19900313 TZCA Arusha7

·~ •r-,;. ~ ,.,_ ~-:l·' - ' ' ,....,'.: ;,., .... :~-- . .. f)./ :,-.-·. ,. . . . ·~~ :lo • ·, --~~' IN TBE COUB.T OF APPEAL O:F UiIZJdiIA AT ARUSHA KisAimA, J .A • , oUAR, J .A. • And 1mzAvAs, J ~A.) CRIL"INA.L C,l'Eil, no. H~9 OF 1989 RASEIDI SA.1..DI@ JULIA IDDI. :- . ~>-:~, _·: ,: ·:· ' '• :' THE R.l!!l. UBl:,IO • • • ''.-~•~::, . •' . (Appeal from the lonvio tio11 of the .'! Hiah Court of Ta..c.za..nia at Aruaha ) , (Munuo, J .) dated the 21st day of Deoelllber, 1988 iD. Criminal Sessions Case ITo. 39 ~f 1987 ' JUDGMENT OF THE COURT The appellant was charged with and oonviotea of murder .. -1•. ( .:o·oatrary 1 to aaotio.n 19f. 01' the Penal Code. . :)~ ~~-\\ · · ;;:'a,, · --~ prosecution evidence is to the effeot that on l~/3/83 ., \~ •' .•:i,(~: · . P .W .l. of 'Makoa lN.llage, i.r. UAcht;IJne; H.a:i Dietriqt was at. the .-.. ~'.j~~ :• · : .•. , , -. - ... . ,., - . ,.:. \ ..v.i ;:.: , .. --~. ,. ~-. -,.·:tt.,1 -(;; ho.me of her ei.i;tf! ,-.:Jalima Salum. '.Eu.a.house was aear BD,MO . ;,.:'<:tJ. •'. ·:1,. : (Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre.) and Asha the. deceased ·~'\f ,· . was also residi.n& ill this houae: · At 3 9.111. that day ·the appellant /: we.c.t to this ho·u.se a.Jld asked hiE;J girl friend As.ha to ta.J{e her for a drink. Asha refused where~pon the appellant 1.breate.aaa her with dire consequences sayi.ag that if 1,here was someone who .·' was putting her ill this position of beil:18 difficult then both that .person and he him.self ware going to lose her. In t:h.o. , . ~ve.ain8 of the same day at abollt 8 p.B. the appall.ant returned ·1':I:·-·'.t/ :t,. '· . ,,';·,..~: icco.m.panied by two women Christina and It.~. :rt was e. bright e • • ./2 ,;. ,..,•. ~ . :· • . ' ◄ --:-". ' - ~~ ... ... • ,,. ~ •. .. .. (' "' '.. .. • ~ •1,: ' ; ' ....,,. 2 .·- ' ~ ~ ' """'- - ~ .. .;. ' , ..., ', '. ~. • • ' f ''P ,J· JiloOJllj.tl l:light~ .and o..r J.aaip was bural·ng .:Losiq.e the. ,liafu,8.. ·~ae, . ~. ~ -~ ~ i;lu-ea pec>pln who .a;rrived .!=1-t Ash.a,' s ;r,ea¥!cuiQe ... - :::.: ' ... • ... , .. •• A ___.,,_ , ; . . . al.l· 'sJoai· p.ear- ~ . the. d.oOr'. ~Asha \'7&a serv'ing food to' tho cbil.dre#~. ·.. . ·,~ . .. Asha ~en woot out of tl:>.G ho~() :to the next w:iuso· to bring;. ·so~p~_ . . ~- Sud.d.enly. Aslia 1a ory•":Qf. 0.iO.D.Y W8.S ,.h.oa.N, from. OUtfi'i-Q.'