19900622 TZCA Mwanza2

Er'.\UE7 .'..JJDJJ.,L!.Il. • • • 0 O O V::filSUS e O • 0 (;.:pp.oru fror tI.1c convi.ctiori, of t:.·.o H:i.j:i Coui:t of T.::,nzn.nic e1,t T;,,,])o~:•,:,,). dr..tod tho 29th of Soptor.fJc:c•, in ........_.............. ___ ,. -.:cut of t!.10:i.r JJ.ono one IT.32::.TIJJI :ELF::JTI ES,JL':ZI (:;:\ ::., 1) t'.l1d his cuts on alnost all ~ior finc;orso S!10 uc.,s ~:os:)ikJ.izod ru1c1.. ·c.liod 17 ._da,ys. o.ftOJ."l·lr'.J:tls 13ocauso....·;f ~ct9:1U:fJ: ..: . ,• T:.10 Hie\ Cou.,.~t d To.ho~~~ . . .... ,. Bf '.t.l::.e rJClc:'oc..socl ,r~th nn.lico-c.,fo1~ot:~oug!1t convictoc: ::in of curc.lor contrary to. section 196 of t::o :Pond Codo r..nc:. sontoncocl J:i□ to 0 "0 ./2 2 - Mor.10:r.nmhu:1 of i~ppoC1.l 1:mt c,ftcr 2. futile o::orch'.o of s'L'J.mittin~ oonto11tio11s 1 tJ:.r:,,t ia to sr:J :i..J.1r.:;~oclibility of t:·,.c ?.-_•ooocutfon t-ti tnossosi fc..iluro of provinc; ix,lico-o.forot'..:ol'-d-rc~ c.nc: t!10 or.i.•onoous 1•~joctio11 of t~:.c c:-sc for the· dcfoi-1000 ritra· Wt"2.bc.yo t:.:011 wont to civo o:zc:..1p.los of conti~o..clicti_bns 1jotwoon ,1 ' tho cviclcnco of :iolio1 ~..nc: tI1~-:c of :oUe,2o l'Iro E'.L:'.J!SII::. 9_lo::·,rnocl a.doqti:..~toly c1.o---,l t iri t:1 by t2:o loc-,i'11od tl"ic.l juc.1c;s u'.io bcliovccl the witnoosooo Ho cc.nto111.lccl t~1'.'..t t~10 co11tJ:0c.~ictio;.1c ·wore noro appc.ront tl1..-:-,11 1•on.lo Ho o,loo ,'.'..tt::-ibutocl tl:o v2,:dc-tion in dotnils 1 a,o he ocllod i t 1 to tho lG.:!.)SO of tine botuocn t~.lo ovont ruicl t~10 tricl o Mni ttoclly t~10 loarnc,cl t:vinl judge folmcl t~c.o..t t:1cro wo1·0 no ' contr&:ictions. ~ s~idg II o o. I .1111ct J:11. .. ..1,, • • l . no v~D.nG 111 t,101.r ~ I CLOr:.C2,).1ov.:: o~c~ in t:10 co11tcnt of their cviclci1cc to 81.l[.;c.,-c:r::t t>~-..t 1·1-:000 wiimosoos Wore untrut21ful 0 ,In Cl'OfJS-O::,"'.ni~1ntiony none of t1wso uitnossoo uc-,vorocl 01·, so to G~)oclc 5 ate ;-,_is i:-rordso If t:-,_o ovidqnco of ? • ~!.. 1 cliffo1•od fron that of ?.-:-r.2 on c1.n;y- point, it io 'Jcc--,uso 02,ch of then c:.:;:1•ivoc o,t t;:c scone 0t c:if:.:'c1·ont tii-10s0 '11!.:oro is.,· t:10:::cforo 1 no co:1tT,c~iction in thoir ovidcnco, · c:.s t:.:o l:x1..;y 0nc: ,S'Oi.rtJ.or:011 c.ssossors orronoously t)1oug'..:.t O 11 3.- tho si tt1c.,tj_o;,1. W!:'..S vice v.:r!} □ t',, [',8 !'.iro Nto,1·c,3,o l,r.,s seriously SL,:Jr.1ittodo ' Ho ·,,:i:o:1of.J0 to co1:.sic1o:i: t:10 OJ:r.,;]lJl,xi :)oi:;.1tcc1. out b3r Ero lJt::~Ji',YO · t110r:1 ,:!.l'ld ovc,J.u"-t0 .. { in t::c lij'.t of t:.1;:,,t ;'.olc1.il1c;2 "On hoc.rinG tl1,) o:;:-Lo 7 I ...,!.l·~,1 · ,;•,·• ·?,,tl,r,; 1"0'lt OUt I.. ♦ 1..i •• ·c; -'-1 .. 1 ___ ...,_ • - ..., to inycst"ic;o,tc. I 1-rc,c 0:."J. .:;n,cl 6 o I G~·,,1-r t'., r:t.11}. r g 1-.,,.111:.1in3 mr::i,~/ fi•on t7:c oconc. T'~o1•0 ~rc, □ juot t·~.~O lTOTJD.l:l a.net t~.:::) !::C,.i:1 1{10 1,t';,S l,,,_1:.1~1i.J.1C ~,_;i:•Tc~3·to n 11 'TI.~o 2,0CUGOC:. 1-T(.',8 2J.ol10o T.:Cl.'O UC:C:-0 tlQ ot~1er :people. 11 11lll!011 I 02.:.10 ot1.t, I om~ Ibz,r-,hin /} 6 :~ of/ 0..:.10::,,d of no o..-~J.10;:,,cl of us t~10ro lrc.s a, C;'l'Ottp of poo:,lo otc~•ounding t~"lC.1 clocoe,Doc°!..,·j•, "I o.nd r.iy son wore not tho fir □t to t:..:·:dvo a,t tllo soonco" .