooretttG.Wc t[ 0t e io qo Ui 30 Z14U CL pVc , sxn l;ttm SIJC& .ZOpU0L JO ptOt4 Y 4tqE? eqq O. at zo'.ceu c Tp000.xcI io an' eta. .tat- TnbeI etiuz 40tz seop ;ç t; q.oe;Jo tfl. O! S ;t JO ?trçpC1EJrI W3 OSJO pOM tq2riot4; GUO 9A?t( I '6'v: 6c6 Jtr ;oei Ct on 0. p e4To TPunAa llo g • .XN • 1 t'..zq et red oq. .&np ota puti Im jo ou rri -.siepun seup atfl_ PCT.P3fl.t3 t. T p0.0tU00 24 OEçp o.ITOA :zto — C- Sd pe uti TJ LEO iesn o.io; o £jpaat o.;a 4Ot o otd 014 U0 cA2c auj.pt To vitod et; uo çctEe 6t juvn.acICt -t LEO PeUt CT(A seu; jo ooueot u-t pei;ep ot o. pçnp put UE 0 IC 9 Ot .TJt4 OXê LaCVCt ; aoect at uo uetx 'q pTaolk osa ;iqtt out, i upf 'eqt Xt '1' 1vflecI 04g. tcYçtpi a@Jtc JO , o aq4 ;o ooetc eq. ;o Gj.uojw r; Th ot ol ?n SOUIXr 8Mfi. JtC1 pGuctqJtt JA tio [tiM 1.O'tO14 ZOttE1 3 U ;f.L. u iodd TO oo;t la pecIoxct OAiL P -C.- 10M, 1: usta tott o otia j IC çSB0JUOP )1U 12r4.cre jt1 ?E) 1 38 t UOTSCtO0 p.t 03t1tt IOCI t1 .öt; 014 oi-T'ci EOLO O. ajYaU SIflk 0ttj J)tZ1. tte4ç.II CUm t3(i2O .008TI 3 PctOq9t.X 0 'Fi ['M JO QQO.X.ZOO 31 8OL0t40 utcIth? OTV Gtfl . oqi. ç O p8pxc4eZ uQ 8JUOD 014 ptZ P p0ittlo 't .&..tLL O L)Ø pu c.et4 PIJD? t( O pGq4r'p tIIt0( 0t1 . t.O3 -3T41.)(Q, av , stq. UO eTr LsP Lt%OW i itr ot(i% ou ees 1 potjp oq suoo uItGi ot1. DW, oI. 0 4Tt op JO ou&)rAe os pC rp,ro. 4t1QO 014 .OVJ LII tr tvt ut 'i ppçqq9 P01401FA •pp rtn ti I '.UTOd QtZ icit to pepsp eA a. 4t £çqTpa ,jo uop ith uJ ojrj • tec C jo eoatd .v14 uo j'ç eit 5uq.euO •etO X89t .Vq o .udqrm14 o. epitr, oqq1U ;. pop qo 1'T :dUJP nciti o OPU)A0 It posju0O 1.GLt &( sr c etj q puJqEit. zocr jo e oTd 9 VIP ToTSG..UOO 94 JO •814 ut2 eou0 t.oCn fl0Z oq zt iir Ut ttMO3ttfl 0 .OU wu4A c &Tdz3ottL rn 3t p)m? • ST •p0OF9O( fgq4ve JO 8) - J 014 )0fttT flt4 0MC 0 2 ?Utl&Yt ll ptr u .tzit uotsroo qons c'fqI tO toctC Jo aeTJ pu pi'q' pejoppt o (M-i pU c.k,) T tJO X014 x0rT. 1.1 00 314 aio;eq UoT1S)JUO0 S q T01! 0L4. O tt:.T..'nD, 014 S I0C OS JOSO C OOUOPTAO 814 O. 8.XOIi 73 J 1 C fl J t1t1Y0 Ot(t& 9$O JO 4uoLtt.ce 0.10 oIoti Tto . ' o OUU1O )0flJ0p qTp'q Ot8 314 V2W. SMo 012J Otfl. ()I. Si 1T or' 3'i JLot1T;Or. •&i oosou op.. I tO14 p0A.)rEe. p ST T8ITJ0p 0tj 4 £1' tt' It4 JO jt1OflT00II. 014. 3I ! U1E0(I(L3 014 cO. OOLTO?TAO a& 1?. qostot rC otq. p01TT0'0L L[S 2UOr 'tq so.:'cj et1o&U1i - T: P01TJP U 0 0Q?ti IIT ptiq -4- '? was suc1 t icce of per t - s r ru,ht hay eon chffere?i • O proper evaluetiori of the evicence cn this s)ect I ci sccisLcd that th aellant arinitec' the offence c'efileuent ai 1 sicc1 oi thurLrici ed a piece of pcper COi teinin. such acLu.ssion. It follows thrto..e th"t th6 evicence of w.1 a to her 'ofiloticnt ane by whc, is corroborated by 1ic aoins1on of, the cp)ellcnt hiuscif, Conscqity I find the eviLe . in this csr i'hty antt coigerlt on which to base a convicrion. I thrJ .ce soc no i Li iii the )el aoinst convictioli anc1 1 dicnis' i acco - h • With regard to the a teal aainst senen I m of the cbnsiered pinion that it tas well iorited in view of the 66riousness of the offeice I corifirn tho sentence aecorcUnly. The ape1 is therefore .uiee in its entirety. JIJtG Ju1eent de1ivord Cc..nr on 239. 3 44 vw:r3n for n)2u.LlanG. clunru for eocn C in . fiT iC e ) i 904 ICY -P. lifE Cf IL. A JJi?}fIC. ..tFTEEisII