&''.aodi ;.~1.1 :~. .' -~- ,. ,"\,~ .!)rio ~Fe.tum&' went out OLl.lT to· iae:~eiU3- b.ieaD.ins, - . prof~~ frol'l 'f:l'ta.b wollllds and the appolla.il.t, 'Chril}tiiili 8Jld . '• • ' " ,j· Karia fu>ldine .b..J:r· but a.U ran a.way whc.n l:Iadija e.h:d Fa.twna apl)ea.rod b ~ , : :»-~. . "· ;.11.~ Z~itwd. !~ban, a .nf.ti.BAbo~ ot th.o ~Q.easod · :· .;_, ~-~ ' - . '~- '- . ' . ' · ~~ '~tat~d···t~t ~n,-:tho·~~~orial. a.a_'i .q,:ab·o"U:t. 6i'.'pt~~ t, · - .. • • ,1,..,_,"';./'. # ••• .. • ... · • . _. . . -~- -~ • ., __... .-...:..,. .• ..... Sbo w~s . at the shQ.O ma_kors sho_p. at ~1,10 whon A.~S:.E!-.P.PGUQd . '• .. ..... • .... .,.. •• . f' • ~• , .-If .... I ,"i • . thor.e. 'Asha ,Wt.fl a ~~ho~l mate of JlcrI?. ' ...... • .. '. I"- ' . ~ . ~-011 Ohriat~ a.nd .,r~ ~ .... ~:... -. +- - . ·~ :·.;""_--.. : : ; - • ' • .,. ........ i-,,,-: -- th_o &p,Pel~t 0.~P~-~4r _'.~.t. the aa.me, sh.op and Chri'.stina. ~·.--•---.,. .. · ... _~ .• _,,6.,t;_~= ....... ·\ ... ·-~~ ., .. "'. ,r't,-.,..,..... _-r , a,r.oete9-•'•h'.a~ b·u.t.'!'Jiot" Asha;- thon As.ha a.o.a:-·za~tu.ni a.e£1; t'o~ethcD 1 •. ~ ~- - ·, ~ ~ ,·"'If':·. ~·• . . · ~ ,:: r .• • ... ~'! -. •: - • • •... • • . .J ..__ - • • • , .-ii to· their l'e8}?C01;iv;e '.q.OL!lGS Whicl;J.. :W~O ½: kal. ;tl._p8.I't j r '.Qlµ-isti:na and· ~ appo~i ;.al~~~"i~t. ... ., . ~t-~~: , ~hr.Ls~~ ~~t,,to .. tho . ho.uso 61. .Za.i,'tu.Qj. -~- 1to'U:Q.d· .Asha. thoro., :.µaha. biid,..gone· to ooll.oct: . 11e;r'' ~lo~ frOlll Zai twli~l . . . Whan .A:s.ba ~ ro:tt she to.oj: e. sho:r:t . ~ut: ~ .her bo111o wlif:Co ·Cbristtila. ·e:o.d tho e.ppelJ.an~ took tho _ma.i.n. .re>e.d wllich. alio lod to Asha' s hQ.mQ.; About' 8 p .in.. w.bilo . j t l, .f . J ,\- J ' r • • ;, •• •' ,,'Ji, ,~ ••' ' :-'' ;' .\ ·•··' _<_ • ,, . ~ ...:._jo.:.;----:..;..~:.:- -~ . . . ~:· ~-,., :·:•, .~~/ ·:~~•./~.;\, .. r, ., ', . .- ,"I ' 'I.•• r .. . •·-► _Tlio lipl)~~).:l.."'..ntt s dofGhoo mi.a Olli.. o.:· -:-.1.il:ii. ... lio ~ f - 3 said b.D r~ ~~ iD, l).,.bt. J.ll:" 1983, Ha M.ci. ttod. ·:;~~ :; ho kn.Ow ~ • . tho • aell~a-oe:;: ab4· iWa.s·''W3od to viai ti.cg hor .:.iai,i.so as her fii·Gtl4 .