19881119 TZHC Dar es Salaam

\.._ \ (h Q._ \4 ·0.,>') DT TITD EIGB COUJ.T OF TlJTZlJJL".. l ..T DL;J. DS . SlJ.JJJ~ (I'C) CIVIL 1.J?I?3}J., lTOo 31 OF 1988 (Fron tto u.oc:i.Gion of tho Diotj_•ict Co1.u,t of No~·oc.,'Oj_'O e,t N01:·ouoro in Civil 1..;poa.l Hoo 2 of 1988) SDLDl'UJJI S1.LUJ\1 MLDITIJl3UTie. o • o o • o. • o,.. o 4 o • o o o •.o • • • • o .JJ'I>:oLLJJTT vorous J1JJYi,A }IT1J,ffiJ..YJ. .GiJ • • ·• 11 • b o o e • o o • o o o o • o " o • e • o • o o • o • o o o • , IllJS:;:'OlJD:illTT J1JDG1 □:rr MJJ'IG1JT0 2 J., Tho ,.1cin insuo in tl:io cc.oo io whether tho roGpondont Jur.12, Mponl)2:,ynuq) troopussod upon tl:o shc:nbo. of tho 1·ospondont Scloncni S2,lunu Mczubuti oi tucto at Mcsotc::, in tho Diotrict of Ivioroeoroe Tl:2,t ir; wl:,.,t Solonc:ni clloeocl before tho pi'ino..ry cou;.,t nt Bwcldrc Cl:ini. Ro wo..s tho plcintiff in tb.d co1.1I't s IIc stated thc.t tho trespass hnd token plo.,co in 1980 2.ncl tl'-<.,t Jui::a procoodod to cul tivc.to porr.1w.1ont c.nd ooG.sonc,l c1•o~~)s on tl:o ol:.;:-;.,l)v..o Tio s2,icl tl1t.,t ho uco t:·.o:;1 in Dm~ os S2.loz.1 u!10::i:-o l:o w2..o roc:::i-,d.nc; t1'02,tc.ont for an illnoso wl:.ich l:o clic1. not spocifye It 1-m.s corn:1on e,rrouncl that Jur:i2, l1c,s l:is 01,m shc..i--:1bn next to tl:c.t of Solor.12,ni. It wM June I s contention th2, t it wcs Solonw.1i' who l::.cil t:riocl to oncroc::,ch on :_i:J possoosiono Thero wc,s ovidonco fron sovure,l witnosooo who suppo:doc1 Solo:,cni I s o.110:.:;2,- tion tl1-.:.t when ho crno be.ck fron Der cs S2,lc.2r.1 ~10 protested N1cl r.12,clo c, cor.;.pl,,int to tho old.ors of tho vilh"so, c.nC.. tl::e,t when Junv.. uc..o qy.ootionod nbout tb.o r.~::-,tt•.::~~ ho in effect o,dni ttod tl::.c,t l:.o h;::,d onm.:oo,cl::od on Solo;·.10,ni t c possosoion 1 o:;;:pl.:--,in:.:1: i tl:2,t l:o h2,Cl clone so l,oco..u:Jo of f2I.1inoo The cvidoncc of those witnoasos went 0:1 to ol::ou tJmt Solono.ni 1-12,s odisfiocl lJy thd o.xpl2,11dion encl p01.'1.1i ttocl Jur.;2, to continua ed. tivctinc tho ohnnbc. in dis:;_:mtoo Tho quostion thct posocl for clocicion i:J wl:othor Solon2,11i Lr,d }.X)r,.1i ttod Jui.\'.', to cul tivo..to tho sl:-.nnl)e, tooporE'.l,ily OJ.' for coocl. T:.io i)r;i,nr.:ry com.•t hclc~ th2-t Soloncni i:r,d not o.J.ionctod tho sh2n1)e, to J1.1nr. for- r_;oocl mcl conooq1J..ontl;y- csv..-;io jude,uont in favour of Solor.12ni. lfaon tLc Dutter c,,no bcfo'.i:O tl:o cliotrict cov_-:_,t of IforocDro on t:'.ppo2,l, tho leaned princi:pc,l district nc,c;ist:r·c,to took 2. diffo:rent vicwe Ho l:olcl thc,t Solon211i 1:.2..cl c.,lionc:.tccl tl:c sl:.c,r.11x:. to Jun2.. for 5 ood. Tri th thv..t ho nllo1.;rod tl:o C.iJl)ODJ.e I hc,vo conGiclorod tho Dc.ttor cc:rofully c.ncl I b:1vo cono to tho conclli_oio;1 tl:ct tl:oro uc.s no juotifioo.tion for tho district cou:d to Ui)sot tho dociG::.on of tl:o 1,:dr.1nxy co1..'!1.,to On tho ovic~onco on 1,oco:rcl, oopocie,llJ the ovidcnco of SJ'.'I.Z Il.c.jc,bu Mc.ocn,::;i.uc. c.nd :;:iw4 Ju!Jo, !fajcnco, which oviclonce :,_:iositivolj,- iup1•0:Jooc'. tl:o tricl court~ I o.n se,tisfiod tl:o..t. tho c.odsion :..~ce,chod by tho tric.l cov.rt Tlus aj_)po2J. tl:.oroforo succoodG• Tt;o jud[;T1ont of tl:o clistrict cou;t't • is sot c.,siclo nnd tl:.;:,t of tho princ:.ry coui't rostorodc The c..ppcllcnt will b.c.vc his costs :L.'1. thi0 court end i11· the courts bolowo DeI'o Hl.J?IGJJTO JDJ)G.'J 19/11/88