19900616 TZCA Mwanza5

.,,.-. ........ ___ .... . -:;---- ..,. ,...,.,... ..... ..... ... -.· ---------·-- - ...--- DT TDE COURT OF l:i.P:PTI!i.::~ OF T!:2:TZ.:l.i:rIA .AT E~-L.'QTZA. CRilUJT/U, APPEAL lTO~ · 147 OF 1989 NICI-1'\EL KIZINGO,, o ,, " .. o .iPP::::::I.,L..\:l'TT VERSUS T:83 IWlIDLIC., • • • 6 O ~ II TISPOliJDNJT ( ..ippeo,l fron tl:o oonv:j.ct ion of tJ.10 Iligh Court of Tc,n~~nia et '.Ihbo:ro,) da,tocl tho 31st clc,;y of Aug,.wt, 1989 in JUDG::l:r-CTNT OF TIIill COURT Tho np?ollc.nt, MIC'Il•iEL ro:z:c.mo, w2.? convicted of tl:i.c uurder of MEL."::;SLmA T;L'JCELDKO r.nc1 11"2,S sontc11ccc1. by KOROSso, J IJ to suff0r c1cntho ITa now c,ppoo.J.s bcfor0 1.,~so The o.ppo,llo.nt'. was roprcsontocl b;:,r } ro J3UT::J'.D.•'.L.'l. 7 1 .. letl.I'nod cotmsol, c.no. Mr. l'.ITJTjICI, lcc,med Sonier State Attorney, rc:p:::-oscntcd the_ Rcpu1)lio/D.espondc.nt(t Before Mra Dutanbal[', 0i..1bm-kcd on hhi crounds of 2-p:,yJal his o.ttontion · · l'ms drm-m by tho cow.·t to 2.l1 onission o,ppn.r,mt fro □ tho :rcco1·d end was required to acLlross the ooiirt . on th,1,t fir;:,·;:,o I F.rom the poruso.J. of t~10 i•coorcl it o.r,poac th,.....,t o.,t t:~o start of tho hoo.ring two nssosoors wore solcctocl e.."'ld t~10ir rolos oxpl[!.inod to then., T.'.1oroa.ftor it docs not soon tl:-r,t 2 tho nosossors wo::.,o givon tl:o o::_1yo:..,t1..mity to :po..rtici:;.:12.to in t:'.10 prococclings 1'.>~r :putting g_uostiono to tho wi tnosrios., Tho lc&--nocl trioJ. judge oloc.rly showocl in tho :r8corcl ,;rhon there .-ms o:::r:,n:iilo,tion- ~n-ohiof 9 o:coss-o::~2,r:d;_1£'..tion, ro-o::.:1.1fa!2-tion ond CJ::o....-1indion of the 1 .-ritncsso □ by tho court o If tI10:ro 1-rr.\s no ro-oxc,.-:iinc.,t ion :10 olo2,I'ly indicatocl uith tho word "HIV' 2,0 on J?%'0 7 of tho t;ypo-11:ritton record, for instc.ncc. Thran 1ri.1orc tho oow:t did not oxo.nino v. witness tho uorcl 11:Hil, 11 n.ppoc.rccl o.s on :i?v,gc 120 T!--.,o oDission to nontion tho c.ssosso1~s oi thm.' ar; o:mui;.1in 5 or not o:r,..:-~:1inin 0 a, wi tncss is con~picuous tl-.1J:ot1(:;-l1out t>.o 0~1tiro rccorcl. This could. Hro Th..1tcmbnla su11::1i ttoc. tho,t C!.ll tricls in t:.10 =:i(;-1 Court e.ro with tho o,icl.. of assossoro pOD O•Jotion 265 of t],c Crininal Procedure Act, 19850 Ib wQ:1t f1..1rl:.1cr to or.,~r t'.:i..:'.,t :L."l ,!vlubu.z;yn BitUF~..Jb. J!98iJ T~L.n,. 264 this Court vitk-tccl t:lc entire :proceedings l1occ..uso c j1..irlgc :fo,ilccl.. to direct c..sG08oo:'s on tho isouo of 11:rovoca.t:iono. Jio contonclocl t~-,_z,,t tb.o i::muo in tho prc~ont c..1)pocl is oven narc so:r.·io1.1. o~ Tio pro,;yccl tl.:o..t t~10 of .IUpI.ionco_ P:.:tDort v. R~_ C1."tni11nl .-'l.p:;_)Cnl no .. 27 of 1979,. In on o. vi to.l j1oint, suol,. [',G p7.'ovoc;'..tion 1 thon tho trii:iJ.. j'udco Tho Coux.t o:f J.ppoc.l in JC'ulingo, ancl Others v. Ilo [l9!lJ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 /3 11 T~'.co opinions of c,u,;c::rno::.}:J 02.1.1 110 of g:;_•c2.t v--o.luc nnd C',Ssistrn1cc to o, t:dc,l j'L'!Clgc, l)ut only if tlloy ftu.ly 1mdC:!.'St0ncl t!.10 f.:-,cts of tho 02,nc before t:1.cD " •• 11' Uc acld t~1.C.,t one of tl:.o m.',ys in u>.ic!!. t~"!..J o..ssossors 02,n f1..D.J.;y their value c.m:. o.,ssistc,,nc·oo If r1foc7-i:.:oction o:r non-cliroctio11 of tho o.s::::cssors vi tio.tcs :proccoc1.:i.;:1sn t]:011 not c,llowin.g ,:.i,s:::ooso:i.'s to o::cc,nino w:i. tnosoos doos even r:101·0 so. ~To tl1oroforo qu.D,sh tl:o ~1:;:-oco'cc'_ings 9 sot 2,sido tho sontonco 2.ncl ardor rct:d.'."'-1 o t!; ' . . . ... ~ # 0' I "'·........ •' , / 1''i' L .. l:.o Tt:•.K..'JYiJJ \ '--.4 - :i~ ~ I .,:J, /~,. .i ::-. Jc.- ( So S~ K.(IJ.:'i.Gj- )