~ .. _·:r~ • ,\:.. •~ ::.::·"'9-·• :. ~ •. ~ ~ - , . - . . ,, .. -~'\ - ·b\l~--:wa$ ..iio_t· aroWljl •O.ll •,tho do.y .ejl~ was kill.od ;- '.HG ,•dem:Gd r • -t..,.~• '"":":• ~ l • .-~~. ~ l:;, ~;.~, : ~.,. t,~• •• ~ • " • ; •~/ -• ,_ "', .>'lJ" •'• ~ •• .,. ~• ,. r-o" .... ~:~~·,Ze.J~~/{t~~i.ng. eoo.o. a-t isba~a hou_e.o.:_~¥1,~~ tbD.t..,.fatot'l,11, e;.~-/t'- · ·. - ',: ....:. "~_. ;'? i½'~-:. -",..,.':·, :;~· ~·: -.. -7. ; · _ :" -. _; -.- '. ·~- ·_ . .,. ... · . · · ·.-· ~~o .ica.rLl.'od.· trial~ judgo -ba<; fl..O ·hcs:j. ta.tion-ip:;bqlio~, - : ) ~; • ~ • },i, • • .. • ~ .~ ' .. ~ - ·~ .... t' ~ ' • ' ~ t"" " ~ ... . ! ~ ' "" -: ~-.;J ~ ~ -• ... :-;· ~ '!""-\ f.' """ ~ . -~ ~ ~ .,..,,__ ~"'! .f 6_:.. ~-- -~~~;o~o~uti~: ~t~t~~~~-s ·o!1 their ~i~Cllti:fi;-~7_16n ~-·:11e, ..... ' ·•-1:' ,.· ' , .... -~ • l;:'- - .. ~polJ.c.nt· aa .t.tm,.-_killo{ ~ J.sha;,. _Ho rc.joctoa.~rtho a.li:b~-.:- .. . '·'.. - . _' ' 7. ;_ .-.. -- ··• ·. ·_ ~- ..~ . 't:·:-,J • ,, ·.. ~1f'-tho ap~oi~nt ,cis 1witruthfut,1ma,;so .oo'.tiv1.ctocl.h:i;fu. 0 . " ,. , . .f, ....!. ~ - " - ♦ - • ·: .w ...- .. "T ., : w : ti, .~ ~. • •· ..- ·•. . ' ~ l • . . . . ,- ~:.. • ~ £ • . • ~T ' ·• "Ill,• ,__ . - - ,. • ~ ' . --., . ..- . 14r. 'L,yo.sUl.&a . .- -~ho - loar.n9d · Oo~Gl 'for- _tlie- ti1>p~t . ,. . - . . \.~ . ' . pQitl.tod .wt t.rur.!t:t;? ..TJ .;l wa& .c.ot o-onot~.-eoa_ lJi her· • ' ,. ~ • - • " • 4 ♦ •• I 0- • 'i.dantifi.oat;;cm.o~ ' - tho' ~ppolJ.lUlt. Be ~c.id ab.0 · • tEb .. a.~po.111 f1.pt tw~~ tMt· :ma to:dAL dc.y ·a:od ·,~ci-Qfo~·. it. would .:. .}._-'>- . t ~ . ' . JiavG :\')9QA. .F0¢1i-~,i~9Lltitic.o.ti0ll ot· -'i;hc. e.pptyHe,nt was _,. ·r .:.d~jrv.if 4-.. ,..-. t~o~ {izJ.Liiiti~~~1~-.~o;; -~~{¢t£:r.:_waa·. ~ ~ it' - .· •'- ) • r:_.._, • • " ~ -' , ~' " ~ .... - 1 • ~ ~... ~.., ~ -:".°3! -i.. · U I' l •"' - - . ., ~ • .. t ,~ 't;!: -o··. '.· .:-~;r,gjo~t- r -"' r ., · • ..,.....-- .... - -:,a, -....~ ' ... . ....;3; ·,dd)lY- t..~~ica:['.n6d~ ·1· -. "' tl"i~l~ji1~p;~~~;iio: 'B:6~~ :r~a,i{oli~ ..;- ~ :t'. ~ '~- ,JI, ·i-f' ...... • . . ~ -~ ... .,. •. ,::tr • .' ·,_ . . -) . --~ -, :-:;--l:...~. -.~ -. ..• - . . ..t~. . . -· ,c :,,~ .t -: ·,:,_.~,.-ti~ ~ '-t"• ./ ~:·, ~~r- •.