\pn:i..,t fro □ t!10,t there m~s ;:,., contro,cliction o,s to vr..10 o.rrcstod "On 01-c:~ cri~i·val t?:~cro 9 ti:o c:wct1aocl 1r~s ,just rimDin:J e,1-ro.:;7 D'.'oi·-1 t!.10 scone • ,., o :~o c:1,1soc1. :.:i□ o .- ~ ~::., t:'.J"'7Cntoncc~ ::in , • ~ Ho. C,?.,ucJ:l hir.~ o,bout 50 po.coq fror., t:.:c f:!00110 -··. 0 0" Ilm·lior on- :\:To 1 had s2.idg 11..:':..ftoi- .O.j;pi•ohonclinc~ 21.iG 1 tho 2..couoocl ct.•o:):;iocl t~J.o knifo on tlJp croim.d ,<Jncl ny. fo,t::c:;:• )i.c!cccl it Upon .. . ( . . C ,, • 4 "Ho went out 2,1[1.ost ir.:r.1::;,cli.---,tol3r Ol"!. ::02,::_•i::1c t>..o Yioiso o O 41 l~o c:,.(~scrl :~.i1:1 e,c 1ro r.~ir-Jod 2.11 0,lc.,r□ o 0tl1c:: ')0 0;)10 C0,□ 0 r,ft Cl' \[C :.:2.c1 D,:11;1•0~,_oncloc~T.G1' .___ ( ,):1~):.10.s is su :i2)l:i_:::.,~J-- dispolloc1 1.mc'Luo crocli t i;bo~1 ?:.o mj_-l z nr: c1.icl not t21~c :1:--xt :L"'l. G.rroGtinc; tho. c,ocusoclo rro 1r:.,,s :1~:ncl eel to no C;f,l coll lc0(for."' 1io ::-,r1•osto:1. t'.w ;..',CCus:.,-: to(\'Ot~1-cz- i:rit~ 11 ot:.:i.cr l)OOJ?lOo 11 · T.110 in~onsistonoy cr,lso c:dotocl o,s to u~:ot:1-0:::.• or not ground thr,t t!.10 uitnossos wo:co not togot::or lJOC:.',UDO t!1.0Jr 1mrc doniocl :zi,, ;T t> 2 hi□oolf o gro1.1.ncl 0 It if.l our opinion t;_;.c.,t -t~10 o::;:.."'.::TJ;los e,'ivo:n ;:-.,_ q cufficiont to r:cko it r,~nmckntly olJvious t~,_e,t tho cont:~c,c7-ictions botwoon tho two koy 1-li tnosso □ coulc1 not 1_;:) i·oconci;I_oc1 011 2,.ny co;.1co~'IJ2..blo tria,l jud.[;o, t~mt t J:,_O~/ c..I'O not uort~1y 'of ·2,11y c:tccli t 0 , ~oo o/5 , : ;.: r ,.. .... · J • 5 / ground o:f aypcal,9 whicl1 is tl1.:,;t the defence c~·.oc w;:;s e:-::;:-onou,_sly identified 1)y P. Wa 1 9 ho 1;rc,s :::.:.":i:ostccl 1);,r a ce:?k,i11 iJiJ.i tiC'.,rello 1(10D Ho 1,11s la,to:;..• iold tho.,t he !.12J3., i11,ju:i.."Jd a, uor..r,nj roconcilod, they had told ldm t'x...,t :i_ t !:lV,C~ i1ot ::mclcclo Second u~1ilc dcfcncog 11 I find tll.:-·,t sto:.·y 1·idicuI01...1s0 It is vc-:,_•y st1•ElJ13'0 tl1::-.:b if Julloro we,s ouch 2, [;?ndgc 1 Po W0 1 r':.11.d Po W 2 sJJ.01.iJ..d c:'J.0,1100 u:;ion □l'.c.~1 2, ::n:ldclon f', occasion o.,s o.,n ;::,,tt.;i,cl: upon o., [;t~::'..,.1.:;o:r o..t ni:;hto I find tho ~>,COlIBOd ~ s o.,11032:r--; on ·i:,>-t:,~.·1 l::,.· :preposto1•ous., 11 Tho apyollc,nt bi'ov.ght o"C!.t ~110 issue of thio old q1...1.·::c:cel 11hon cross-,e:,::,_1,m:i.11:i.ng Po Wo 1 n;1d P .. W., 2 1J1..rt they dc;1iod. 2.,"1~- l::nowledse of "'"'"t-'~in.._<>,tc .t"'~ .L" ...L(Jj ~ ~-~ t11·, u. u ;:,r•-·osJ_t., 0·11-- (.;,, ..J....1..1, - l ~- J; 0 r.r T.J a~. 'I O ., ...~n' ..r \!L .,;n 0 '·' ,'.J :; 0 c.. 7 4, ·"·•t··, .l ~ ., -r U,.ul..!.. ,.,,~..'.J son ,/• a•.!.\,.., were bro1.:(;ht to testifyo l:b:., il7,lrunsll2., conceded t:.:o..t there i'lc',S some wcclmcss on tho p8.I't of tho yrosocv:t ion 011 t?.:::..t., .Ad.Di tt0dlyJ1 tho 2,ppolln.nt did not cell t:10 02.id Aa_o.,m K.1.maka -Ho be i,.is 1n.tno;s but th~n we frould be cxpoctinc him to p:i:ovo his 6 innooo:.100. l)J'.'ODC'Ol:.i ioi1., oooonc. :;r-01.md f I J:JsT:cs:: OJI ~2P::7.:'.L r--·------·---~-- .. -