- " 11->i"._: at··al,l," ho _coil"t;pn.c1.od •., . : , .... ,·' t>:-: '\ '1,. -.,. : ._ """' --;. • . ' -::-~ . • _. . '\-. ~ '~ ; - ... ....:'f'i . ' . . .... •"'"' . ' " ,.. }., - '' .__;,... J. / .,_ "'. • ~"' _.l·•lf.. ~ ,. \._-. . ~ .• l •f-~ .. ,,.. - ~ ,__"l· ~'"J.-.' .-,'\. ,. ,, • ~ ! ~ ., .. r ~ .ot- ·._ . . . . • )._. ·• ,.f ._ · • :-.,. .. ,.... .., • .._.__ 1.~ - -....'"'\ .. , .,,,. ..,,. _,. ~ ·\ , . . 'lt is · a'omPWlla t turisat:i:i~a.c.to~y ·t.no:t Ffl,tuau::;. wlip· ·.wci.~ ec.ia. t .. t"~·l,:._.,,_•~-.~~::.' •.~~•:<#'"• <,<t·"', -~: -,,.··~-:.·~I_::.:~' • '& t' ~\,.,,~ - ...,.. ., \ ~~~ h;l,vo--:1»_oop. ·-~~!~°!1--\.~ t_. ~h~, -.~Qua·o:1?~ :Jio a.o~,.OQ.ti~w'w~.a ·.c.ot. .~-~ o.a:,prs~oo~~i~~.:.~ ~os:s:. to' coi:.r~~ro.:tf p~?.~i liardiJO.t, ...~ ~ ... , , .._,f ■ -1-,; J$a~9;a: - ;,.. -~-- • ~, ,.._ -~"\."' ~~# 'oii>~ti?!l~••fi.as~:~von.~, ·-zt:1~v.~s;Jcai:tod. ~ ~ ~ '1...... '•• j ,, • T • • ,,. • ' <- ~1.to ·say. thf.t·;~::~w~~,~ ckae~;and..iRPdnant-- .._-. . . . --- h --;t, v:·: ~ ~ j ':· ;_ #'.&otbP\',' aho~--_b¢f,or~'t".b.'o ld.J ;'1 ~-f; - ·' ~• ~"".: •.. .;.i,•·;).~l}·_,l~:•\ •l_ ;f • .:. ' - . ' ..-' . A1l m· nu.,~ ·wp ~e· loft 1A oo c.ciu.bt tha~ tli:o -lci:l:li DB ;:: • htipp0r100: 6$ · ·ffd~~~ ·b.Y lfadi~a.. ~4 doa'oasod was· :iico.e .•, -~. ~ -~> l, -i. , .;..,,.,, ,,( ., ·, , ·.. \"~f.(';: ,,, . .. ,.., by tho 'ap_pall2.nt, an~ ti~l:~~-'::°:Pigb.l?.~rs. ~~~<- ~;.~t~i..P-i': ·;-~-:: mo.ntionod the lovei rcJ.a.tioJ:lship botwoCJ.1 tho appe~t. ~d.;:~~~; · c. • ·, ··-~ • · ' - ~...- ~ •• / . - • .' -~7'- ,,"'\:,)· -the docoa.aod. Tllo e.lib1 .of the app~ll,Ant . . '. ml}£~LPD dou.bt; .. , . JUSTICE OF il'TEL~L -~ ' ·~;) ·.\ . :.J§; -:-~ ' •. ~ " ◄ • >· ·'\4111•' ;~ --:··· •:._.-··.• ..~;:- ·.--. •·. t:v.·. u: ::, . .->p,:-u,~f'~,;-, ,., .. • .. . •• .,,..· ,_ Ne S l"" 1 . • ,• ~11.1.6. ~ 1" 1 v.· ·S ....:-'• .,: ~..1:r_ ;c...:. '. -~-.;;;;t~ii,,.·. ·'""· ·, :..:.;;:_¢ ' ·{/.,,.. 0,; , . .. .,. 1·· . .., -. . ':.--;.:•:':';/ . STICE OF. JJ..1 • ..... '· . ,. J.tti I~..:.. --. . . :. -, , . . . ... :. ·:> .---:....- ~ ..1.i'._,_~~~ ·.: - !-: ·.- . '•.,.' -~,1-: ..•. ~ 't: ·~/ •~,. ·. -=-h ~~-- . . ~:..i~.~~ ~-. _.... \l\c: 1,t: ......• _c ; . ( J-. -·2.. · 0 · .- SEiiI01 DEroTY REGIS · • -r:·,. ..!: ·.\ .• -;-r•- ~½?~ ·-